17 ms·
Programming Language Rankings: June 2016
- acangiano 10y agoNot perfect, but it feels significantly more realistic than the TIOBE index (http://www.tiobe.com/tiobe_index http://www.tiobe.com/tiobe_index) or PYPL: https://pypl.github.io/PYPL.html https://pypl.github.io/PYPL.html. The trouble is that I make this statement from a place of intuition, conscious of my own biases, so I could be wrong.
- denfromufa 10y agoTIOBE seems to be the most realistic with history tracing back to 1986. C/C++ coders have tons of code not on github and a lot of references like books, which are sometimes more useful than SO. Also the metrics, native language and area of application are very important.
- barking 10y agoTiobe seem to alter their methodology fairly often which afaik also has the effect of altering historical rankings. In other words if you look at the TIOBE rankings on the wayback machine for a particular year in the past they can differ greatly from the rankings for that year given on the site today. For example, I think that VB was affected greatly by this
- jayvanguard 10y agoI find TIOBE to be so far from reality I question why it exists and anyone continues to pay any attention to it. It still ranks Delphi higher than Objective-C. Assembly language above Visual Basic. Dart above Scala, Erlang, Haskell, and Bash.
- vorg 10y agoTiobe's also cheated a lot by some language backers. Groovy jumped from 0.33% to 1.18% in a single month 6 months ago. See http://www.tiobe.com/tiobe_index?page=Groovy http://www.tiobe.com/tiobe_index?page=Groovy
- zik 10y agoIt reflects the biases of github and stackoverflow which tend to reflect the interests of enthusiasts and web developers. I don't think it very accurately reflects what's used in real life, either for the innumerable hours of boring everyday programming work that people do or even what kind of code is being cranked out in the major open source projects - the ones that are actually used by other people. What it does provide is an interesting leading indicator: what's hot right now. Languages like clojure which get a lot of attention for a while but aren't used in a whole lot of real applications tend to peak and then drop relatively quickly.
- acangiano 10y agoYou are spot on. The reason why this list resonated with me is that I am an "enthusiast and web developer". It's confirmation bias at play. As you said, this is still interesting, even if not accurate in absolute terms, as an indicator of what technologies are currently emerging among passionate developers.
- lazyjones 10y ago> It reflects the biases of github and stackoverflow which tend to reflect the interests of enthusiasts and web developers. That's a bit oversimplified IMO. SO doesn't reflect "interest in" as much as "having difficulties with". There must be "WAT"-type effects vs. simple, intuitive languages like Go factored in for it to provide useful information regarding popularity. It's a bit like counting hospitalized patients with sports injuries to rank sports activities by popularity. As for the relevance of github - people are always claiming their language detection is broken and I'd worry about the (intentionally?) skewing effects of moving the core language/library development to github.com like the Go project did.
- mangodrunk 10y ago>SO doesn't reflect "interest in" as much as "having difficulties with". They are using it to have difficulties, so I think it is an interest in. Also, perhaps those that are beginners in things might have more questions, and show that also shows interest. This redmonk has some horrible graphs, and as you said, the method at which they categorize on github is flawed, let alone using stackoverflow or github as indicators being flawed.
- jballanc 10y agoTIOBE is much more about general computing/IT, evidenced by the relatively high ranking of things like COBOL and Transact-SQL. RedMonk, in contrast, seems more focused on pure programing (or, you might even say, the "hacker" community).
- TwoBit 10y agoI've been suspicious of Tiobe's ranking of C higher than C++ because I know hardly anybody using C any more. 90% or more of C/C++ programming I'm aware of is C++.
- kbart 10y agoEmbedded and system level programming is still done almost universally in C and that's a huge segment. In reality I'd say C is even higher, because only a small part of code written in it ends up on GitHub, the rest is deep inside legacy systems.
- smcl 10y agoI was a bit confused too when I saw Swift ahead of Objective C
- haimez 10y agoThat one makes more sense to me. There's no legacy platform that only supports Objective-C and not swift, so virtually all the developers switched to the more pleasant to use language.
- smcl 10y agoBut there's almost a decade of existing Obj-C code (I'm guessing iOS apps comprise the bulk of objective C code). I would have thought porting that To Swift would be a Herculean effort - but I'm not using either language so maybe I'm not best placed to talk about this
- pjmlp 10y agoI guess you are not focusing on UNIX systems programming. Anything other than C and Assembly is sacrilege.
- dingo_bat 10y agoC rules the roost in embedded Linux devices. I suggested in my team that we move to C++ and was met with incredulous reactions. To be honest the only thing I seriously miss in C is std::vector.
- myth_drannon 10y agoI prefer StackOverflow careers as an indicator of language popularity in the industry. When you post a job you can only select 5 tech tags that accurately describe the position. I have been scraping SO for couple of months now. If you want to dig into the data, right now it's aggregated as json. https://github.com/aparij/soCareers-Data https://github.com/aparij/soCareers-Data
- lkrubner 10y agoSince I've been interested in how the Functional paradigm might help us developers deal with concurrency, there are 2 items here that really strike me: 1.) Clojure fell back 2.) Elixir, though small, is still moving forward I've been a fan of Clojure since 2009. It grew rapidly for a few years, from 2009 till at least 2014. It has stalled out. This makes me sad because I've loved working with it and I think it a great community, in most ways. But it is true that the community has been unable to answer some of the criticisms leveled against it. The reliance on Emacs has meant it is not easy for beginners. On the other side, the elite (the purists?) have wanted to see Clojure be more like Scheme, or more like Racket, or more like Haskell. Clojure has offered up many interesting ideas, but perhaps hasn't quite built a complete eco-system that makes it broadly appealing. Elixir, though very small, still seems to be moving forward, and perhaps has a chance to answer some of the demands that people made of Clojure (more pure? easier syntax?). Maybe Elixir is the language that make the Functional style the dominant style in computer programming?
- sotojuan 10y agoElixir's doing very well for its age—before 1.0 it had four books, a conference, and a dedicated video series. With the rise of Phoenix there's quite a lot mire of resources for it.
- davidgrenier 10y agoI don't think it matters much what these charts say as long as they do not measure merit and Clojure has a lot of it. You can use it irrespective of how an ill-advised majority of developers think Javascript/Node/Angular is good.
- lkrubner 10y agoPlease think about what you are saying when you write "You can use it irrespective of how an ill-advised majority of developers think Javascript/Node/Angular is good." Most of the places I work will only allow the use of a language that is in the top 10. I am not allowed to introduce Clojure, because it is not popular enough. But if I told management "We should use Angular" that would be an easy sell. You sentence would be more accurate if you had simply written: "You can use Javascript/Node/Angular irrespective of how good they are, but you can't use something that is great because a sometimes ill-advised majority of managers base their decisions on their estimate of future risks."
- jballanc 10y agoHmm...I wish they had taken a bit more time to dig into the situation with Julia than simply to note it moved from position 51 to 52 on the ranking (is that even a significant shift?). Having just come from giving a presentation at this year's JuliaCon, I am more optimistic about Julia's future than at any point in the past. I think what we're seeing here is that Julia is making a concerted push toward v1.0. It was announced at JuliaCon 2016 that they are targeting JuliaCon 2017 for the v1.0 release. It should be expected, then, that the break-neck pace of innovation has taken a back seat to a focus on stability, but based on what is already on the roadmap for Julia v2.0, I don't see Julia moving anywhere but up. (Also, I think the comparison to CoffeeScript is rather unfortunate. In my mind, CoffeeScript was primarily addressing shortcomings in JS that JS has, since, done quite a bit to rectify. Julia is not trying to be a better "X", so there's no "X" to steal away its momentum.)
- tanlermin 10y agoDo you see it replacing python for non DS? What is on Julia 2.0?
- ced 10y agoThe juliacon videos are online. See here for Julia 2.0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gXMpbY1kJY&t=1250 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gXMpbY1kJY&t=1250
- jballanc 10y agoI think there's a general misconception that Julia is a DS/scientific programming focused language. It just so happens that these are areas where its advantages are most apparent, and give the biggest early wins. Given enough time, though, I think the paradigms that Julia is exploring will make it a killer general-purpose language. As for Julia 2.0, it was decided to put off implementation of traits and interfaces until then. That said, some of the ideas that were being bounced around during the post-con Hack day in these areas are really exciting. In short: Julia may be the first language to pull off behavioral typing in a practically usable way.
- flukus 10y agoSo apart from swift and go, things have been extremely static for ~5 years? I'm guessing that VB uptick was from VB devs finally discovering git?
- SwellJoe 10y agoMaybe it was around about the time Microsoft started adding git support to their Visual products? (I don't know, as I don't really use any Microsoft products, but I know Microsoft did embrace git and a lot of OSS tech over the past few years.)
- na85 10y agoMisleading title. It's entirely github and SO-centric and as such misrepresents C and probably C++ as well, since those languages have scads of code elsewhere.
- guidedlight 10y agoI tend to agree. I believe JavaScript is misrepresented too, mainly because many of other languages would include JavaScript modules, that are mostly copy/pasted because those other languages don't have a mechanism to reference a JavaScript module.
- vegabook 10y agoI love this ranking because while all rankings have flaws, this at least is very transparent on how it works, it's parsimonious, it is entirely numerical, easily reproducible, and it gives us at least a small amount of cross validation via two (mostly) orthogonal variables. Now all we need to do is to animate the plot over time.....
- xerophyte12932 10y agoI know right? The fact that the metric makes absolute sense is beautiful. Yes it probably misses out on a ton of factors that contribute to ranking (see TIOBE index metrics) but the transparency and simplicity of it all make up for it. You can directly see how each metric is contributing to the factor and the numbers are very easily verifiable.
- sogrady 10y agoThe reasons you cite are certainly the reasons we found the original analysis by Drew and John compelling. It's not a perfect analysis, in part because there isn't one, but we've found it interesting both as a snapshot in time and for observing long term trends.
- asdfzxc 10y agoI wonder why Hardware Description Languages don't make the cut here?
- Kidney 10y agohttp://yudaherbal.com/ http://yudaherbal.com/ http://yudaherbal.com/deep-sea-fish-oil-softgel/ http://yudaherbal.com/deep-sea-fish-oil-softgel/ http://yudaherbal.com/kidney-care-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/kidney-care-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/lecithin-softgel/ http://yudaherbal.com/lecithin-softgel/ http://yudaherbal.com/cordyceps-plus-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/cordyceps-plus-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/gastric-health-tablet/ http://yudaherbal.com/gastric-health-tablet/ http://yudaherbal.com/kidney-care-capsule-for-men/ http://yudaherbal.com/kidney-care-capsule-for-men/ http://yudaherbal.com/manfaat-slimming-capsule-green-world/ http://yudaherbal.com/manfaat-slimming-capsule-green-world/ http://yudaherbal.com/eye-care-softgel/ http://yudaherbal.com/eye-care-softgel/ http://yudaherbal.com/vig-power-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/vig-power-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/hepatsure-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/hepatsure-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/manfaat-ovary-nutrition-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/manfaat-ovary-nutrition-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/ganoderma-plus-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/ganoderma-plus-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/triflex-capsule/ http://yudaherbal.com/triflex-capsule/ http://obatacemaxstradisional.com/ http://obatacemaxstradisional.com/ http://khasiatqnc.jellygamatgoldgtradisional.com/ http://khasiatqnc.jellygamatgoldgtradisional.com/ http://manfaatjellygamatgoldg.com/ http://manfaatjellygamatgoldg.com/ http://qncjellygamattradisional.com/ http://qncjellygamattradisional.com/ http://kataloggreenworld.com/ http://kataloggreenworld.com/
- andyidsinga 10y agohaving only looked at the graph, it seems like this is could also be interpreted as discussion rate vs implementation(usage) rate (??)
- SwellJoe 10y agoIt's interesting how stubbornly reliable old things stick around, despite popular negative opinion of those reliable old things.
- nhaliday 10y agoThat reasoning is plausible, but a large portion of their longevity could easily be due to network effects (libraries + legacy code) and nothing to do with the quality of the languages.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoThat is certainly true but I wonder if this effect is exaggerated by the methodology of this study. If they simply count existing lines of code/SO questions and none of those ever get deleted, then inertia is bound to increase. The more old lines of code/questions there are, the longer it takes for any new language to rise in the rankings, even if the new language is used for all new code. But I don't know enough about the methodology of this study. Maybe they are doing something against this statistical incumbency effect.
- sergiotapia 10y ago1. Legacy code too expensive to replace. Or even stupid to replace. 2. Talent pool in said languages.
- terda12 10y agoWell is there really any incentive to change? Code is just a method of communication with the computer, just like language is. Sure a country like France could move over to speaking English instead of French and probably be a little better off for it, but fundamentally, French gets the job done just fine. There's too much inertia to change amongst established companies I think.
- adamnemecek 10y agoI've heard this opinion that technology never disappears. Like there are users even for the most primitive technology.
- flohofwoe 10y agoWhen looking at github-provided data it doesn't make sense to differ between C++, C and Objective-C/C++ since the detection for these languages is still completely broken. For instance this project doesn't have a single line of Objective-C in it, yet github says there's 9% Obj-C in it: https://github.com/floooh/yakc https://github.com/floooh/yakc. Similar oddities in my other C++ projects.
- bluetomcat 10y agoI have a bunch of repositories written in pure C (no C++) with a few Makefiles and some supporting shell scripts. When I google my name, the result from GitHub has the following description: "my_username has X repositories written in Shell, Makefile, C++, and C. Follow their code on GitHub."
- 0xmohit 10y agoProbably worth reporting to Language Servant [0]. [0] https://github.com/github/linguist https://github.com/github/linguist
- insulanian 10y agoTypeScript is really getting traction. I think it will explode when AngularJS 2.0 is finally released.
- cloverich 10y agoI think its going to outpace Angular as a point of its popularity, as it seems to be gaining support throughout the javascript communities (including React!). I started using it in my React projects only a month ago, but it's been so beneficial I honestly already can't imagine going back.
- myth_drannon 10y agoWhy not Flow ?
- cloverich 10y agoWe actually started with Flow, and at the time I'd assumed it was the more popular, robust, and entrenched one. Its definitely the opposite tooling wise, and that's our main reasoning for using it (over Flow). Flow seemed like a better overall typings layer (Im absolutely not qualified to judge this) but a common suggestion here on HN was "They are more similar than different, learn one and you learn the other" -- so we dove in with the one with more mature tooling. I worried it would be harder to integrate than Flow -- it is somewhat -- but its not been a major issue. Its not flawless, but overall its been a fantastic boost to (personallly, my) productivity (code completion, free documentation, and more-correct code).
- eevilspock 10y ago> There is no movement, in fact, among languages ranked within our Top 10. > the difficulty of growth is proportional to the rankings themselves – as one rises, so does the other. OF COURSE this will be the case when your analysis is looking at total cumulative usage instead of current usage (i.e. deltas in cumulative usage)! For example, say language X has been around 20 years, and language Y 5. Language Y could be 10 times more popular than language X today, but if the analysis is counting 20 years of accumulated code in X, X will easily rank higher. I hunted for their methodology, and found none. Nothing they say indicates they are doing delta analysis. Since such analysis would not be trivial and be a lot more expensive, I'm pretty sure they'd mention it if they were doing it. To corroborate my criticism, the TIOBE Index, which measures signals where accumulation is less a factor, shows much more movement over time, with languages rising and falling as one would expect: http://www.tiobe.com/tiobe_index http://www.tiobe.com/tiobe_index.
- IshKebab 10y agoIt would be interesting to compare the number of stars of different language projects on github, rather than the number of projects.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cm2187 10y agoUnrelated but still annoying. This website is a prime example of responsive design gone wrong. Trying to read it on an iphone, but the chart with the trends overflows out of the screen, and the website locked the ability to zoom out. In this example as often, the website would be more readable without responsive design.
- pieterr 10y agoIf you scroll down to the bottom, you can select the Desktop version of the website, which allows zooming on the iPhone.
- rezashirazian 10y agoHaskell is more popular than Swift? That's surprising.
- frou_dh 10y agoSurprises me that there's apparently so much Haskell code out there (in absolute terms), given its reputation as the archetypical "high barrier to entry" language. Maybe the people who do get comfortable with it end up using it a _lot_.
- sogrady 10y agoMuch of this is attributable to these rankings being counting stats rather than rate states, which makes age an asset. There's a surprising amount of Haskell in existence, but certainly if you're looking at rate at present Swift is growing far more quickly.
- jmnicolas 10y agoNo mention of Dart, is it dead ?
- elchief 10y agowho cares
- dang 10y agoPlease stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- pjmlp 10y agoIt is connected to the machine, apparently Google Ads is keeping it relevant. When Google own teams rather use Typescript, it speaks a lot about it.
- sogrady 10y agoDart held static at 37, which leaves it 11 spots behind TypeScript. We have seen very little movement in the language generally, and it hasn't really gotten any notable boosts from outside drivers.
- 0xmohit 10y agoWish it was possible to zoom http://redmonk.com/hist-rankings-full.html http://redmonk.com/hist-rankings-full.html
- sogrady 10y agoThe rCharts package we're using doesn't handle that, but if there's interest we can look into releasing a larger version.
- TickleSteve 10y agoSince when was "Arduino" a language?? Its C++, just hidden.
- frik 10y agoIt's more C with some macros. The Arduino UNO and older classic Arduino models like Mega had only a few KB of memory, you want to keep an eye on the resources and in many cases even avoid malloc. The compiler supports a limited C++ dialect. http://www.nongnu.org/avr-libc/user-manual/FAQ.html#faq_cplusplus http://www.nongnu.org/avr-libc/user-manual/FAQ.html#faq_cplu... (Not sure about the newer hardware with ARM CPUs and newer tools.)
- TickleSteve 10y agoNo, Arduino uses the standard avr-gcc as its toolchain: https://www.arduino.cc/en/Hacking/BuildProcess https://www.arduino.cc/en/Hacking/BuildProcess 'Arduino' is simply a set of C/C++ frameworks for the peripherals and a simple IDE.
- ric129 10y agoIt's C++, I recall using C++11 constructs on a recent Arduino project.
- pjmlp 10y agoMost people using it don't have computing background, if you watch Arduino presentations most will actually refer to Sketches as a programming language.
- TickleSteve 10y ago...and they would be correct. It is a programming language... Its just that its called C++... and it isn't a distinct and separate language. This study is generated by and aimed at people who know the difference. Therefore, its a mistake.
- themihai 10y agoI was hopping for more from Rust :|
- neverminder 10y agoRust is steadily rising on Tiobe, currently #44. It will get there.
- nutheracc 10y agoAhead of Elixir on the chart, to my surprise, pleasantly.
- nutheracc 10y agoDown-voted, haha. It's not an insult or criticism of Elixir, simply my preference for Rust. Delicate people :)
- kpmah 10y agoRust is a very useful and pragmatic language, and probably the best one in its niche. I don't think you have much to worry about. As things stand right now, it's not going anywhere.
- fermigier 10y agoAFAICT (based on years of poking around various projects, and based on the data they provide on my own projects), the data provided by GitHub are largely broken. Making analyses and comments on these data is futile, as I have already argued directly (and with vigour on my side) with several Redmonk employees in the past. This didn't end well, since I'm pretty passionate about these things in particular, and "the truth" in general (vs. "opinions"). I'm sure real scientists could do some interesting work on this subject, but Redmonk's methodology is anything but scientific, and in consequence, their results are just content marketing, not something that you should base business or engineering decisions upon.
- machbio 10y ago"GitHub language rankings are based on raw lines of code, which means that repositories written in a given language that include a greater amount of code in a second language (e.g. JavaScript) will be read as the latter rather than the former." This has huge impact on the ranking - it does not seem right to me..
- edoceo 10y agoSeems like lines of JS would get counted a lot. So many copies of various versions of jquery et al.
- gavinpc 10y agoTeX has its own stackexchange site [0], and so does Emacs [1]. While both TeX and Emacs Lisp questions are still treated on StackOverflow, it probably explains why TeX in particular appears to be such an outlier. (It's sure not because people aren't having trouble with it. The stackexchange site is indispensable.) [0] http://tex.stackexchange.com/ http://tex.stackexchange.com/ [1] http://emacs.stackexchange.com/ http://emacs.stackexchange.com/
- munyari 10y agoDon't forget about the vi/vim stack exchange
- habosa 10y agoSomehow there are more Github projects in FORTRAN than Elixir. This blows my mind.
- hellofunk 10y agoNo reason it should blow your mind. Aside from the fact that Fortran has been around decades longer than Elixir, it is still the language of choice for vast areas of the scientific and technical industries, because of certain ways it works that no other language offers for high-speed computation.
- chmaynard 10y agoYou are making a broad characterization of Fortran as superior in "certain ways" to other languages. I'd love to read a justification of that claim, perhaps in a blog post. One could argue that because Cobol is the language of choice for large banks using mainframes, it is superior at doing tasks required by financial applications. Somehow I doubt that it has anything to do with that.
- hellofunk 10y agoThere have been several discussions here on HN recently about some of the particular features of Fortran that I'm referring to.
- chmaynard 10y agoI did a quick Algolia search for stories posted in the last year on HN with "Fortran" in the title. I couldn't find any articles that compare Fortran language/compiler features with other languages. Maybe you could help me out?
- hellofunk 10y agoYou're not searching very hard. Here's one, with some comments from me: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11938405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11938405
- dingleberry 10y agoit seems that the interesting languages fall more on github side the popular languages seems to fall more on stack overflow side those on the line are vanillas