6 ms·
I used to trade FX. With this bank as well, though I didn't know these two guys. So there's two ways to buy something: agency or principal. If it's agency, you
by lordnacho 10y ago
I used to trade FX. With this bank as well, though I didn't know these two guys.
So there's two ways to buy something: agency or principal. If it's agency, you say to a guy "hey, go and buy me some widgets and I'll pay the amount and you'll get a little fee".
If it's principal, you say "hey, make me a price that you want to trade at, and we'll trade, and how you make that profitable for you is your own problem."
What is front running? Generally, it's where you're the agent, but you use that fact to scoop yourself some widgets before you do the trade for the customer. Now naturally, even if you are not literally executing an order for a client, that flow information is useful to you. For instance you might guess all the clients are spooked because of some news, and after two of them call to do the same trade, you guess they'll all do so.
3/4 pm fixing question. Actually seems a reasonable suggestion to do it at the less liquid fix. A lot of derivatives are fixed at 4pm, and there may well be some guy out there with a strong interest in moving it. I recall the price action at 4pm being very odd on many, many occasions.
Anyway, what's confusing to me is why didn't Cairn just get a firm price from HSBC? You can phone a guy and ask for a few billion if you like, people do it all the time. Alternatively, anyone can get an unknown execution price; the banks provide a GUI to everyone who wants one, and you can click the thing until you've got your amount done. The market won't run out of GBP.
What they seem to have done is give a licence to HSBC to trade their order in a way that was bound to create an unequal conflict of interest. The bank can always make it profitable for itself, because they're in control. The customer is bound to be disappointed when they have both an unknown price and price impact against them.
It's possible that since Cairn would be a "real money" customer things are not quite like when I was a customer. Hedge funds are called "leveraged" customers, and the sales people tend to be different, with a different focus. The FCA might also be taking a view that real money guys need better protection than speculators.
I definitely wouldn't have called in to do a single massive trade. I'd have gotten on the GUIs an clicked my way through, with an uncertain outcome, split across various banks and over a few days. It's not as if the profits from selling a business unit will be lost by the currency move between the sale and the cash disbursement to the shareholders.
Agree that you can't lie to the client about what you've gotten up to. That part is undeniably bad.
- jackgavigan 10y ago> The FCA might also be taking a view that... These charges weren't brought by the FCA. I bet the FCA looked at this case and decided that no crime was committed (under UK law, at least).
- smallnamespace 10y ago> I'd have gotten on the GUIs an clicked my way through, with an uncertain outcome, split across various banks and over a few days. Because you're sophisticated market participant and have sat on a desk. You understand the price impact of showing potential flow to the Street, and how to break up an order in order to hide your intent. Would you expect a random corporate treasurer know how to do that? Not to mention that there are structural barriers to what you describe -- it costs money to buy Bloomberg terminals and live market feeds, and not every treasury department can afford to do that. What upsets people is that when traders interact with less sophisticated clients, the latter tend to get fleeced. It's the same reason people hate car salesmen.
- tptacek 10y agoI'm not sure where we are that we've decided people doing 3.5 billion dollar transactions are "unsophisticated".
- smallnamespace 10y agoThere's plenty of stupid money in the market. How else do you think trading desks make money? Nobody who understands the FX market would have chosen to run their execution like that.
- tptacek 10y agoThat really seems like a "No True Scotsman" definition of "sophistication". Regardless, it's not the definition the markets use. For the same reason, I qualify to invest in private company stock by dint of my bank account and annual income, not by passing a test.