4 ms·
And how are we sure it isn't recording when you're NOT saying OK Google? :-) Is there an analogue for a piece of scotch tape over the webcam for the paranoid (
by EGreg 10y ago
And how are we sure it isn't recording when you're NOT saying OK Google? :-)
Is there an analogue for a piece of scotch tape over the webcam for the paranoid (Zuckerbergs) of the world?
- bad_user 10y agoI think battery life and 4G network bandwidth are constraints for now. If it would record and stream data while in standby, battery wouldn't last for more than a few hours and would visibly consume your allocated bandwidth. What they do is to introduce a dedicated processor that listens for these keywords and that is supposed to wake the phone up on detection. The danger of course is having that processor activate the phone on keywords other than "OK Google". And it doesn't even have to be on purpose. As I said, my wife's phone detection is totally broken for some reason.
- EGreg 10y agoIt doesn't need to stream all the time, just record. The traffic is encrypted end-to-end anyway, you can only do an analysis on the size relative to how much time it's been idle.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoThis. 30* 24* 3600* 22000/(8e9) = 7.8 gigabytes per month for 24/7 surveillance at the bare minimum (AFAIK) of 22 kbps mono audio.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y ago2.83GB. Voice sounds fine at 8kbps. Reduce it even further if all you need is to understand what's being said.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoStill, that would light up your data usage like a christmas tree.
- Dylan16807 10y agoDo you connect to wifi at least once a month?
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoYou can also show per-app data usage over wifi on Android (it's a single click away on stock Android). If Google Now was transferring 2.8 GB of data each month, someone would have noticed. Also, the high battery usage argument.
- khedoros 10y agoIf they were streaming spy data like that, I suspect that they wouldn't report the data usage. IMO, battery life is the strongest indicator that they aren't.
- satysin 10y agoWho says it would use up your data usage? Of course this would require the network operator to allow it but it isn't anywhere near impossible to do without the user knowing.
- EGreg 10y agoThat assumes people are speaking all the time -- the onboard processor can in fact translate most of the speech into text you know.
- nitrogen 10y agoYou only need to transmit if you detect frequencies in the range of human speech, and only in batches that can be masked with other data transfers.
- digler999 10y agoI think if this were happening, people would eventually be able to tell by watching the network traffic. You may not be able to decode the network traffic, but if you run it through an analyzer like wireshark, while you say "OK, Google" and you see the bandwith increase, then if you see a similar bandwidth pattern other times you might have a clue that its recording. Of course that assumes they aren't saving to the disk and sending it later.