13 ms·
Sorry, I've never been able to reconcile these claims. On the one hand, any retirement-investment seminar is going to give the stat that real estate on average
by SilasX 10y ago
Sorry, I've never been able to reconcile these claims. On the one hand, any retirement-investment seminar is going to give the stat that real estate on average has returned just a little above inflation.
OTOH, pretty much everyone's social group is full of people who bought a home that has significantly appreciated in value if they've held it 20+ years (and also saved them a ton in housing costs). What gives?
- Is there a huge chunk of homes pulling down the average?
- Is the home appreciation understating the return, after you account for interest/maintenance/tax costs?
- Is our recent experience dominated by anomalously large returns that aren't likely to continue?
- Is it an artifact of the calculation, which excludes relevant things like the imputed rental income (and not having to pay current rates)?
Does this statistic really translate into "don't worry, you won't be priced out of any booking metro area"?
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Is our recent experience dominated by anomalously large returns that aren't likely to continue? Bingo. Homes bought for capital gain are best thought of as leveraged credit bets. Where were interest rates "20+ years" ago? Where are they now? What fraction of the original investment was invested up front, i.e. down? (The last number speaks to leverage.)
- hjnilsson 10y agoIt's just the recent trend. And property prices will take a dive sooner or later. An interesting graph to keep in mind is [Amsterdam house prices](http://imgur.com/eGAE3BW http://imgur.com/eGAE3BW) adjusted for purchasing power the last 400 years. As can be seen, we just two years ago passed the all-time which ended with the Dutch Golden Age. The event that will cause the current market to collapse is not clear yet. But it undoubtedly will happen.
- breischl 10y agoThe two big reasons are incomplete accounting of holding costs, which you touched on, and ignoring inflation. Note that the article specifically talked about real returns, ie after factoring out inflation. For example, if somebody had bought a house for $100K in 1986, and sold it yesterday for $219K, they would probably be crowing about their great investment on Facebook. But in fact the cost increased by slightly under inflation, and they probably spent tens of thousands on taxes, insurance and repairs in that time. Now, they may have derived enough utility from using it as a home that it was still a good idea. But ignoring that and examining it solely as an investment, it's a money loser.
- superuser2 10y agoOTOH, the alternative use of mortgage payment money isn't index funds, it's rent, a guaranteed total loss every time. Merely keeping up with inflation (or even falling behind it by quite a bit) is GREAT compared to throwing money away that you'll never see again.
- SilasX 10y agoInterest, tax, and PMI are a total loss every time too.
- superuser2 10y agoSure, but if they even come close to rent on an otherwise comparable home something is deeply wrong.
- refurb 10y agoOf course that's assuming housing prices never go down. That never happens...right?
- superuser2 10y agoWhat? If housing prices go down to 0 the money you've paid for your house is gone. But the money you paid in rent is gone either way.
- refurb 10y agoThere are plenty of situations where renting leaves you financially better off than owning. Even in a market where housing prices are going up.
- vonmoltke 10y agoTax decreases linearly with the price of the property. At any rate, rents and taxes are sufficiently linked that tax can be ignored for the comparison. As for interest and PMI (assuming you need to pay it), I'd say housing prices falling far enough where rents start looking attractive compared to these qualifies as "something deeply wrong".
- tomarr 10y agoLeverage is the key. Someone could buy a $200k house for $20k of their own money in the form of a deposit for a mortgage. Now say house prices go up 4% a year (so probably less than S&P) for 5 years, while the mortgage interest is 1.5%. So they will have paid in approx $70k, and gained nearly $30k in asset appreciation. That's a 40% return on your cash, and you've not had to pay any rent!
- paulpauper 10y agoexactly, and this key point is ignored by Shiller Also, there are more options for homeowners who use leverage vs. stock traders who use leverage and are at the mercy of the awful brokers. For mortgages, payments can be deferred, etc.
- refurb 10y agoLeverage also has the downside of magnifying loses. Put 10% down on a $500k house. Market falls 10% and your return is -200%.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWalking away from a mortgage is significantly less painful than walking away from a margin call (or, losing actual money versus borrowed money).
- jldugger 10y ago> OTOH, pretty much everyone's social group is full of people who bought a home that has significantly appreciated in value if they've held it 20+ years (and also saved them a ton in housing costs). A) Inflation adjustment. Yes, the I grew up in hasn't quite doubled in value since 1989. In the mean time, the SP500 has grown 500 percent. B) Interest expenses add up. Renters don't pay principle or interest on principle. C) Some markets are hotter than others, and more volatile than others. SFBay for example, has had huge swings. D) Tax subsidies aren't calculated for long term returns. Mortgage interest deductions and capital appreciation are the two big ones. > Does this statistic really translate into "don't worry, you won't be priced out of any booking metro area"? It translates to "don't worry, you're better off renting a house anyways."