7 ms·
TV Loses Grip on Eyes and Ads That Want Them
- Xyik 10y agoNot surprised. There are so many more signals you can mine online vs. offline and so ads are actually way more relevant, not to mention becoming more interactive. See Facebook Dynamic Carousel Ads and Google shopping ads. Not to mention the cost model makes way more sense. Not too familiar with offline advertising, but I assume you pay per second or by average number of viewers for a particular timeframe - not nearly as granular and far as online advertising.
- _Understated_ 10y agoWasn't there an article just the other day about how online advertising is shifting back a bit to TV ads because of ad blockers?
- wccrawford 10y agoThey're in a tailspin. They're trying everything they can to keep doing their same old crap, but people aren't having it. Annoying ads on TV get fast-forwarded or people move to Netflix/Hulu, annoying ads on the internet get ad-blocked. If ad creators would admit that they have a responsibility to be ethical and entertaining for their target audience, they'd have a lot better luck with their campaigns. Instead, they concentrate on trying to have captive audiences and use mind-games to try to get people to view their ads. It's sad, but the more tech-savvy people get, the less it works. They're scrambling.
- superuser2 10y agoAs people become less and less tolerant of things that are obviously ads, the industry will have to become more subtle. Coincidentally, newspaper companies are extremely cheap these days.
- tomjen3 10y agoYeah, but that article also showed that the younger generations are watching less "TV" over all (and probably much less if they hadn't counted VOD as "TV") so they are just trying to target the old people, because young people are so much more expensive to target.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoWhen I cut the cord and went streaming, I sort of expected that I'd have to "make do". Instead (duh) it was like walking in out of the cold. TV's days are numbered, and frankly, advertising-as-interruption is on its last legs.
- mrweasel 10y agoThe quality of the content on TV seems to have been in a steady decline for many years. Looking at the graph in the article, ad spending on TV is at an all time high, it has just plateaued. So maybe revenue isn't the issue, maybe quality is. It my guess that the TV networks somehow believed that if you made X amount of dollars on one channel, then adding a second channel would make you twice that amount. Networks that had one or two stations 15 years ago, now have 8 or 10. Rather than increasing profit, they are left with roughly the same amount of revenue, but they have to spend it on content for many more channels. Not wanting to close channels, networks started to produce cheaper programs, "reality" TV mostly. Meanwhile you can't buy a good, independent news channel, even if you're willing to pay. TV can blame streaming, Youtube, the internet in general, but that's not what's "killing" TV. I believe it's the quality of the content that's the issue for TV.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoI absolutely agree. My 62 year old mother isn't looking to cut the cord because she loves to go a la carte and stream, she just hates what's on and how much she has to pay for it.
- dexterdog 10y agoI think the quantity has gone way up because there are so many channels but TV is in a golden age with so many series that are better than most movies. If you are cherry-picking shows to watch from the catalog, now is an incredible time to be watching.
- vitd 10y agoIt depends on what you mean. The OP was talking about prime time programming on the 3-4 major networks. That's very different from what's being produced on pay channels like HBO or Showtime, or on Netflix. I agree that the high quality stuff is better than 10-20 years ago, where everything was a Friends or Seinfeld ripoff. But I think most of the high quality stuff is on non-major networks these days. Though maybe that's just my perception. I find myself watching less and less stuff on those networks, and more and more on the other networks.
- mamon 10y ago"Young people are still spending big chunks of their time watching TV, but the youngs are finding different ways to waste their lives." - that quote made my day :) Anyway, back to the point, I am now in my mid-thirties and have never owned a TV. Of course I wasted a lot of time this way in my youth, but since the advent of Internet, online streaming, torrents, etc. I find television to be terrible user experience, because it is totaly non-interactive. I just can't stand the fact that someone else is making the schedule that I need to follow. Internet gives me the possibility of watching what I want whenever I want it. The only exception to this rule are football matches that must be watched live, but those also are streamed nowadays. I expect television to be completly gone in 10-15 years time.
- merpnderp 10y agoMy 4 year old son has never known normal TV. His entire life has been internet based tv shows and movies. We just went on vacation to a place without internet and they had only cable tv. He was so frustrated with commercials, not being able to pause, or quickly pick a show he wanted to watch, that he decided he'd rather not watch tv at all. So yes, the experience is much worse than internet tv, at least for onboarding 4 year olds. (As a replacement for tv my son picked building sand castles and playing miniature golf, so huge win)
- rimantas 10y agoI've the TV that is very interactive. You can pauser, rewind, watch the missed programs, set reminders, etc.
- Kurtz79 10y agoBy "TV" in the US do you refer to the service or the physical medium, in general ? I think "physical" TVs have still a way to go, I'm in my mid-thirties and haven't plugged in mine to an aerial since at least 10 years, but it still sees extensive use plugged in to a console or to an HTPC. But 10-15 years it's lot of time in tech, maybe by that time we will have holodecks :)
- tomjen3 10y agoI have a tv that is used to what flow-tv substantially never (less than 4 minutes in the last year or so), but at the company gym I have noticed some of the older people turn on the tv right as they go in and don't even mute it during commercials and my grandparents will religiously turn on the tv to watch the 9 o'clock news daily. I think this is really a generational issue and I very much doubt it will be gone in 10-15 years, but it will probably have epsilon uptake and die with the generation that is now in their later 30s.
- jokoon 10y agoI still wonder if TV ads can be accurately monitored, since it's not possible to measure broadcast audience. Being able to make measurements is a huge advantage for online ads.
- GoToRO 10y agoBroadcast audience is measured. They choose a representative selection of the population and install some device that tracks exactly what people are watching.
- bunderbunder 10y agoNielsen is the best-known (possibly only?) company that does this in the US, and they're very good at what they do. Their use of a sample is perfectly fine, and there might even be grounds to argue that it's more accurate than trying to get a complete count of viewership. But when it comes to ad viewership, I'm guessing all they can really measure is the attempt to show someone an ad. I'm not sure they have a good way to measure compliance. Are people actually watching the ads, or are they using ad breaks as an opportunity to take a leak, get another soda, or mute the TV and talk to each other? Granted, the same's true for Internet ads. Does anyone really sit through YouTube ads? Or do they just mute their computer's audio and go take a peek at Facebook while the ad plays?
- CaptSpify 10y ago> Nielsen is the best-known (possibly only?) company that does this in the US, and they're very good at what they do. Their use of a sample is perfectly fine, and there might even be grounds to argue that it's more accurate than trying to get a complete count of viewership. Sorry, but this isn't true. We've known for a long time that their ratings are BS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nielsen_ratings#Criticism_of_ratings_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nielsen_ratings#Criticism_of_r... Your other point is true though: They can only attempt to track who is watching ads, not actually track.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- markbnj 10y ago>> Remember this moment in five to 10 years, when it becomes obvious the television industry is in trouble. Really? It's not obvious now?