9 ms·
An appeal for unremarkable women
- patrickgzill 17y agoMy sister was just about the only woman in her engineering classes at Cornell. She was hired in the 70s (and continued doing consulting through the 90s) by a designer of nuclear reactors doing programming, since she could understand both the engineering side (steam valves etc) and the programming side - she helped program the nuclear reactor control room simulator using Fortran. Yet now she is a professor at a well-known university. The hours are easier, pay is as good or better, excellent benefits. Given that, why beg women to join in something that doesn't pay as well and expects you to slave away during weekends and holidays when there is a crunch? (edited to add: I think part of it may be that men (speaking generally) are more in love with the works of their hands, even if it doesn't benefit them directly; they can have pride in it years later. I am not sure that women necessarily have the same attitude towards material objects.)
- jgrahamc 17y agoGiven that, why beg women to join in something that doesn't pay as well and expects you to slave away during weekends and holidays when there is a crunch? Why rule out half the population?
- aswanson 17y agoIf it's a bad decision we should rule out as many as possible from making it.
- Tichy 17y agoYou mean women typically have the choice between becoming programmers and professors at well-known universities? Or in general, they don't become programmers because other jobs they opt for pay better? "I am not sure that women necessarily have the same attitude towards material objects" I suspect 90% of offerings on Etsy.com are from women? Haven't looked it up, but I am pretty sure it is a large fraction.
- cpr 17y agoPerhaps more women than men have the (good) instinct that making concrete things with your hands is better than making abstract things in your mind?
- Tichy 17y agoBetter in what way?
- Qz 17y ago"I am not sure that women necessarily have the same attitude towards material objects" This is one of those self-perpetuating falsehoods that people only say because they heard it somewhere else (which I guess I am now complicit in).
- aohtsab 17y ago> I am not sure that women necessarily have the same attitude towards material objects. Then clearly you haven't talked to enough women. Also, if you believe the only allure of programming is a poorly-paying job and terrible hours, then there are larger problems afoot.
- lutorm 17y agoFunny, Philip Greenspun has exactly the opposite take from you: http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science
- davidw 17y agoI don't know... these debates seem to go round and round, and at the end of the day, I grow weary of them. My resolve is to do what is in my power to help out other people, be they men or women, who are interested in learning something about programming and maybe need a leg up, and not to discriminate or make the work environment uncomfortable in any other way. Beyond that, though, I don't think I can do much more, and it doesn't seem a good use of my time wondering what a very generic "we" can do to change the status quo.
- timr 17y agoThey don't tend to go "round and round", really -- what usually happens is that someone posts something that points out the obvious inequality in our industry, wonders what to do about it, and the top-rated response is from someone who is "tired" of the conversation (because we've clearly exhausted all the options, naturally!) At least we're consistent. I have very little patience for people who are tired of the conversation that we never seem to have. There are no women in this industry. It's unnatural, it's stifling, and it's a problem. And I think it's a situation where the wolf is guarding the hen-house -- the chickens keep disappearing, but nobody knows why! Whatever could it be? One thing I've noticed amongst my female friends is that while they might get interviews, they tend to be rejected at a much higher rate than equally qualified male applicants. Given how completely idiotic and machismo-driven the interview process is at most tech companies, it wouldn't surprise me at all to find out that this is an industry-wide phenomenon. Do I know this is a problem? No. But like most other latent sources of bias, we'll never know if we stick our heads in the sand every time the subject is raised.
- JoeAltmaier 17y agoPerhaps you are simply younger and haven't been around as often. I am 50; I have staffed-up multiple teams in the last 30 years; I have never managed to get many female applicants much less hire them. I've solicited the local SWE (Society of Women Engineers) chapter head; I don't even get a response. I've contacted my sparse set of women colleagues from the past; never any interest in changing jobs. Maybe its just me; but I to am tired of beating my head against the wall.
- gcv 17y agoPhilip Greenspun wrote a good essay on the subject. http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science
- stcredzero 17y agoFrom Greenspun's article: Having been both a student and teacher at MIT, my personal explanation for men going into science is the following: - young men strive to achieve high status among their peer group - men tend to lack perspective and are unable to step back and ask the question "is this peer group worth impressing?" Though, I would say that the ability to impress a peer group is often strongly correlated with the ability to attract mates. Hence, we have an evolutionary weakness for wanting to impress our peers. Unfortunately, there are peer groups whose impression is negatively correlated with attracting mates.
- jgrahamc 17y agoOh yeah. Totally. Being a science nerd at high school made me real popular with my peers.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI think it's pretty clear that being a science nerd did make you popular with your peers: http://www.jgc.org/blog/2010/01/how-i-got-50000-page-views-by-simply.html http://www.jgc.org/blog/2010/01/how-i-got-50000-page-views-b... Greenspun's claim is that you probably overvalue this popularity, whereas women disproportionately would not.
- jgrahamc 17y agoBut those people weren't my peers at the time.
- krakensden 17y ago> men tend to lack perspective and are unable to step back and ask the question "is this peer group worth impressing?" That's not just a male problem, it's just a different set of peer groups.
- patio11 17y agoAn anecdote, make of it what you will: There are more female systems engineers at in my row of cubicles in Japan than there were in my university (WashU). (And most of my female classmates at WashU were either Korean, Chinese, or Taiwanese -- as in, by passport, not by ethnicity.)
- CWuestefeld 17y agoOne more data point: The team I manage has 9 people, 5 of whom are female. This was purely chance, I'd swear that no preference was given based on any particular demographics. One thing that makes this difficult is that this year and each of the previous two, I've been one developer short for a significant period due to maternity leave. Add to this the extended vacations (2-3 weeks) that developers who immigrated (from China and India) take to visit family, and it becomes clear that having a diverse team makes scheduling our work quite a challenge.
- patio11 17y agoYou apparently share something in common with my boss, and I share something in common with your employees. A conversation that I've wanted to have a few times with my boss: Boss, I understand that you think me taking two weeks off at Christmas is difficult to schedule. If I can direct you to the calendar, boss, you will see that Christmas is clearly marked on it in red ink. You see, it happens at the same time of year... every year. Sort of like, I don't know, Chinese New Year, Divali, etc etc. As you might recall, I was gone last year, and the year before, too, always at roughly the same time. You might remember that in those years, too, I sent you emails six months and six weeks in advance. You might also recall that, when you asked me if there was anything I wanted added to my employment contract at our first meeting two and a half years ago, I said "Yes, I want it explicitly understood that I return home for two weeks every year at Christmas." So now it is three days before my annual vacation, the one time per year that I see my family, and you believe you have discovered an urgent problem in the schedule... to whit, that you have scheduled a project such that it cannot possibly be completed without my presence these next two weeks. Ah hah. Well, best of luck with that. I'll see you in the New Year.
- toisanji 17y agoMy cofounder is a female with a PhD in computer science.
- JoeAltmaier 17y agoMy niece entered Iowa State and resided on an all-women floor of the dormitory. A good mix of freshman majors, medical and engineering and so on. By the time she graduated, she was the ONLY technical major left (biomed). All the other women had switched to journalism or Phys Ed etc. Why?