36 ms·
A Peek Inside New York's Subway Redesign Plan
- typetypetype 10y agoNew cars and polished stations. but I don't see anything about improving the actual infrastructure with more tracks, better signaling, etc. I guess we hope that those sorts of improvements are happening but are not interesting enough to write about?
- parent5446 10y agoI don't have sources available on my phone, but I believe it is something they are actively working on. The problem is it's just so much more expensive, takes a long time, and doesn't affect public opinion as much. The Wikipedia article "Signaling of the NYC Subway" has a lot of information.
- lg 10y agoi know they are working on this. but as a member of the subway-riding public, far and away the number 1 thing I have a strong opinion about is delays, which almost always are blamed on "signal problems"
- parent5446 10y agoI agree. Problem is the general public is even less informed than the people commenting on this article. They'll probably just think it's a waste of money.
- bko 10y agoDo we really need wifi and USB ports on the train? There are already a lot of wifi access points on the platform, but it requires clicking on a prompt to agree to T&C which is an extra step many don't bother taking. I'm reminded of TVs the Taxi and Limousine Commission mandated to be placed in all yellow/green cabs in NYC. It's always dubious improvements that people often don't ask for. What people really wanted was more availability as evidenced by the success of Uber. I imagine in regards to train service, New Yorkers would settle for cleaner, less smelly stations and more regular service, especially on the weekends. But I guess that wouldn't get as much press coverage.
- AznHisoka 10y agoAs well as functional clean elevators in more stations. More seats (trains like the R maximize seat/space ratio while trains like the 4/5/6 don't) Also ban bums from sleeping on trains.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Also ban bums from sleeping on trains. I think there's likely already a law against it, it's a matter of enforcement. And I for one have a hard time being mad at someone sleeping on a train at night during the winter time; shelters aren't fun places, they fill up and have stringent requirements, and for many of them, the alternative is freezing to death outside.
- astrodust 10y agoNew York's answer to the homeless problem is to throw them in jail, and considering many suffer from severe mental illness, this is really cruel and inhumane. So they're swept under the rug. It's absurd.
- cududa 10y agoCompared to San Francisco where they're let to just wry in the wind?
- astrodust 10y agoMost American cities I've visited take an indifferent and/or actively hostile attitude towards people with mental illness. It's actually kind of scary.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoYeah. If you have a family history of mental illness and live in America, make sure you've got a big support network of friends and family, in case you develop a mental illness. That would probably be more useful than healthcare coverage.
- galdosdi 10y agoWhat a complete waste of time and money. These are all very marginal nice to haves. What people want is for their subway commute to take less time, end of story. Or for those on crowded lines like the 4/5, less crowding. Maybe ease the crowding enough that you could even reach your hands into your pocket to grab your USB device to use those new USB outlets they're hyping (there's no way you could currently on many lines during peak) The only new feature worth a damn in that whole story is adding more countdown clocks, but even that just quantifies but does not in any way reduce the waiting time. Typical case of totally different priorities between NYS and NYC. Cuomo obviously does not ride the subway. NYC needs to secede already Edit: I didn't notice the price is $27 billion. This makes me angry. That's enough to make some pretty substantial "real" boring improvements that would actually improve service. According to wikipedia Phase I of the Second Ave Subway cost "just" $4.5billion. And we're going to blow $27 billion on prettier signs? Are you !@#$% kidding me? I wish I could vote against you more than once, Cuomo Edit 2: To be fair, there is one useful feature of the new trains: More space to pack more passengers with the "open gangway" design. But the rest is a waste
- mbiondi 10y agoWhenever the city spends money on projects like this, you have to remember it's more about employing people than actually improving things. Look at the 2nd avenue subway - almost 9 years to build a tunnel about a mile long. And now they are saying they may not complete it in December.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoYou didn't read well.
- parent5446 10y agoDid you even read the article? The trains have wider doors, flip up seats, and other features intended to fit more people and get people moving faster. It's literally the best they can do until they replace the outdated signaling on the tracks, which is an even more expensive project.
- jpwright 10y ago
- mc32 10y agoOn paper the improvements look nice. I don't get the preservation portion. That adds cost with little utility. Clean the stations, make them less grimy, eliminate the dark dungeon feel, dress up the load bearing beams a bit with a material where grime and soot can be easily cleaned. Put in some women only cars on the crowded lines to prevent groping... Maybe one day get a north-south line to join the outer borough lines (a peripheral line). Most lines are in and out of Manhattan, as if people didn't move interborough.
- ksenzee 10y agoIs there data on whether women-only cars work? What happens when you jump on the subway at the last second and end up in one of the other cars?
- noobermin 10y agoNot to mention that it stinks very much of segregation, which was said below by some posters although sarcastically. I think the right thing to do is to attack the pervs and the criminals. That is where the actual blame lies, right?
- therowaway947 10y agoWomen only cars - yeah, segregation on public transport is such a great idea and completely legal! /s
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> "Put in some women only cars on the crowded lines to prevent groping" Rather than delay the problem so that those people can just go and grope people somewhere else how about better CCTV so they can be caught and punished.
- swiftisthebest 10y agoWe should put in some minority only cars too! Wouldn't want that privilege to rub off.
- urda 10y ago
- hx87 10y agoHow about A/C in the stations for once? Or turning on the A/C when temperatures are moderate but humidity is high? With low enough temperatures and humidity, a surprising amount of grime and overcrowding becomes bearable.
- jimktrains2 10y agoInstead of AC, I always thought it would be fun to use the heat to do something productive (like make electricity), even if not effect, it could consume the heat?
- hx87 10y agoI'm not sure if using recovered heat from the subway system to generate electricity is economically feasible (probably not). In the end you'd have to eject the heat anyway, probably to the Hudson and East rivers.
- jimktrains2 10y agoOr into the buildings above. Could the heat be used to pre-heat cold boiler water in buildings? Of the low efficiency (but no carbon?) electric could run LED lights or other small electronics. There would be a loss in converting to electric and a loss converting back to heat.
- ethnt 10y agoOn underground trains, you have to choose between air conditioning the platforms or the trains. It wouldn't be feasible (especially in old systems like New York or London) to do both because of the lack of ventilation (the hot air needs to go somewhere).
- Animats 10y agoThe big innovation seems to be trains with fewer seats and more standing space. That increases capacity, but few people get to sit down. No platform edge doors, surprisingly. Many newer systems have those. But they require that the trains all have their doors in the same places, so you can't mix types of train sets. Display signs may just duplicate info people can get on some phone app. (The MTA has an API with their train and bus position info, at least for the lines that have reporting gear.[1]) But those are cheap. [1] http://datamine.mta.info/ http://datamine.mta.info/
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Display signs may just duplicate info people can get on some phone app. If you happen to be at a station with cellular signal or wifi.
- astrodust 10y agoIf you're not a tourist without a data plan. If your phone is charged. If you're the kind of person to own a phone that can run apps. If you've taken the time to install the app. Signs are useful, people.
- cryptoz 10y ago> Display signs may just duplicate info people can get on some phone app. Public transit should never require ownership of a smartphone. All features should be accessible equally to everyone. Having an app is great, but you can't reasonably advocate for the removal of physical signs in public transport.
- cududa 10y agoOnce I'm in a large underground station I'm more likely to follow the overhead signs than rely on my phone
- andrewla 10y agoI believe the GP was referring to the train arrival and other dynamic signage, rather than the static signage that exists now. Bang for the buck, it feels like getting wifi (and cellular data) into all stations is way more useful and future-proof than a bunch of displays that are going to look quaint and outdated a year after we spend billions getting them installed. If you want to know which track is downtown, or what the stops are on the express, the existing maps and signage will get you there. If you want to know about service interruptions and arrival information (or potentially connecting train information or more detailed trip estimates based on subway traffic in the future), then unless you can understand the static coming out of the loudspeakers, you're out of luck. It's taken them more than 10 years to get arrival signs into the stations, and (as above) they already seem very outdated, with insufficient information many times (because three display lines is not enough lines for busy stations when you're waiting for a 6). Plus most stations still don't have them, which seems absurd given that every other subway system in the world has them.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI don't care about clean stations, I'd rather have stations with elevators and escalators, so the handicapped and the elderly can actually use them.
- terminado 10y agoWhy do the new subway cars always smell like bad breath is coming through the ventilation system, even when empty and recently cleaned? Is it an anti-vagrant odor, like the repellent counterpart to Subway restaurant's fresh bread fragrance?
- CDotDot 10y agoSomething as simple as the new grab bars in the middle of the car will be a great improvement. Although I'd rather it be a 3-bar split as opposed to the 2 in the mockup. That way we can still have the annoyingly frequent bar leaner and still have a place to hold on to.
- kaiizen 10y agoSo just like Seattle's light rail cars? Just much more traffic?
- noobermin 10y agoI for one mourn the fact the forces that be in my city are intent on pulling us back to 1960 transport wise. We are poised to break 1M within the next decade, and some have been floating some form of light rail to serve the quickly growing city. Unfortunately, looking at the ten year plan published recently shows that what made it in from those discussions were...widening roads. Good on NYC for attempting to put somewhere in the US on parity with other first world metropolises.
- davidf18 10y agoThe most important thing that they can do besides buying more subway cars is to computerize the driving of the subways which would double the throughput. They started experimenting with this (on the L or 7 lines?) but they should implement it more quickly.
- terminado 10y agoWhy do the new subway cars always smell like bad breath is coming through the ventilation system, even when empty and recently cleaned? Is it some kind of anti-vagrant odor, like the repellent counterpart to Subway restaurant's fresh bread fragrance?