3 ms·
Not only can bitcoin be tumbled, but think about the scenario where it is exchanged for another crypto-currency like litecoin then exchanged for bitcoin at anot
by CyberDildonics 10y ago
Not only can bitcoin be tumbled, but think about the scenario where it is exchanged for another crypto-currency like litecoin then exchanged for bitcoin at another site, then exchanged for cash. Good luck tracing that.
- UweSchmidt 10y agoBut that's just more data, you just JOIN another table - the exchanges have a list of transactions, left column BTC adress, right column litecoin adress. The difficult one-time work will be done when chasing terrorists. Everyone can be compelled to hand over data. Crime is impossible.
- CyberDildonics 10y agoIf you sell btc for ltc on one site, split up the balances, then sell the ltc for btc on different sites, how exactly would someone piece that back together? The crypto currency exchanges would be transferring to and from their internal addresses. There would be no direct connection without knowing all the addresses the exchanges use, and they can (and should) use a different address for each transaction. > Crime is impossible. Lets not get carried away
- UweSchmidt 10y agoThe "sites" keep track of the transactions. This information could leak or law enforcement could successfully request this information. High level analysis could find btc-altcoin transactions that "fit" together, maybe with later transaction when the person will eventually cash out, and use other data thats not obvious to us right now. A difficult problem, but one that is straightforward, fashionable (big data), profitable (lots of money at stake), and potentially something that law enforcement/intelligence agencies work on. We tend to underestimate future capabilities ;)
- MichaelGG 10y ago> Good luck tracing that Subpoena the trading sites? An active adversary would be running the trading sites, though I doubt they'd waste that info on a low-level case. LocalBitcoins says they retain all messages for 180 days, up from their previous 90. Is that purely for internal disputes? Sure, if you're not doing anything illegal enough, you can get away with simply using sites in multiple jurisdictions and hoping it's too much of a pain. But let's not pretend it's not traceable. I'd only be happy with zero knowledge proofs (if they're real; I haven't understood the maths at all.)
- CyberDildonics 10y agoThe crypto currency exchanges could be in any country, I don't think it is any solace to be able to send out subpoenas to sites completely outside the banking system.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>"LocalBitcoins says they retain all messages for 180 days" // Can't you just wait longer than 180 days then? The investigators then subpoena for the transaction records to link it all back together and the records longer exist (in theory).