4 ms·
As the article explains, the product is actually worse, but much cheaper, and in absolute terms it's "good enough" since the better product is over-serving its
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
As the article explains, the product is actually worse, but much cheaper, and in absolute terms it's "good enough" since the better product is over-serving its market.
This is pretty much the textbook definition of disruptive innovation.
- ckastner 10y agoBut it's the same product, albeit a budget version of it. If the products differ only in quality and price, that's not disruption, that's simple competition.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoA pizza in a restaurant, a pizza in a supermarket and a pizza delivery are all pizzas, but they're not the same product and differences in price is only one factor.
- ckastner 10y ago> A pizza in a restaurant, a pizza in a supermarket and a pizza delivery are all pizzas, but they're not the same product If the product is "pizza", then of course they are the same product. Lay out a salami pizza from a restaurant, supermarket and delivery next to each other on plates and they will (mainly) differ only in quality and price.
- macintux 10y agoYes, if you ignore everything that makes them different, they do look the same.
- ckastner 10y agoOK. What differences do you see between three plates of salami pizza that is not purely a difference in the quality of their ingredients (floor, water, cheese, tomato sauce, salami, etc) and the composition of these?
- halcyondaze 10y agoRestaurant pizza: - Atmosphere - Service - No effort Supermarket: - Convenience - Have to cook and serve yourself - Independent of time, have it whenever you want Delivery - Service without moving location
- ckastner 10y agoNone of these points matter when the three pizzas are already in front of you, on three separate plates, which is why I brought up this particular scenario twice. I think it is obvious that we (including the other participants in the thread) have vastly different points of view on this topic. To me, the "pizza" example is simply about the end result: what you shove in your mouth. To the other participants, the pizza is much more than that. For example, you mentioned "atmosphere" with restaurant pizza. To me, that has nothing to do with the pizza; the dining experience is an entirely different product itself (a service), and applies to various non-pizza dishes as well. To emphasize why I believe this, and as food for thought (no pun intended), here in Austria, virtually all pizza delivery services are operated by pizzerias. In other words, in this particular case, the restaurant pizza and the delivery pizza would be identical. The difference would lie only in the mode in which you acquire the pizza -- the service product. While I obviously still favor my point of view, I can also understand why you favor yours.
- halcyondaze 10y agoFair points!
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoOne of them hasn't been cooked.
- macintux 10y agoThe original point was that the "product" is much more than just the pizza.
- bdavisx 10y agoIs it really worse? Are 5 blades really better than 3? If they are, they aren't much better. It was all marketing and mark-up because they had the market.
- douche 10y agoOne (sharp) blade is better than three. I haven't shaved in years, but when I did, I gave up on the disposable multi-blade razors that cost far too much and degraded too rapidly, and got an old style Schick injector razor, along with about $20 worth of good-quality, German, replacement blades. I've still got quite a few left from that purchase - you could use one blade for a month of daily shaving with the slightest amount of care.
- imtringued 10y agoIt's slightly easier to cut yourself (this depends on the type of blades you pick and your experience with them) In all other aspects they are actually better. There is no proprietary cartridge handle, they last quite a long time and the best part is that they are very cheap.
- Bartweiss 10y agoIs it "disruptive innovation" though? It's textbook competition, and textbook efficient markets, but the product is exceedingly similar, and the subscription model isn't what's causing the shift. This just looks to me like competition in a formerly-monopolized space.
- fisherjeff 10y agoI think his article actually uses the term disruption a lot more aptly than most others. The implication is that the entire business model of these major conglomerates is now threatened. The cushy budgets P&G, et. al., have used to their great advantage for the last 70 years now look vulnerable when faced with competitors with business models like DSC's.