5 ms·
I mean, you could argue that maybe the military would be better, but a military coup of an elected leader doesn't just "seem" undemocratic; it is undemocratic b
by emodendroket 10y ago
I mean, you could argue that maybe the military would be better, but a military coup of an elected leader doesn't just "seem" undemocratic; it is undemocratic by any reasonable standard.
- pluma 10y agoTrue, but then it becomes a matter of contrasting the will of the "demos" with the ideals that need to be upheld to ensure the future well-being of the people. There are very few actual democracies in existence today. There is a reason most democratic countries don't put every decision to a public vote and why there are often certain laws no government is allowed to change. You can agree or disagree with the priorities Atatürk set in place but from his point of view even an elected leader can become a traitor and enemy of the state and it's the duty of the military to stop him (because they are the only power not directly under the government's control and are able to resist with force if necessary unlike e.g. supreme court judges).
- tptacek 10y agoYou can say that a coup is in the long term interest of the people or not, just as you could say that a permanent military junta might better serve the people than the AKP. What the comment you're replying to is correctly pointing out is that what you can't say about a coup is that it's democratic. It's the opposite of democratic.
- ivanca 10y agoIt may not be democratic, but it certainly not the opposite of democratic. Let's put it this way, let's say 60% of people vote to kill the other 40%. And then a third party enters and stops such madness. You know who is more democratic of them all? The third party, for allowing the existence of more than one party. A coup can be more democratic than any election. It's all about context.
- tptacek 10y agoYou are confusing "justified" with "democratic".
- ivanca 10y agoFor democracy to exist the "demo" part must persist. So no, I'm not.
- tptacek 10y agoIf it's that simple, if you can just make decisions by fiat based on some set of core principles, no matter what the people say, then you don't need to take account of the popular will at all. Just have a government of philosopher-kings. In reality, it's in no way the simple ground truth that Turkish coups have uniformly sought to achieve "greater democracy". What they are in fact is a terrible misfeature of the Turkish system; a way in which Turkey joins the ranks of Pakistan and Egypt on a faster or slower arc towards autocracy. Which is the other word for "democracy that remains democratic until the people do something that make you uncomfortable".
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>what you can't say about a coup is that it's democratic // How so? If there's a dictator in power and the majority of the people want to return to a democratic election and the only way to remove the dictator is with a [violent] coup - how is that not democratic? How can the imposition of a democratic system by the majority will of the demos _not_ be democratic? [I'm not claiming that the situation in Turkey was supported by the majority or not, just trying to drill down on the general point of what [you consider] is democratic].
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ajmurmann 10y agoWhat does an elected leader have to do to warrant a coup? Dismantle the democracy? Randomly start killing people? Start death camps? Where do you draw the line or do you have non? Edit: typos
- emodendroket 10y agoNo matter how justified or not the coup is, the military overthrowing an elected leader is as close to the opposite of any notion of democracy as I can imagine.
- ivanca 10y agoStop repeating the same nonsense, an elected leader cannot crush his opposition and still be expected to be called a democracy.
- tptacek 10y agoFirst, please don't call other comments "nonsense". It degrades the thread and makes your own comment far less persuasive. It's also something the site guidelines tell you not to do. Second, just because a coup is overthrowing an elected government that, having achieved power, is subverting democracy, doesn't mean the coup is itself democratic. A military coup is the opposite of democracy. Democracy has been restored in plenty of countries previously ruled by authoritarians without recourse to the military.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>"Democracy has been restored in plenty of countries previously ruled by authoritarians without recourse to the military." // World politics isn't my strong suit, could you give a few examples? Thanks.
- tptacek 10y agoIndia, the Velvet Revolution in Czechoslovakia, the Philippines, &c.
- amyjess 10y ago"Undemocratic" isn't a bad thing. Democracy is nothing more than two wolves and a sheep deciding what to eat for dinner.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoIt's pithy, it highlights the problem of the Tyranny of the Majority, but I feel democracy has more about it than that. To borrow your analogy: In general there are more sheep than wolves, but the wolves have a habit of twisting things - gerrymandering will give them a fresh kill for every vote.
- toyg 10y agoThis sort of analysis has already been done in the last century, but it seems like it's recently been drowned out by misinformation. Suffice to say, a modern democracy is supposed to have strong safeguards for minorities; take filibustering, for example, or the various human-rights courts and treaties. Modern democracy is not just "one head, one vote", or there would be no safeguards against a new Holocaust.