7 ms·
How climate change is rapidly taking the planet apart
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jwatte 10y ago3.5C by 2035? That's, like, 20 years away. Plenty of time for the Mars mission, because surely we can't solve our own problems here on earth. What will it take to get to revolution and revolt?
- throwaway136373 10y agoOne strategy would be to keep making up bigger and bigger claims, trying to scare people into action.
- enraged_camel 10y agoI love all you silly people who make alt accounts just to post unpopular comments. Like, what are you so afraid of? It's just karma.
- throwaway136373 10y agoDon't care about karma, I care about my career. I've seen several careers short circuited because they didn't tow the complete liberal orthodox line. Welcome to SF.
- colemickens 10y ago"science agreed upon by a majority of scientists including more than two 9s" == "liberal orthodox line". I'm sure you have far better research, data and analytical ability than NASA and virtually every other scientific outfit on the planet.
- throwaway136373 10y agoAnd scientists are never ever wrong in their predictions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- theseadroid 10y agoAnd doctors are never ever wrong in their diagnosis. Or don't they? But you still go to doctors instead of diagnose yourself?
- eagsalazar2 10y agoNo one is saying that but at least, unlike you, scientists have attempted to make a case (as have several other people on this thread). I'm inclined to go with the people who've studied this subject, made arguments, were peer reviewed at least by each other, even with the reality of their human failings and biases.
- jwatte 10y agoDoes there exist, in your mind, any data that would make you think global warming is real and imminent? If so, what would that data look like?
- yongjik 10y agoNah, it's just that people generally don't like to work with someone who claims "Scientists are wrong," and when asked how he/she knows it, answers "Well, they've been wrong before!" Because who wants to argue with such a person in a design meeting?
- eagsalazar2 10y agoYou know you keep whining that it is just liberal orthodoxy and that you will be persecuted if you speak the truth but you should observe that you are the only one throwing insults and generalizations around in this conversation. Several people have made reasoned rebuttals to comments like this one and yet only you are saying "ooh poor me, liberal witch trials!".
- jwatte 10y agoSo, first, it's "toe the line," and second, toeing the line means stretching outside the defined limit. You may want to edit your post to make a coherent statement.
- greenyoda 10y agoNo, it means staying inside a defined limit (i.e., standing behind the metaphorical line): "Toe the line" is an idiomatic expression meaning ... to conform to a rule or standard ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line
- qpwoeirutyzzzz 10y agoAll my accounts are throw-away accounts, I have no interest in maintaining some persistent identity on HN.
- revscat 10y agoThis isn't "made up." It's a fact. Burning your head in the sand only dooms you and yours.
- throwaway136373 10y agoPredictions aren't facts.
- ori_b 10y agoHottest 7 months on record, by the largest margin on record, is not a prediction. It is a fact.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- function_seven 10y agoNo, facts are facts. And the fact is that every prediction that has been made has underestimated the coming change. If I predict the DJIA will rise 50 pts every day next week, and it really goes up 100 pts, am I wrong? Sure, but not the way you think.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Snargorf 10y agoYou seem to have it backwards, predictions that have been made have consistently overestimated climate change. Typically the real temperature change is at or below the bottom of their ranges. This is the "global warming pause" that they didn't predict and rushed to explain as unimportant. Don't you remember back 10-12 years ago when the ice caps were supposed to be almost gone by now? Haven't you noticed that no cities have actually been affected by any sea level change - that nothing has actually happened?
- jwatte 10y agoHave you read the linked research? Do you have a better explanation for the data? By all means, let us know!
- theseadroid 10y agoThere is a post on reddit that address people like you. I'll post the link at the bottom but in the same time I'd like to read it again and quote it in full here: Throwaway for a real scientist here. I'd make my name, research area, and organization openly available, but the fact of the matter is that I don't like getting death threats. I'm a perpetual lurker, but I'm tired of looking through the nonsense that gets posted by a subset of the community on these types of posts. It's extremely predictable. Ten years ago, you were telling us that the climate wasn't changing. Five years ago, you were telling us that climate change wasn't anthropogenic in origin. Now, you're telling us that anthropogenic climate change might be real, but it's certainly not a bad thing. I'm pretty sure that five years from now you'll be admitting it's a bad thing, but saying that you have no obligation to mitigate the effects. You know why you're changing your story so often? It's because you guys are armchair quarterbacks scientists. You took some science classes in high school twenty years ago and you're pretty sure it must be mostly the same now. I mean, chemical reactions follow static laws and stuff, or something, right? Okay, you're rusty, but you read a few dozen blog posts each year. Maybe a book or two if you're feeling motivated. Certainly, you listen to the radio and that's plenty good enough. I'm sorry, but it's needs to be said: you're full of it. I'm at the Ocean Sciences Meeting in Honolulu, sponsored by ASLO, TOS, and AGU. I was just at a tutorial session on the IPCC AR5 report a few days ago. The most recent IPCC report was prepared by ~300 scientists with the help of ~50 editors. These people reviewed over 9000 climate change articles to prepare their report, and their report received over 50,000 comments to improve it's quality and accuracy. I know you'll jump all over me for guesstimating these numbers, but I'm not going to waste more of my time looking it up. You can find the exact numbers if you really want them, and I know you argue just to be contrary. Let's be honest here. These climate change scientists do climate science for a living. Surprise! Articles. Presentations. Workshops. Conferences. Staying late for science. Working on the weekends for science. All of those crappy holidays like Presidents' Day? The ones you look forward to for that day off of work? Those aren't holidays. Those are the days when the undergrads stay home and the scientists can work without distractions. Now take a second before you drop your knowledge bomb on this page and remind me again... What's your day job? When was the last time you read through an entire scholarly article on climate change? How many climate change journals can you name? How many conferences have you attended? Have you ever had coffee or a beer with a group of colleagues who study climate change? Are you sick of these inane questions yet? I'm a scientist that studies how ecological systems respond to climate change. I would never presume to tell a climate scientist that their models are crap. I just don't have the depth of knowledge to critically assess their work and point out their flaws. And that's fair, because they don't have the depth of knowledge in my area to point out my flaws. Yet, here we are, with deniers and apologists with orders of magnitude less scientific expertise, attempting to argue about climate change. I mean, there's so much nonsense here just from the ecology side of things: User /u/nixonrichard writes: Using the word "degradation" implies a value judgement on the condition of an environment. Is there any scientific proof that the existence of a mountaintop is superior to the absence of a mountain top? Your comment and sentiment smacks of naturalistic preference which is a value judgement on your part, and not any fundamental scientific principle. You know, like /u/nixonrichard thinks that's a profound thought or something. But it's nonsense, because there are scientists who do exactly that. Search "mountain ecosystem services" on Google Scholar and that won't even be the tip of the iceberg. Search "ecosystem services" if you want more of the iceberg. It's like /u/nixonrichard doesn't know that people study mountain ecosystems... or how to value ecosystems... or how to balance environmental and economic concerns... Yet, here /u/nixonrichard is, arguing about climate change. Another example. Look at /u/el__duderino with this pearl of wisdom: Climate change isn't inherently degradation. It is change. Change hurts some species, helps others, and over time creates new species. Again, someone who knows just enough about the climate debate to say something vaguely intelligent-sounding, but not enough to actually say something useful. One could search for review papers on the effects of climate change on ecological systems via Google Scholar, but it would be hard work actually reading one. TLDRs: 1) rapid environmental change hurts most species and that's why biodiversity is crashing; 2) rapid environmental change helps some species, but I didn't know you liked toxic algal blooms that much; 3) evolution can occur on rapid timescales, but it'll take millions of years for meaningful speciation to replace what we're losing in a matter of decades. But you know, I really pity people like /u/nixonrichard and /u/el__duderino. It must be hard taking your car to 100 mechanics before you get to one that tells you your brakes are working just fine. It must be hard going to 100 doctors before you find the one that tells you your cholesterol level is healthy. No, I'm just kidding. People like /u/nixonrichard and /u/el__duderino treat scientific disciplines as one of the few occupations where an advanced degree, decades of training, mathematical and statistical expertise, and terabytes of data are equivalent with a passing familiarity with right-wing or industry talking points. I'd like to leave you with two final thoughts. First, I know that many in this community are going to think, "okay, you might be right, but why do you need to be such an about it?" This isn't about intellectual elitism. This isn't about silencing dissent. This is about being fed up. The human race is on a long road trip and the deniers and apologists are the backseat drivers. They don't like how the road trip is going but, rather than help navigating, they're stuck kicking the driver's seat and complaining about how long things are taking. I'd kick them out of the car, but we're all locked in together. The best I can do is give them a whack on the side of the head. Second, I hope that anyone with a sincere interest in learning about climate change continues to ask questions. Asking critical questions is an important part of the learning process and the scientific endeavor and should always be encouraged. Just remember that "do mountaintops provide essential ecosystem services?" is a question and "mountaintop ecosystem services are not a fundamental scientific principle" is a ridiculous and uninformed statement. Questions are good, especially when they're critical. Statements of fact without citations or expertise is intellectual masturbation - just without the intellect. Toodles. I'm going to bed now so that I can listen to, look at, and talk about science for another 12 hours tomorrow. Have fun at the office. original post https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/1z1hyo/two_of_the_worlds_most_prestigious_science/cfpy15c https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/1z1hyo/two_of_the_...
- revscat 10y agoFood shortages.
- trhway 10y agoYep, Arab Spring is just the beginning...
- marcoperaza 10y agoGiven how politicized this has become--anyone who challenges the alarmism is outcast from the field--I think there's good reason to be skeptical of the rapidly escalating predictions of the consequences. I'm not saying climate change isn't happening or that it's not driven by humans, but it's kind of remarkable that 1C over a century has become 3.5C in two decades. And of course, global control of all major industries is always the proposed solution. How about nuclear? It can power the world, it's carbon neutral, and modern reactors are physically incapable of meltdown. It seems to be the obvious solution, but those sounding the alarm over climate change tend to be the same groups that oppose nuclear.
- XorNot 10y agoYes, I too am surprised when new data causes us to have to re-evaluate our predictions. We made a prediction, gosh darnit we should ignore all subsequent observations in refining it!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marcoperaza 10y agoThe point I'm trying to raise is the potential for publication bias. If publishing results that challenge the narrative is a risk to your career, you won't publish it. Meanwhile, the outliers in the other direction, which do fit the narrative, get published and picked up by others in the field. Here's an article echoing my concerns: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/science-news/10837146/Climate-change-science-has-become-blind-to-green-bias.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/science-news/1083714...
- enraged_camel 10y agoAs we collect more data, we are able to make better and more accurate predictions. Welcome to science.
- losteric 10y agoGiven how politicized this has become -- anyone with dire predictions gets outcast from the mainstream news -- I think there's good reason to be even more concerned about the rapidly escalating predictions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- joelg 10y agoSo what can we - the average HN crowd - actually do? Bret Victor's essay on what a technologist can do about climate is a well-reasoned perspective targeted at people in the tech industry, and it's at least a start. What else? http://worrydream.com/#!/ClimateChange http://worrydream.com/#!/ClimateChange
- azeirah 10y agoEven though I admire Bret victor's work very very much, I think we as technologists do not have much an influence over the issue by inventing. Instead, as I myself, and nearly everybody I know is barely aware of the issue at all, we need to make the general public aware of what is taking place through means of media. This has become a political problem, not a technology problem.
- germinalphrase 10y agoTools for making complex systems understandable to people unfamiliar/unpracticed in scientific thinking could be a powerful part of influencing this political problem (which I agree it is).
- henrikschroder 10y agoEveryone knows, noone gives a shit, because most people can't afford to care. It's only a small sliver of humanity - the college-educated upper-middle class of the west - that cares, and even most of them are just socially posturing and not actually caring. What works is the economic argument, the best environmental choice has to become the cheapest one, and that's something technology can do. When solar power is cheaper than coal, coal power plants will shut down very quickly and be replaced by solar power plants. When electric cars are cheaper than ICE cars, noone is going to buy the latter, and vehicle pollution will quickly disappear as well.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jwatte 10y ago
- themartorana 10y agoI knew it was bad, but wow. Makes me rethink having kids. Oops... By the way, this is the kind of talk that makes me want to learn a few little somethings from doomsday preppers, stock up on guns, ammunition, water, and food that doesn't go bad for a century or more, and buy a surplus military subterranean missile silo to turn into a geothermal-supported bunker - because now I have a family, and that shit changes your outlook. And I'm fine being laughed at when nothing happens, but awful happy to be prepared when it does.
- z92 10y agoWhich food doesn't go bad after a decade?
- themartorana 10y agoSpace ice cream? I don't know I haven't done any research yet. Wine for sure. (Might as well be drunk while we're all turning into Morlocks.)
- mod 10y agoHeirloom seeds.
- knweiss 10y agoHoney.
- mynameishere 10y agoPopulation control and nuclear power seem to be two things that are both beneficial in and of themselves, and also helpful against CO2 emissions. What else? Are solar panels a net positive yet? But really, population control is the big one, and it's hard to talk about because, what are you going to do? Western birthrates are already very low. But try to convince a Zambian to not have 9 children... The usual solution is education, but that #1 Takes a generation or two, #2 Is a gamble in the first place, and #3 Goes hand-in-hand with expanded industrial production.
- henrikschroder 10y agoThere's no need to convince anyone of anything, it turns out that improving the quality of life for everyone, especially by providing education, makes birth rates drop dramatically. It's pretty much only sub-saharan african countries that have a birth-rate above 3. Zambia is at 5.59, and was at 7.41 at the most in 1975.
- erik 10y agoPopulation is less of a concern than you might think. At least according to Has Rosling: https://vimeo.com/79878808 https://vimeo.com/79878808 (This is long, but worth watching.) World population is starting to plateau, with the number of children no longer growing. What I take from the video is that the primary concerns are reducing extreme poverty and infant mortality in Africa on one hand, which will result in a reduced birth rate. And on the other hand, moving the most wealthy to technology and lifestyles with lower environmental impact (solar power, electric cars, and I'm not sure what else), so that as the developing world adopts a wealthier lifestyle there is not a proportionate increase in environmental damage.
- marcusjt 10y ago"moving the most wealthy to technology and lifestyles with lower environmental impact" - that's a strategy that's new to me, and initially sounds smart, as I'd certainly rather that rich people had crazy cool low/zero-environmental-impact toys than gas-guzzling ones! However, isn't the net environmental impact of the 1% actually tiny compared to the activities of the 99%? So surely it's widely penetrating / mass adoption of low/zero-environmental-impact technologies by the 99% that will change the world? And of course as George Monbiot said... “(Population is) an important issue…most greens will not discuss. Is this sensitivity or is it cowardice? Perhaps a bit of both.” “…if we accept the UN’s projection that global population will grow by roughly 50 per cent and then stop. This means it will become 50 per cent harder to stop runaway climate change, 50 per cent harder to feed the world, 50 per cent harder to prevent the overuse of resources.” “Even if there were no environmental pressures caused by population growth, we should still support the measures required to tackle it: universal sex education, universal access to contraceptives, better schooling and opportunities for poor women. Stabilising or even reducing the human population would ameliorate almost all environmental impacts.”
- 1_listerine_pls 10y agoWe could pollute the exosphere with reflecting particles. The sun's winds could send these particles away into outer space after some time (which would depend on the average particle mass). The particles could be small enough to be harmless to satellites, yet big enough to last some time. Just an idea.
- taneq 10y agoOne of the best analyses I read of the original Matrix movie (before the sequels came out) was that the whole thing (Matrix, Zion, machines, etc.) was a virtual reality game run by humans to keep us busy until Earth's biosphere recovered from the rodgering we're currently giving it.
- alfon 10y agoWhen my high-functioning aspergers friend was 'deeply concerned' about the ESAS methane some months back, the actual models not taking into account positive feedback loops, and how there was a very high likelihood of us as a species going extinct in a mere decade, and given how much I trust his criteria, I knew something wasn't going well. This article pretty much sums up what he was telling me.
- boneheadmed 10y agoThe sky is falling! Animals exhale CO2 and what has been consuming that for eons? Plants, trees, shrubs of all sorts. Once the so called carbon emission problem is solved everyone will be complaining that there's too much oxygen relative to CO2 and so we need to regulate X, Y, Z so there isn't a catostrophic end to plant life. More leftist gloom and doom designed to guilt us back to the Stone Age. While elites jet around the planet spewing out more fossil fuel emissions than they have hot air.
- jwatte 10y agoSo, you're not a great believer in the scientific method, then?
- NumberCruncher 10y agoI remember the times when we were in danger because the earth could get hit by a meteor. I am still working om my giant laser which will save the earth while you waste your time caring about the climate change. Are you worried about climate in 2100 and raising see level? There won't be any sees 2100! We all get vaporised if I can't finish my giant laser on time. I hear the pigbearman coming.
- jwatte 10y agoI think you have grossly mis-compared the relative strengths of the claims. Does there exist any data that would make you sit up and say "actually, we should probably deal with this now?" If so, what would that data look like?
- rralian 10y agoI actually suspect this is a shill political account. The recent comments are anti-Obama, claim to be a doctor who was harmed by obamacare, argue against evolution and science in general, and basically tow any hot-button political line. It seems suspect to me the only stories worthy of comment on hacker news are the ones where an ignorant right-wing position can be proclaimed. Make no mistake, this is a willfully ignorant comment meant to spread FUD.
- dschiptsov 10y agoWhen climate wasn't changing? The deepest and oldest problem of human species is their over-confident rush to interfere and "fix" vastly complex self-regulating ecosystems they do not fully understand.
- dwaltrip 10y agoWould you rather the earth self-regulate us humans out of existence?
- themartorana 10y agoActually the oldest problem is humans exploiting to ruin the natural resources around them. Sometimes we try to fix that.
- busterarm 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yH3iwybkE-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yH3iwybkE-I
- Houshalter 10y agoWhy was this flagged?
- psynapse 10y agoGood question. Wondering the same thing myself.