8 ms·
Maybe it is common knowledge for you. I could have looked it up, but I don't like seeing non constructive criticism.
by _RPM 10y ago
Maybe it is common knowledge for you. I could have looked it up, but I don't like seeing non constructive criticism.
- weego 10y agoHighlighting a factually incorrect statement is not criticism. Criticism assumes a different point of view. Granted he could have put it as a GitHub issue, but how about we avoid anti-intellectualism.
- pvg 10y agoCriticism assumes a different point of view. It doesn't, really. Criticizing poor choice of terminology is still criticism.
- platz 10y agoIt is entirely constructive. I just prefer brevity more than you do. But you would've still downvoted me even if i'd provided a link, no?
- eli 10y agoIt's a fine line between brevity and rudeness.
- simplify 10y agoThat is not what constructive is.
- ars 10y agoThe point of making a comment is not showing off your knowledge, it's being useful to the reader. You comment was not useful (or at least not as useful as it could be). Put in more effort next time - a comment is written once, but read many times.
- zghst 10y agoSame could be said of the author to put more effort into their writing pieces before they publish a piece that will be read many times...
- echaozh 10y agoI think being part of a discussion sometimes requires some basic knowledge of the basic. Otherwise, if you need every concept explained to you, well, it's not a discussion, but a lecture. After all, if I deem it common knowledge and you do not, how do I know where is the limit of your knowledge base? IMHO, people in the technical industry should first try to find knowledge by themselves, and ask only when it is not easily accessible. If you keep asking questions which you can find answers by Googling, hmm, how do you even survive in this industry? That is, if you're not in management, of course.
- gnud 10y agoIt was very useful to me. It told me the author of this library doesn't know what a predicate is.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zghst 10y agoIt is valid to simply point out mistakes like these. It only takes a few seconds of effort, a few mins to fix and move on from. Instead we want to make this simple statement an emotional battleground and berate OP for not doing the author's brainwork.
- jccalhoun 10y agoit may be valid but it assumes everyone reading the comment knows what a predicate is in this context.
- GrinningFool 10y agoI'd say it makes no such assumption - in fact it tells the reader that it's not valid. The reader may then choose to educate him or herself as necessary.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]