14 ms·
The Fake Factory That Pumped Out Real Money
- jacquesm 10y agoIt's a typical case of creating a wrong metric and then steering by it. I really don't like these 'credits' systems, the same goes for CO2 credits and all the other systems out there like this. They're a magnet for fraud and rarely if ever serve to actually remedy the issue they're aimed at. It's just a way to move money around, not to solve problems. The interesting bit here is that is actually quite hard to figure out why what they did was illegal, at first glance you'd say that the agency that created the opportunity is just as culpable as those that took advantage of it, it doesn't take genius to figure out that this would lead to trouble. http://econlife.com/2012/04/government-guidelines-and-unintended-consequences/ http://econlife.com/2012/04/government-guidelines-and-uninte...
- Pxtl 10y agoYes, that's why most economists I've read seem to agree that carbon tax is better than co2 credit cap-and-trade systems - simpler and harder to game, flawed only because it includes the word "tax" which is unpalatable to the public.
- Alex3917 10y agoA tax is actually vastly more complicated and easier to game. Remember, the goal is to cap emissions, not to raise money. When you start with a cap and work backwards towards the clearing price, you are guaranteed to be meet that cap. But when you start by setting a price, there is zero guarantee that you're going to meet your emissions target. Also, the point of cap and trade is that it lets societies meet their emissions target in the least expensive way possible. Whereas a tax imposes the same fees on everyone, regardless of how much it would cost them to lower their emissions. This makes zero sense.
- fsargent 10y agoCap and Trade and a Carbon Tax are equivalent in outcome. Cap and trade would impose fees on everyone regardless of how much it costs them to lower emissions also. The problem with Cap and Trade is that it targets the large scale emitters rather than the item desired to be limited. Imagine that you had five major producers putting out 30% of airborne carbon, and 50,000 minor producers putting out 70%. The cost of administering a cap and trade system to the minor producers would be incredibly expensive - the legislation would instead focus on gouging the five major producers. Also imagine that the 50,000 minor producers could very easily cut their production of carbon in half. The price should be set to the amount of damage the externality causes. Current estimates of the social cost of carbon is ~$220 per ton. http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nclimate2481.html http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nc... Cap and trade punishes large players - taxes are fair because they impose the same fees on everyone. Cap and Trade being the least expensive way possible is also a terrible loss for good tax reform. If we implement a responsible carbon tax, the offset income can be used to reduce associated corporation taxes, sales taxes, or even income taxes. An optimal tax system taxes things and behaviors we don't want, and subsidises things and behaviors we do want. Let's get rid of an income tax, and replace it with a environmental tax. More money in your pocket, and cleaner air.
- rayiner 10y agoAs California's attempts to tax mileage of hybrid and electric vehicles proves, if you create an additional source of revenue for the government, tax levels will bear no relation to the harm they're designed to compensate for. It becomes just another way for the government to raise taxes without admitting to doing so.
- tajen 10y ago> "tax" which is unpalatable to the public. They're right to be concerned: A tax goes to the government and the price is set wrong. What's the correct amount? $5 per barrel[1]? $25? $250? $3000? $3000 would be insane, right? The People would rise up against those who decide that price. Plus, if it's a government tax, it goes to the pocket of the government. If it's traded on the stock exchange, at least it's not the government who's to blame if the pricing is too high, and it's not the government who gets the money - it's redistribution at its most noble name[2]. There are two axes: How high it should be to reduce demand of petrol to a sustainable level, and how high to account for the cost of the global warming. CO2 emissions were stable in 1990, meaning they were consumed by plants which would emit the equivalent O2. All those policies do is attempt to come back to the levels of 1990. So we just have to let companies purchase their emission rights and see where the price goes. If we don't succeed, it will cost trillions, so again we need to factor those trillions into the cost of barrels. If we just get the cost high enough, we'll either use alternative sources or avoid spending[3]. So, yes, basically, the right cost of a barrel of petrol is the cost of switching to an alternate source, plus the cost of the damage of the global warming: It could very well be $3000. And fact is, a government isn't going to raise a $3000 tax per barrel. So, when replacing a stock-exchange-traded price with a tax, I wonder why "most economists we read seem to agree". [1] Meaning: 5% of the price of a publicly-traded barrel of petrol that have the same effect on global warming. [2] The only thing against trading emissions on the stock exchange is that a lot of people don't trust stock trading anymore. They point out speculation, HFT, subprimes. Sometimes it's a misunderstanding of the usefulness of capitalism, sometimes the public is correct (The financial industry reaps the benefits instead of the end user does). Whether or not it's right, it's extremely sad for the Earth if we replace a $3000 emission cost with a $5 carbon tax. [3] "Avoid spending" is not a light term here. It basically means a group is going to be really, really poor because we can't build enough goods for them given the CO2 limit.
- dkokelley 10y ago> that is actually quite hard to figure out why what they did was illegal How so? They produced fraudulent RINs and sold them, knowing they were not attached to actual biofuels. It's only a couple of steps removed from printing fake currency. Did I miss something in how Green Diesel justified their actions?
- jacquesm 10y agoWell, given that the buyers bought just the numbers and not did not go to the authorities immediately it would seem that everybody in the deal was happy except for the EPA. If you make it so that a number is assigned to something liquid that is as fungible as can be then you really can't claim surprise if someone then decides to short-circuit the whole thing and bypass the manufacturing step. Think of it as an optimization. After all it seems the numbers where the valuable bit, the fuel was worthless in comparison.
- kelson 10y ago> "In return for the hollow credits, ConocoPhillips paid Green Diesel $18 million, according to court documents. Shell got stung for $14.4 million, BP for $13.6 million, Marathon Oil for $12.4 million, Exxon $1.2 million. All these companies also were forced to buy new RINs to replace Rivkin’s phony ones." > Federal agents were watching, as was Houston attorney David Fettner. He’d been appointed by a court to find and seize Rivkin’s property on behalf of commodities trader VicNRG, which had sued Green Diesel and other Rivkin companies for selling it $3.8 million in bogus RINs. “Rivkin left a trail of unhappy people behind him,” he says. Doesn't seem like everyone else was happy > Well, given that the buyers bought just the numbers and not did not go to the authorities immediately it would seem that everybody in the deal was happy except for the EPA. You'd be happy buying $1000 from someone for only $100, until you discovered the money was essentially worthless (counterfeit)
- jacquesm 10y agoThey should have bought FUEL, not RINs.
- rayiner 10y agoCap and trade systems have the huge advantage that no revenue goes to the government. That eliminates the incentive to set tax levels for revenue generation purposes instead of at levels linked to the real purpose.
- fsargent 10y agoTrue, but looked at holistically it'd be better to have the revenue go to the government, and reduce a tax that punishes behaviors we want - such as employment being punished by the income tax. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax
- ac29 10y ago>Cap and trade systems have the huge advantage that no revenue goes to the government. The revenue certainly goes to the government in California, unless I am completely misunderstading the program: http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2014/budget/cap-and-trade/auction-revenue-expenditure-022414.pdf http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2014/budget/cap-and-trade/auct...
- pmorici 10y ago"The interesting bit here is that is actually quite hard to figure out why what they did was illegal" I wouldn't go that far. Each RIN needs to correspond to some physical bio-fuel. They were generating RINS but not manufacturing the corresponding fuel. Seems like straight forward fraud. Now had they been actually making the fuel but then dumping it in the trash and just selling the RIN I agree it would be harder to see what it was they were doing wrong but they weren't doing that.
- jacquesm 10y agoYou can't exactly affix a number to a specific gallon of bio-fuel. That's where the whole scheme goes off the rails, to create unique ids that only exist in spreadsheets with no 1-1 link to some quantity of product. It's a liquid, not a box of stuff.
- evan_ 10y agoExactly, it's fungible, so you don't need to track specific gallons. The point isn't to track the specific molecules that represent one specific gallon, the point is to just track that a gallon was made and sold. Nothing was made, nothing was sold, but he fraudulently tracked a creation and sale by creating the RIN.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoHow is this so difficult to imagine being games? I "sell" you 10,000 barrels of fuel. Then I give you back 99% of your money. Rinse and repeat, you've generated lots of RINs with little capacity for anyone to catch you downstream. Contrast this with a carbon tax, where in order to legally generate revenue one must pay the tax.
- timecube 10y agoRINs aren't generated when biodiesel is sold, they're generated when biodiesel is produced.
- 10y ago
- paulsutter 10y agoWhether actual fuel is exchanged - or numbers - audits are the only way to catch a cheater. A fraudulent biofuels producer could resell ordinary diesel with just a bit more effort than selling fake credits. A site visit to verify the production of actual biofuels is the method to detect either scheme, so the resolution would be no different. > The interesting bit here is that is actually quite hard to figure out why what they did was illegal This was outright fraud (creating and registering identifiers for fuel that never existed).
- rwmj 10y agoI don't know if RINs are good or bad, but I don't think you can say that this article proves anything. It might equally be that the system is open to widespread fraud, but with a bit of effort it can be made watertight. Or that there is a tiny amount of fraud which the authorities are mostly on top of, as the case of the two imprisoned felons from the article shows.
- Bromskloss 10y agoI'd much appreciate a description of the core thing here, without the narrative.
- dkokelley 10y agoBiodiesel company unable to produce quality product, resorts to selling fraudulent biofuel credits (without underlying biofuel). Founder is caught and jailed.
- brianwawok 10y agoIf you don't read the article not sure this kind of comment adds anything to the community. Yes it's a long article. If too long for you skip it.
- foobarbecue 10y agoYour comment, on the other hand, was suuuuper helpful.
- seibelj 10y agoEPA allows biodiesel refiners to make up their own serial numbers. They sell the numbers in excel spreadsheets to oil companies. No one ever verifies that the numbers match real barrels of biodiesel. Criminals moved in
- ryandrake 10y agoTHANK YOU. >3000 words to 36. These long form articles are not for everyone, a TL;DR summary is always welcome.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThat's not really a summary of the article, which is about a particular company. And the article itself already has a nice condensed explanation of the fraud: http://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-fake-biofuel-factory/img/feat_biofraud30_1200x720.png http://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-fake-biofuel-factory/...
- mrob 10y agoMethanol is not a catalyst in biodiesel production, it's a reactant. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biodiesel_production#Transesterification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biodiesel_production#Transeste... This example shows ethanol but it works the same way with methanol.
- Sebume 10y agoRivkin is a short, stocky 51-year-old who grew up in Atlanta, the son of a surgeon. He started Green Diesel in October 2005.
- edkennedy 10y agoOther hilarious and frightening "business ideas" with US government issued carbon credits: Dumping giant piles of iron sulfate into the ocean in Northern Canada: http://www.timescolonist.com/news/local/haida-readying-for-second-round-of-iron-dumping-in-ocean-1.115880 http://www.timescolonist.com/news/local/haida-readying-for-s... Driving a train full of biodiesel across the border and back again numerous times while never unloading it: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/biofuel-credits-behind-mystery-cross-border-train-shipments-1.1252080 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/biofuel-credits-behind-mystery...
- shard972 10y agoI tried to find a follow up to the iron sulfate story but couldn't find one, would be interesting to hear what happened.
- aaron695 10y agoEvidence seems like it worked. Much as people didn't want it to. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/haida-gwaii-ocean-fertalizing-chile-1.3550783 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/haida-gwaii-o...
- edkennedy 10y agoThe theory behind it is sound, the issue is with sustainability. Changing the ecosystem that much when you have no idea how sustainable the growth is or how it will affect the ecosystem as a whole is risky.
- hackaflocka 10y agoInteresting that there's no easily found mug shot of him considering he's in Fed Prison. In India, about 25 years ago, the govt instituted export credits. Basically, in order to import anything, you needed to have export credits. So, export credits became a fungible currency. And people started exporting all kinds of crap under the guise of something legit, just to obtain export credits. People were exporting bricks, calling them shoes, and then selling the export credits. Of course, government officials were involved end-to-end in the scam (via relatives and friends, as is usually done there). Sad to see similar things are happening in the US now.
- josinalvo 10y agoNevermind the scam. How is the system supposed to work? A company produces biodiesel and can sell, separately, the biodisel and the RIN. A fuel company can buy the RIN instead of biodiesel, and, in theory, that would mean that another fuel company bought the biodiesel, and is using more biodiesel and less petroleum. Correct? What if, instead, the biodiesel is used in a previously non existent or previously carbon neutral industry? That does not seem to reduce pollution at all. How does the system prevent it? Does the system prevent it?
- dmurray 10y agoThe biodiesel was meant to be equivalent to regular diesel, so it could be sold at the same price, but more expensive to produce. So a "previously non existent or previously carbon neutral industry" wouldn't have any reason to switch to biodiesel, unless it was already good for them to switch to regular diesel.
- fit2rule 10y ago> He kept a miniature, stainless-steel working model of it in his office. “I could put vegetable oil through it and get a cup of the most beautiful biodiesel you ever saw,” Harvey Greenwood, Green Diesel’s former director for engineering, says of the model. The most interesting part of this whole story, imho. Doesn't anyone else want their own desktop vegetable-oil to perfect diesel machine?
- Spooky23 10y agoI had exactly the same thought! This would be a great christmas gift for the mechanically inclined.
- hexane360 10y agoI really want to make something like this. I wonder if that would need a little agitator, or some temperature control, or valves, or what? And then once you have the piping, you can get some automatic control, and some management software. . .
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]