7 ms·
The example is a co-op comprised of professional photographers. According to the article, the co-op screened out over 90% of applicants. I suspect that selling
by brudgers 10y ago
The example is a co-op comprised of professional photographers. According to the article, the co-op screened out over 90% of applicants. I suspect that selling stock photography on the web is not most of the accepted applicants main gig.
These aren't people waiting in line for another person's sushi or drycleaning. The article's title is a bit misleading. This is a niche in the world of professional photographers that doesn't really generalize to the scale of an "economy".
- Flimm 10y agoHow do you know that the photographers on Stocksy aren't full-time?
- fennecfoxen 10y agoMost US-based photographers selling stock photos are not, in fact, full-time stock photographers, but there are US-based full-time professional photographers who do some stock photography (either with photos shot for stock's sake, or sometimes with surplus photos from other photo shoots, as permitted by the specifics of the shoot). High-quality cameras are expensive, and the relatively low returns on stock photos aren't usually the best use of that capital. More full-time stock photographers are from places like eastern Europe, where the cost of living is lower.
- brudgers 10y agoMy intuition [maybe that's not knowledge] is that the application would require a portfolio of stock images, hence the photographers are almost certainly already in other stock image sales channels. There's little reason to assume that they will drop those other channels. Because of the ownership model of Stocksy, there's little reason to bring on photographers without an existing track record selling stock images.
- bhouston 10y agoI think it is very generalizable. Maturity in a sharing market likely means more to the people doing the work.
- meira 10y agothe article evidences a situation that COULD becomes a pattern, and a pattern that improves the gig economy. I don't think the title is misleading, but your judgment is. The same can happen in every "gig economy" platform, like online transportation (with local taxi unions owning the app) or a neighborhood managing it's own home renting app. This would be a lot safer, wouldn't? :)
- jackfrodo 10y agoThis could be a dumb question, but is there anything stopping a large startup like Uber from being more generous with the cut its drivers get? How is it more feasible for a small company to do this?
- meira 10y agoI don't know, but they expend billions of VC dollars subsiding rides to get market share. Maybe they could change strategy and expend the same money lowering their share in the rides. Probably the first strategy worked better for them until now.
- Amygaz 10y agoThey certainly could have had the same success or even better, by taking a 10% vs 25% from the get go. I think it has more to do with the Uber management's vision of what that platform is. This has never been a platform to empower drivers or to right inefficiencies in the transportation business. It has always been a platform to exploit inefficiencies in the system.
- Bartweiss 10y agoSome numbers: Uber charges riders $0.18 per minute and $1 per mile. They take a 20% cut (plus the whole of the $1 base-fare). Drivers estimate that they spend 20% of what remains on tax and vehicle costs. That's not an enormous margin, but it's large. Uber is still expanding rapidly in driver count, in geographic range, and in product range. That takes quite a bit of money, especially the geographic range - Uber runs pretty vigorous ad and lobbying campaigns to influence regulators and oppose taxi agencies. Fasten is a startup whose entire business model is "Uber but better for drivers". They advertise to consumers that they take a smaller cut, and hope to attract more drivers with their better rates. My guess is that Uber will crush or acquire them after dropping prices (or raising driver share) in the relevant markets. So I think the answer is: Uber could do this, but it would slow their growth. Once they're an entrenched player in most markets, I would expect to see driver share (and possibly rates) rise a bit to maintain supply, but right now they're funneling everything they can into expansion. (And, I'm sure, panting at the thought of using self-driving cars to turn that 80% into profit.)
- empath75 10y agoI don't see why an uber competitor couldn't do a similar thing with drivers. A taxi co-op seems like a no-brainer.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoThere are (were?) lots of taxi co-ops. Unfortunately, they've been demutualizing over the last 50 years. The issue, in the US at least, is the IRS. There's a fairly massive legal grey area in how to treat patronage (distributed profits) for members of a worker co-op. Are they dividends? If so, they should be taxed at the capital rate. Or are they bonuses? Then they're taxed at the income rate. But the IRS doesn't want to give any guidance on this and other issues it created with co-ops. You literally only find out the day they sue you whether you've been doing it right. And, if you put up a fight, they always settle instead of pursuing the case to judgement, in fear of setting a precedent. Oh, and good luck finding a lawyer or accountant specializing in co-op law to help you out. The problem with worker co-ops is not that they're infeasible. It's that decades of lobbying and IRS paranoia have hobbled the model. Ironically, they work fantastically well here in the developing world. It's an extremely efficient way of pooling risk, aggregating labor, and achieving economies of scale without selling off a massive stake to VCs.
- dragonwriter 10y agoAFAICT, the IRS has consistently treated them as non-dividend income for income tax purpose, with the main unclear (and changing over time) question being whether they would insist they were subject to either self-employment tax or employer-based payroll tax, or neither.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoAh, that's right. Thanks for pulling me up on that. It's been awhile since I've looked at this. I believe another bone of contention is whether the IRS even allows worker cooperatives to exempt patronage dividends from their taxable profit, to avoid double taxation (corporate, then personal income tax). Technically (under Subchapter T), they should be allowed to. But the IRS is pretty sue-happy about this and refuses to issue much guidance. The last clear ruling was in 1971 and only allowed dividends to be issued on the basis of hours worked, not value earned (or other metrics).
- monodeldiablo 10y ago"According to the article, the co-op screened out over 90% of applicants." I don't see how that's relevant. Eventually, all the "gig economy" startups will also need to be selective of their applicants. Uber also screens their drivers, for example. As for not generalizing to the scale of an "economy"... as someone who's done a fair share of hiring, screening 90% of applicants is par for the course for any business in this economy. And profit distribution, democratic workplaces, and flat hierarchies are totally normal in tech. I don't see how a worker cooperative model wouldn't scale. In fact, as technology democratizes many of the functions we've historically relied on C-levels for -- decision-making, organization, contract negotiations, partnerships, hiring, firing, etc. -- I see this as an inevitability. Let me put it another way: Why would Joe Developer work for firm A, where a significant percentage of revenue goes to compensating an unaccountable mob of MBAs when I could join firm B and increase my share? At this point, the only remaining valid function of most executives is to cozy up to capital. But as capital continues to trickle up, I feel competition here will get fierce and people will find more creative ways of funding businesses. Either way, downward economic pressure is going to force executive suites to slim down -- in numbers and pay -- or face elimination entirely.
- contingencies 10y agoI don't see how that's relevant. Manual pre-screening is an interesting model, but one which is not really modern. The assumption is that the pre-screening personnel are able to second-guess the market's wants. A more modern approach would allow the individuals seeking reward to try different strategies to address the market directly, thereby removing the artificial middle-man of manual pre-screening.