7 ms·
Unemployed, a grad student rethinks the world of work
- pw0ncakes 17y agoAnyone who still doubts that we're rapidly becoming a third world country needs to read this article and multiply it by a few million. It's not "the recession". This could just have easily been written in 2006. The US is in rapid decline.
- houseabsolute 17y agoI see, a thought exercise is proof that we are becoming a third world nation. I wonder how long it will take under this standard to prove that the speed of light can be exceeded.
- rguzman 17y agoHeh. Ironic that thought experiments first led to the idea that the speed of light is a constant and can't be exceeded. Thought experiments are not proof, just useful and potentially enlightening.
- houseabsolute 17y agoThought experiments can be used to prove almost anything. There are thought experiments that disprove the speed limit of light, and ones that prove it. My point is that merely claiming that one should imagine this situation copied a million times is no evidence at all. It's not even good rhetoric. It should be lent no more credence than would be lent to the thousands of people each year who post on forums their disproof of special relativity.
- pw0ncakes 17y ago"A million times" because there are millions of people whose stories are like this right now, thanks to our failed society.
- houseabsolute 17y agoI see no evidence for that belief. And even if there were, I don't think that would mean our society has failed.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoIf you think it's not social failure for highly literate, qualified people to be doing menial work, then you, sir, are a mean-spirited and unpleasant person.
- houseabsolute 17y agoAgain, I don't really see the connection between my opinion on this subject and my mean-spiritedness or unpleasantness. It sounds to me like you have an emotional stake in this situation and you are letting it cloud your judgment. She's qualified, but not for anything that anyone needs doing. Do you think a highly qualified one-foot-balancer deserves employment in that pursuit and that it's a shame if he has to wash dishes because no one will pay him $50k a year to balance on one foot all day? I don't see that as a tragedy, and it's an analogue to this situation. Admittedly it's not perfect because there are _no_ jobs in one-foot-balancing and merely few in editing, but it's the same type of thing. Since you insulted me, I'll allow myself a stylistic criticism. The "you, sir" thing is lame. Drop it.
- yequalsx 17y agoWhat you say holds in a micro sense but not in a macro sense. No individual has a right to a certain type of employment. It is no great tragedy if an individual does not find work doing what they love doing. However, if too many people are unable to find work doing what they like doing (or are content doing) then this is bad for society. Before the present fiscal crisis a friend of mine justified the validity of liar loans on the basis that they are an agreement between two consenting parties. Of course an individual has the right to make a bad decision and of course 20 million bad decisions can affect the entire nation. Would you make the same argument that you made if the underemployment rate for Ph.D.s in electrical engineering was 25%? There is a point where this becomes a big deal. I'm not saying we are at this point but the existence of such a point should not be denied. It would be a very bad thing for this country if, in general, advanced degrees required too high an opportunity cost.
- hvs 17y agoDid you miss the part where she mentions that she has a "Masters in Journalism"? That and $5 will get you a latte at Starbucks.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoThis is because unscrupulous universities mint more degrees than there are jobs for. That should be stopped. The talented people get in, and those who don't have the talent don't. Right now, because everyone can get in to some kind of grad school, it dilutes the value of such degrees to almost zero.
- dantheman 17y agoPeople should be free to do whatever they want. If a lot of people want to go to grad school that's fine, it means we have people with more training. If that training can help them earn more, then more power to them if not well that's life.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoPeople should be free to do whatever they want. This contradicts your argument that society hasn't failed this woman. I'm pretty sure that cleaning up rental apartments is not what she wanted to do with her life.
- dgordon 17y agoPeople should be free to do whatever they want, but not to make other people finance their wants. I see no contradiction.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoIn other words, they can't do what they want with their lives; they have only token freedom. We need to restructure the economy and society so that culture rules, so that the resources are made available to pay for culture and the arts-- so we can stop being an artistic and philosophical backwater-- and the uncultured profit-ideologists who've currently infected this country with their adolescent ideology and bankrupt values are utterly disempowered, instead of running the show as they are now.
- kyteland 17y agoThe United States will always be a first world country because that is the definition of first world. First/second/third world status never changes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:First_second_third_worlds_map.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:First_second_third_worlds_...
- aik 17y agoWith that definition it makes the term first/second/third world nearly meaningless. "A is A because it is". I prefer the definition that implies that "A is A because [INSERT REASONS]" and "A is A but can become B if..."
- etal 17y agoThe definitions are from the Cold War: industrialized capitalist nations in the West, communist nations in the East, and none of the above, where the proxy wars were fought. So the definition is fixed by history, and also somewhat obsolete. Note the amusing parallel between assuming the US is turning into a "third world" country, since the gaps in industrialization worldwide are closing, and the article's original assumption that an educated middle-class girl would never have to do the same work as a Spanish-speaking working-class woman.
- pyre 17y ago> original assumption that an educated middle-class girl would never have to do the same work as a Spanish-speaking working-class woman. Maybe you read a different article, but she was doing the same job as a Spanish-speaking working-class woman. The assumption is that it was just a stepping-stone to bigger and better things, while the 'Spanish-speaking working-class woman' works the job to make ends meet. She may have had some assumptions that as a middle-class girl she wouldn't end up working a waitress job to make ends meet, but there is a large portion of the population that gets sold the promise of "go to school, get educated, get a better job." This isn't just about 4-year degrees from a major university. It's the same with trade-schools, community colleges, 2-year degree programs, online universities, etc. The idea that a 'better job' will necessarily just follow from 'getting an education' is sold all over the place.
- hyperbovine 17y agoThe US is in rapid decline. I think the US is diverging into two camps: a well-educated, well-off elite, and a permanent underclass. This story is about somebody who always thought of herself as the former, and then found out she was the latter.
- bilbo0s 17y agoI would agree. Only I would add well-connected to the list of characteristics of the elite class. My Significant Other just got done creating a plan for the lay-offs of about 5000 highly educated Health Care workers. Outplacement services, severance packages ONLY where legally obligated, others will need approval case by case, flights back to home countries, movers, obtaining extra security etc etc etc. She had to keep a lid on it until recently. AND . . . this is the creamy frosting on the cake . . . they had her include herself. I think the underclass of the future will probably be just as well educated as the elite. But they probably won't know the right people. It will be very much a sort of 'work from layoff to layoff' kind of existence.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI think the underclass of the future will probably be just as well educated as the elite. But they probably won't know the right people. It will be very much a sort of 'work from layoff to layoff' kind of existence. The well-educated paupers will launch a much-needed revolt. Happily, it can be done none-violently with cyberattacks and property damage-- the people involved will be smart enough-- so we can have French Revolution-style pwnage of the upper crust and Glorious Revolution bloodlessness together.
- mikecane 17y agoI disagree with that view. That is not what America set out to be nor will any American settle for that. Mobility of all sorts has been inculcated into us for decades (one could argue since the foundation of the nation itself). This is different than many countries, where "duty" is upheld over personal fulfillment and improvement. It's our belief in possibilities that drives America and makes it unique among nations. And I don't say this in a cheerleading manner. This is why people come here. It's not just the money. It's the freedom to do things.
- wmeredith 17y agoThis is a short story about someone who expected the world handed to them because they had a master's degree and it didn't work out. It's hardly a revelation and seems to skirt the line between pity party and reflection on hubris. This isn't some upstart rethinking the way we work. It's an entitled person coming to the realization that they were wrong over the course of a few paragraphs.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoIt's an "entitled" person being failed by society and realizing that a lot of others who were similarly failed are neither lazy nor stupid (refuting the economic Calvinism that characterizes American conservatism) but, rather, are unlucky people much like her.
- dantheman 17y agoShe's not being failed by society -- she thought society owed her, and that she was better than those around her. She then realized that people are people, and that we should respect all of them regardless of the job they do.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoShe was wrong that she was better, but society still failed her by having nothing more productive for her to do than cleaning rental apartments, and no means of providing income/retraining in the event that there was no suitable work for her. 120 IQ people should not be doing 80 IQ work. This isn't about "better"; it's about suitability to the work. When the 120-IQ person is doing 80-IQ work, it's an injustice for two reasons. 1) She's bored, miserable, and underpaid relative to what she'd be earning in a functional society. 2) The 80-IQ people who want and enjoy jobs cleaning apartments now have her as competition, and can be paid less and treated worse.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- 17y ago
- houseabsolute 17y agoWe should teach our students earlier that it can sometimes be important to align your dreams with what other people will pay for. I.e. not journalism, at least not in the volume that universities continue to turn out journalists. People shouldn't have to work through six years of school before finding this out the hard way.
- dkarl 17y agoThe idea is widely understood and discussed among college students, so I'm not sure what can be done further to teach them to live in accordance with it. I think it would be more useful to teach them not to despise knowledge of how the "trivial" aspects of the world actually work, so they find it easier to make themselves useful when and where they need to.
- dantheman 17y agoI've started telling people, look at what the median result is for whatever you want to do. If that is something that you would enjoy doing/think is worth it then continue down that path.
- run4yourlives 17y agoI think this is the best approach. It seems that when it comes to a career path, the common notion is to compare the top percentage without taking into account that for many, this situation is only applicable for the last few years of the career; for many more, not applicable at all. It's not whether you want to dream of playing in the NHL. It's whether you enjoy playing hockey enough to play in Rochester for some farm team for a few hundred people a night making $50K.
- bilbo0s 17y agoThis is a tough problem, because 6 years ago someone may have gone to college to be a Computer Scientist. Learned Java or C++ if they were lucky. Probably kept sharp with PHP, Python, Ruby, MySQL et al if they were smart. Maybe a little Flash. Then they get out just when everyone who is NOT going NoSQL is using Amazon RDS. People are hiring iPhone programmers to port Flash apps to ObjC. And everyone is looking to get some Erlang or Scala blood into their dev house. The fact is that all skills are obsoleted eventually. And eventually comes quicker and quicker these days. I don't claim to know what the answer is but I think looking at the world today and asking what people are paying for can be a difficult strategy to make work. Now looking at the world today and asking what people will not pay for is somewhat helpful at least. But trying to catch a moving target is fraught with peril. I think a good piece of advice would be to stay flexible. Flexible in your ability to learn. Flexible in your ability to move. Flexible in your ability to absorb fluctuations in income. I think that in the America of the future workers may need to be flexible, and let a lot of things roll off of them. If not. I don't know. I could see this whole thing ending badly.
- swombat 17y agoThis is probably the main (valid) reason why the "right to work" is enshrined in the universal declaration of human rights ( http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/ http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/ Article 23). Many people define themselves through their career and find their sense of self-identity severely damaged if that's taken away from them. And many people don't have the entrepreneurial urge to go an do their own thing if they can't make it happen "in the system". It's a dangerous place to be, for any society, when a large chunk of its society (particularly middle class, like this girl) feels like their self-identity is crumbling.
- hvs 17y agoThen she probably shouldn't have chose to get a degree in a largely pointless major.
- nollidge 17y agoJournalism is pointless?
- houseabsolute 17y agoRather say that it is "overbooked" from an employment-seeking perspective.
- aliston 17y agoI see your point, but I also think you can get into trouble deciding whether a degree is "pointless" entirely on its current market value. Computer science may have seemed like a pointless degree at one point during the 60's.
- pyre 17y agoHow many people in the 1960's came out of Computer Science programs only to end up 'flipping burgers' and wondering where they went wrong? You can pursue a field because you love it, but you need to realistically take a look at your job prospects when you make the decision to go for it.
- markbnine 17y agoshe can't be doing so bad... she just got published in the csmonitor...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- csomar 17y agookay, many non university students are now working and making good bucks online or offline. A university degree may make it easier for you to knock companies doors, but it won't give you money. Blogs are looking for writer and looking to pay $50/$80 per article. You don't need to be a master degree owner but just good enough to write something interesting for the community. This is what school doesn't and won't teach you (or you could just start and bypass them).
- awt 17y agoThis is written in a humble tone and does a good job of addressing the difference between reality and the message we are sold as high school and college students that getting a degree in any field guarantees you a career, and that you will love your job. It is impossible to know which field will ultimately pan out at the age of 18, and those you trust (professors, teachers) will mislead you, albeit unintentionally. I think the other message is that you shouldn't wait for something big to happen to start enjoying life.
- olegk 17y ago> But seven months later, after getting rejected from every permanent job I applied to, I was feeling pretty discouraged. Seriously? Either he applied for 5 jobs in seven months, or there's something seriously wrong with the guy (horrible personality, horrible grades, can't answer interview questions).
- ibsulon 17y agoIt's much harder in the non-tech world, especially competing against people with specific skillsets. If you spent your time as an editor, nobody is going to look at you for a secretary when there are 50 resumes for secretaries staring you in the face. Editor jobs dried up.