4 ms·
How is ARM "our national asset"? It was owned by pension funds and institutions, both at home and overseas. It's now owned by a different, but also publicly t
by rwmj 10y ago
How is ARM "our national asset"? It was owned by pension funds and institutions, both at home and overseas. It's now owned by a different, but also publicly traded company, which is also owned by pension funds etc etc you get the idea.
Many people work at ARM, some in Cambridge UK and some abroad. Those people - some of the smartest people I know - are still around, and even if ARM were to dramatically collapse under the new management, they would get jobs elsewhere very quickly. Perhaps they'd join start ups developing RISC-V chips, which would be a net benefit to everyone.
- makomk 10y agoI think most of the value of ARM is in its IP rather than anything else. There are plenty of good chip designers around, and the best ARM cores are often the ones designed by other companies, but ARM is ubiquitous because it's well-established and there's a lot of code written for it.
- edent 10y ago> How is ARM "our national asset"? It is UK based. The profits it makes, and people it employs, have a direct effect on our national and local budgets. It attracts high-class talent to the UK, further increasing its national importance. The services it creates acts as an excellent advertisement for the UK's technology industry. As you point out, many UK pensions schemes are invested in it. Personally, I'm not entirely comfortable with the phrase "national asset" - but that's the common term used. > if ARM were to dramatically collapse under the new management, they would get jobs elsewhere very quickly. Tell that to those employed by Nokia.
- rwmj 10y agoNone of this stuff about "national importance" moves me. If ARM was based in France then people from Cambridge UK would still be able to work there, either by moving house or remotely. For a company which is purely based on IPR and software it's completely unnecessary for the networks to be colocated. (Hardware is of course quite a bit different, but maybe that will change in future) FWIW I work, from home in the UK, for a multinational software company which is largely based in the US.
- daleharvey 10y agoIt is not a national asset because people could move to france and participate in the french economy ...? I also work from home in the UK for a multinational software company largely based in the US, but I understand that not every company is organised the same way.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago> If ARM was based in France then people from Cambridge UK would still be able to work there, either by moving house or remotely. // People may not be able to work in France after Britain leaves the EU so a company relying on moving those people would be on shaky ground at the moment.
- rwmj 10y agoThat's merely another reason why Brexit is such a bad idea. My point is why is ARM a "UK national asset" when if it were located only about 200 miles away it could be a "French national asset", and really it would make hardly any difference to anyone. The ownership would be the same (pension funds etc). The people working for it would be the same. If it does make a difference at all, that's just because we (humans) make it difficult for ourselves, not for any real reason. In fact ARM has several offices in France (http://www.arm.com/about/company-profile/locations-around-the-world.php http://www.arm.com/about/company-profile/locations-around-th...). It's only a "UK national asset" because the company is registered in the UK, for historical reasons. For all I know there are some employees in France who are so pivotal to ARM as a company that if they left the thing would collapse. If that hypothetical was true why wouldn't you call it a French national asset already? The whole thing of nationalities and borders is based on very minor and arbitrary distinctions, so any argument that we try to derive based on those assumptions quickly descends into "ex falso quodlibet".
- IneffablePigeon 10y agoIt's a UK national asset because it's _not_ located about 200 miles away. I would certainly apply for a job at ARM in the UK, but I wouldn't in France, because I don't want to live in France and I don't want to work remotely. The fact they're in the UK means that a lot of the money they make ends up here, which means more money in the economy near me and more money for the government to spend on things that benefit me. Nationalities and borders may well be arbitrary (I agree), but that doesn't mean they don't matter.
- dharma1 10y agoHow far is RISC-V from reality? Is it being worked on in the UK?