12 ms·
> If California wants to lower their housing prices That's the rub, after you've constrained supply and inflated prices, there's a vested interest of those who
by kbenson 10y ago
> If California wants to lower their housing prices
That's the rub, after you've constrained supply and inflated prices, there's a vested interest of those who've seen their values increase and those who bought at high values to not let them drop.
This is especially important for those that bought at a high value, as if the worth of their house drops, then they can find themselves in a position where they owe much more than the house is worth. We've seen this situation before, not too long ago. It's not pretty.
AFAICT, the trick is to manage growth effectively in an area through restrictions and incentives so that you try to stabilize house prices as much as possible (like the economy), such as tracking inflation and/or some other indicators. If you enact regulations that suppress new housing when demographics call for more of it, you need to offset that with incentives.
The worst thing that can happen is that a group will wrest disproportionate control over housing policy for an extended period, and then the policies they enact through self interest spiral out of control and make the situation worse for everyone.
- jdavis703 10y agoWhy can't you just live in the house? I mean it sucks when your investment doesn't work out, but at least you have a roof over your head. Isn't that all you really need (unless you're some kind of real estate mogul, in which case it's hard to feel bad since it's just business then).
- nostrademons 10y agoIt works as long as you maintain the income you had when you qualified for the loan. The problem is that real-estate downturns are heavily correlated with economic downturns and job losses. The bloodbath isn't people with stable jobs suddenly wanting out of their homes because they're underwater (although you do sometimes get that too), it's people who buy a house they can barely afford and then lose their job.
- danhak 10y agoReal estate is usually leveraged. You don't simply get to keep living in a house if you are insolvent and owe more on the property than it is worth. See also: 2008 Global Financial Crisis.
- morgante 10y agoSure you do. As long as you can continue to pay the mortgage each one, nobody is going to come along and kick you out of the house. The "problem" is that you can't sell your house for a profit to exchange it for an even more expensive house. Hence, the rest of us are on the hook to ensure that your house can continue to appreciate in price.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Real estate is usually leveraged. You don't simply get to keep living in a house if you are insolvent and owe more on the property than it is worth. Right, but the problem there is the insolvency, not being underwater (conceptually, you have the same problem if you are insolvent but owe a nonzero amount that is less than or equal to the worth of the property, though if its less you may be able to stay off insolvency by increasing indebtedness -- though that will probably take convincing a lender that your income/expense balance will change soon enough that you won't end up insolvent and overleveraged.)
- kbenson 10y agoBecause a significant portion of many, many peoples' savings and retirements are tied up in the value of their housing. Whether you think that's a smart choice of them or not, it's the reality we live in.
- shostack 10y agoIn addition to the other accurate responses, there's also the notion that these days, most people are not buying their "forever home" that they will "just live in." They are buying a ($1m+) "starter home" and then hoping to ladder their way up into what might be their "forever home." That involves selling at some point.
- josh-wrale 10y agoReal estate taxes don't bother with purchase price and many times lag behind market value (for better or worse).
- danhak 10y agoIt's even worse than that. In California, Prop 13 has de-coupled property taxes from market value altogether, essentially subsidizing landlords in perpetuity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(1978) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(197...
- dragonwriter 10y ago> In California, Prop 13 has de-coupled property taxes from market value altogether Incorrect; there are limits to annual increases in tax basis value outside of qualifying events (changes of ownership, new construction on property, etc.), but tax basis isn't divorced from market value altogether.
- wrong_variable 10y ago>The proposition decreased property taxes by assessing property values at their 1975 value and restricted annual increases of assessed value of real property to an inflation factor, not to exceed 2% per year. Sounds pretty insane.
- clock_tower 10y agoThis is why you don't really want to live under a democracy (always assuming you can find a non-democracy that respects human rights). California's government-by-referendum has made it impossibly dysfunctional, because the populace consistently votes for two types of referendum: "spend money on things I like" and "don't raise my taxes."
- seanp2k2 10y agoYeah, it's hard to argue that 20% yearly increases in SF rent are fine while property owners get limited to 2% .
- eldavido 10y agoBecause housing in California is just different than the rest of the US; there's really no other way to describe it (Illinois born and raised, now living in SF). A lot of CA people explicitly treat their home equity as their retirement fund, planning to "cash it out" when they retire. Then there's the people with loans they might be cashflow-negative on month-to-month (paying down a sliver of principal), who are hoping to re-amortize into a new 30-year loan when their value goes up, hopefully cutting some of their payments. I'm 31. My household income is well over 200K and I have many friends in the same boat, and none -- I really mean it -- zero -- of us own homes. The only hope is to get into a "starter home" as some other commenters describe and then hope to have enough equity that if you ever want to have a kid or live in a non-shoebox, you'll be able to afford to make a big down payment on a new place. I hate this because it seems extremely financially imprudent, but realistically, your options are to play the game or move. There just isn't sanity in/around the Bay Area housing market.
- galdosdi 10y agoThis is why I don't understand (at a practical/economic level) the allure in the tech world of moving to the Bay Area. In NYC we complain like crazy about housing, but it's honestly fine compared to what you describe. In NYC you can't have it all but you do get to pick any two of: spacious, cheap, or short commute. Apparently in the Bay Area it's pick any zero? Why do people keep going there?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Apparently in the Bay Area it's pick any zero? No, its not. You can find spacious, reasonably cheap places within tolerable -- though not short -- commutes of most Bay Area jobs. I suspect that young, high-income tech workers very often (1) want short commutes, and (2) want other aspects of the urban lifestyle of the core of the Bay Area whether or not it comes with a short commute, which makes the peripheral, long-commute places with such housing unattractive. (Plenty of families where the adults work in the core areas of the Bay Area do live in those peripheries, though.) > Why do people keep going there? Because that's where the (tech, for instance) jobs are?
- imh 10y agoMany young-ish people live in 1 bedroom apartments they own, while planning to sell it eventually for a multiple room place they can raise a family in. If there is a permanent downturn, it screws them.
- mjevans 10y agoThe price of housing is over-inflated. You don't want that price to be normal. It could be argued that the valuation on their property being out of whack is an issue of mismanagement by the local government. In that case a better approach might be to allow for a majority of that improper pricing to be written off over a number of years as a tax credit.
- kbenson 10y ago> The price of housing is over-inflated. You don't want that price to be normal. Yes. The problem is when it's already become normal, what do you do? > It could be argued that the valuation on their property being out of whack is an issue of mismanagement by the local government. Yes, that's exactly what I was arguing. > In that case a better approach might be to allow for a majority of that improper pricing to be written off over a number of years as a tax credit. Which is another way of saying that we, as the entire constituency of that tax base (be it local, state or federal), have decided to subsidize the poor planning (to give the benefit of a doubt) of those local governments and try to correct the issue. While probably the most likely to actually work, I'm not holding my breath, as if the pain isn't spread over a significantly larger population than the original problem, it will be hard to survive for the tax payers, and if is is spread, you run into the problem of people not wanting to pay to fix the problems of others (as short sighted as it is, as it stabilizes things overall).
- mjevans 10y agoYou're already feeling that pain, in housing or not. The dysfunction is systemic and it's influence spreads. It's like not having universal healthcare; the problem manifests to a point where too expensive to ignore any longer cases show up in the ER. Then it gets built in to the prices everyone that can pay pays.
- kbenson 10y agoYes, we're in agreement on that. I just don't think we've developed good enough structures of governance nor a good enough culture of rational thinking to believe there's much hope for the overall problem in the near-to-medium term future. We might hack away at some of the symptoms, but the human psyche is inherently ill suited for rationally weighing the needs of disparate peoples and how they effect us in complex systems like this, being as our neurology evolved for smaller groups/tribes. At least that's my pseudo-psychology take on it.
- TruthAndDare 10y ago> That's the rub That might be part of it, but it's not exactly obvious that you'd want to live in a place with 50-story buildings either.
- davidw 10y agoIf there's no market for them, they won't get built. But people want to live in places like NY and San Fran for the economic opportunities they provide, not just for "the character of the neighborhood".
- bitwize 10y agoWhen the economic opportunities overrun the "character of the neighborhood", neighborhoods get destroyed and people get priced out of their own homes. It's called gentrification.
- morgante 10y ago> people get priced out of their own homes Wrong. Adding supply lowers prices, not increases them. The fact that wealthy rentiers in the Bay Area have somehow convinced activists that they should oppose new development is farcical. Liberal activists are literally protesting to enrich capitalists.
- davidw 10y agoUh, if you have been following along, you may have noticed that most people cannot afford the bay area as it is. Adding some supply might help things, rather than make them worse.
- lgieron 10y agoHow can you be priced out of your own home? If you own it, you don't have to pay anything (unless you mean they cannot afford property taxes).
- jdhzzz 10y ago
- monknomo 10y agoI'm not convinced that the price of existing houses would drop that much. We're talking comparing comparatively large single family homes to probably tallish apartment buildings. They don't compete for quite the same market, and since you'd have to knock over a few SFHs, they might even go up in price, since yards, space and privacy would become rarer. Of course good luck convincing J. Random Householder of that
- maerF0x0 10y agoAlternatives affect the pricing of a good.
- monknomo 10y agoSure, that's a given. But we're not exactly talking interchangeable widgets. Are you telling me that new towers in Manhattan really damage the value of the remaining single family houses on the island?
- brianwawok 10y agoThey impact it. I see this in Chicago. Graph price of single family 3 bedroom home and 3 bedroom condo. The prices track. The SFH is worth about double... When condo prices fell in 2008, SFH prices fell too.
- dogma1138 10y agoHasn't everything fell in 2008? Correlation doesn't not mean causation. It's like saying that building 2000 affordable apartments in London would bring down the price of the multimillion luxury apartments.
- brianwawok 10y agoI don't think that a 200k apartment and a 5 million dollar luxury apartment are substitutes. In Chicago, a 300k condo and a 600k single family home ARE substitutes. I know many people that could afford either. As the delta shifts one way or another, more of them will opt for the other choice.