2 ms·
#2 seems more like a way to shift jobs around from one place to another than to create them
by emodendroket 10y ago
#2 seems more like a way to shift jobs around from one place to another than to create them
- mathattack 10y agoSomewhat. But there's friction from moving jobs around. An oversimplified way to view it... Let's say I can get $100/hour of value out of an employee. As long as I can get $100/hour of value from them, I'll hire them. Now let's say that there is $10 of regulatory burden. (Hard to fire, etc) Then I'd need $110/value to hire someone. Now let's say it costs me $5/hour in communications overhead for people out of town. Then we have 3 scenarios: 1) $110+ in value - I can hire in either place. I prefer the HQ if the resource in CA is $5/hour cheaper. (Or measurably better) 2) $100-$105 in value - I hire in the other place. 3) Up to $105 in value - No hiring. Lowering the regulatory burden to less than $5/hour adds to the amount of jobs people have. Note - it's never really this simple, but it illustrates the idea that someone has to bear additional costs. When the employer and employee split it, relationships that used to net out with higher employment can end with higher unemployment.
- worldsayshi 10y agoHow is this?
- emodendroket 10y agoIf Texas offers me some really sweet incentives so I go and establish my business there (or move an existing one there) instead of California I haven't exactly created twice as many jobs as I would have otherwise, have I?
- bduerst 10y agoWe did a scenario planning project where you put together human trends and factors to try and predict several versions of the future 10 years from now. In one of our scenarios was a future where humans bounced from job to job (high turnover, low unemployment) and skills-based education was cheap and easily accessible. Some of the factors leading to this was the "established"-education bubble bursting, increased automation, and less desire for consumers to own assets while still having access to them (variable sharing economy). A #2 type of future might not be that unrealistic.
- emodendroket 10y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to get at but a race to the bottom among municipalities and states to try and attract businesses is already happening and has been for some time. My point is that this won't actually solve the problem posed so much as redirect it somewhere else.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bduerst 10y ago#2 solution isn't about moving existing jobs, it's about lowering the barrier to entry for new jobs, since demand isn't fixed and variability will increase. You will always have tug-of-wars between municipalities (e.g. Applebee's HQ between Missouri and Kansas) - but businesses in states or munis with a low barrier to entry for new jobs can fulfill and capitalize on variable demand faster.