13 ms·
Shedding light on the dark web
- eatbitseveryday 10y agoCouldn't reverse tracing work? A fed poses as a customer, and uses a PO Box to receive goods, but also registers this in the Fedex, USPS, UPS databases, such that if this address appears anywhere on a package, it is traced to determine the origin. Build a network over time, repeat.
- dublinben 10y agoThat is a common tactic used in cases like this.
- dnm_hn_thread 10y agoThe FBI cannot legally trace USPS mail without a warrant, but can with Fedex, UPS, et. al. Almost all US darknet shipments go through USPS for this reason.
- mej10 10y agoThats an interesting competitive advantage for USPS.
- ams6110 10y agoThe USPS images every address they deliver now and logs for law enforcement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_Isolation_Control_and_Tracking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_Isolation_Control_and_Tra... I flatly do not believe the claims that the images are not retained long term.
- andrewpi 10y agoThey only need a warrant to open the mail. They can freely use the information printed on the outside of the envelope for their investigations.
- Cerium 10y agoThey could build a Physical Onion Router. Send package to a node, which opens it to find a smaller package already addressed to another location. Similar to TOR each hop will increase security at the expense of resource utilization.
- twinkletwinkle 10y agoDoesn't that leave a huge paper trail?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sp332 10y agoIt works if you have a decent volume and can't trace individual inputs to individual outputs. If you get one package and send one package, it's a little obvious.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dublinben 10y agoAnonymous remailers have been around for decades. They were largely supplanted by online communications, or shut down.
- chatmasta 10y agoExcept unlike an encrypted hash, a cardboard box does not offer much protection from ripping it open and seeing what's inside. ;)
- brokenmachine 10y agoAn interesting idea, but each hop has sniffer dogs. Also those nodes would be an obvious place to use extra resources monitoring.
- TACIXAT 10y agoThis is where good opsec would come in. Use postal boxes in many different locations. Be wary of cameras that could get an image of you or your plate. Don't carry your smartphone.
- cloudjacker 10y agoThe sellers drop the packages off in mailing boxes, ideally far from where they actually live. This would render your idea less worthwhile. There have been arrest of sellers and buyers, primarily due to noobish mistakes. All told, the risk for the seller is much lower than dealing with a variety of forces in the street in their local jurisdiction. Therefore your idea becomes a war of attrition for law enforcement. Where the yield is too low to justify the cost. This is why more effort goes into shutting down the marketplaces, but even this has become a war of attrition ever since the Silk Road 1.0 bust. The federal government operating through just one agency got 80 million in bitcoin from that bust. The next year, the FBI required cooperation with 16 agencies across Europe in a dragnet bust that only got 1.2 million in bitcoin, with most sites being back online in a week. The trend continues, and every enforcement action simply prompts consumers, merchants, and site providers to implement UX and security practices that they already knew they should have been using (multisig addresses instead of human escrow, use of tails/whonix, not logging in as admin from a public library, etc)
- runeks 10y ago> This is why more effort goes into shutting down the marketplaces, but even this has become a war of attrition ever since the Silk Road 1.0 bust. Gwern lists at least 20 active Darknet markets: https://www.gwern.net/Black-market%20survival https://www.gwern.net/Black-market%20survival - I don't think law enforcement will ever get rid of Darknet markets. The important point is that every time law enforcement removes one marketplace, customers are forced to visit the next one that's still online, thus increasing their revenue, effectively strengthening the strongest competitors every time they make a bust. The weakest marketplace is wiped out by law enforcement - leaving behind increasingly resilient markets - and new ones appear all the time, adding to the number of markets at the same time they're growing more resilient. It's a fight against evolution that I can't possible see anyone winning.
- sremani 10y agoDarknet markets are like Hydra with 10 heads, when Silk Road is taken down, more players entered and when one other dark-market owners closed shop and jumped with vendors bit-coins, new ones with multi-escrow showed up. Again, with each take down people are improvising and making the system a bit more resilient.
- puddintane 10y agoYou gotta wonder if many of these owners who jump ship with vendors money, are the ones who show up suddenly with funds to "save the day".
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoThis whole result was fascinating to me. Ross Ulbricht gets life in federal prison, no possibility of parole, and yet people are tripping all over themselves to take his place.
- __xjb__ 10y agoWhat an excellent example of Nicholas Naseem Taleb's concept of antifragility.
- runeks 10y agoIt's evolution. Survival of the fittest, quite simply. The weakest are taken down, leaving more customers for the remaining, stronger competitors.
- aab0 10y agoIt's a rubbish example. The DNMs do not get better thanks to exit scams and takedowns. They get worse, as sensible and experienced administrators depart with a fortune, to be replaced by mendacious incompetents. Nor is the technical side of things any better - they have, if anything, regressed technically on the issue of multisig.
- dnm_hn_thread 10y agoCongrats gwern for being written up in the Economist. Your research exposing the dark web (including your own battles with being implicated for wrongdoing) are commendable.
- rcpt 10y agoUsing gwerns data I put together stats on the likelihood that vendors who sell one product sell another here: http://ryancompton.net/2015/03/24/darknet-market-basket-analysis/ http://ryancompton.net/2015/03/24/darknet-market-basket-anal... All the parsed data is available as a csv as well. I was surprised how well substance relationships could be recovered from vendor co listings
- dopamean 10y agoAny time I read anything about the illegal drug trade I am struck by how much the industry would change if all drugs were legalized everywhere. So much effort is expended to keep things hidden from law enforcement and other criminals that it adds an incredible amount of friction to the purchasing process for the purchaser and the seller. From the buyer's perspective you now have to go into business with some often unsavory people just to get high. From the seller's perspective you have to make sure that the buyer isn't law enforcement and also not someone who is going to rob you because you have zero legal recourse. It's really a shitty experience for everyone involved. Considering how shitty that experience is it says a lot about people and their desire to take drugs that the market continues to exist and basically never stops serving the customer. It really seems like when confronted with something inevitable, like drug use and sales, the effort to prevent it may be more costly and damaging than just allowing it to happen in a more controlled environment.
- abfan1127 10y agoPlease see Alcohol Prohibition in the United States (at least back then they amended the US Constitution to do it legally).
- idlewords 10y agoFrom a public health perspective, Prohibition was a success. The main reason it failed as policy is chemistry. You can make ethanol from anything—even a cactus, as Mexico has taught us.
- digler999 10y agoso if alcohol weren't so easy to make, like say it had to be imported from the Golden Triangle, it would have never been smuggled (in massive quantities) past the border ?
- Retra 10y agoThat would have made it a border control issue, not an "everybody has an uncle that does it" issue.
- jmcgough 10y agoGwern's other writings on darknet markets are also excellent, with a lot of original research. http://www.gwern.net/#cryptobitcoin http://www.gwern.net/#cryptobitcoin
- skraelingjar 10y agoSo when can I get my deliveries via anonymous drone?
- Jemmeh 10y agoI've seen a few articles where people are already delivering drugs with drones. So...I guess that's already now.
- dzmien 10y agoDemand for recreational drugs is ever present, it seems, and it looks like the prohibitionists are losing 'the war on drugs.' I hesitate to recommend sweeping legalization, but surely it must be time to rethink drugs policy. I suppose it is happening, slowly, with medical and recreational marijuana legalization, but other drugs must be considered as well. I don't use drugs or alcohol anymore because I couldn't control my use of opioids. I have had a very difficult time in the past 10 years because of this, and every rehab/behavioral health treatment I found myself in recommended 12 step support groups as a one size fits all solution to my substance abuse issues. It wasn't until I got into a methadone program that I was able to find some relief from my addiction and frequent relapses. Unfortunately, methadone is frowned upon as much NA/AA is favored by addiction counselors. Anyway, I've rambled on long enough. The point is that I think addiction is the real problem we face when it comes to drugs. And two potentially addictive drugs are currently legal. I think that if enough money was allocated for medical addiction treatment, legalization could work. A lot of money could be made by regulating and taxing recreational drugs. Addicts could be kept out of jail and receive the help they need instead of falling into the trap of the criminal justice system.
- Cshelton 10y agoSellers of drugs, will ALWAYS sell drugs, both illegal and legal. Buyers/Users of drugs will ALWAYS buy/use drugs, illegal or legal. It is an interaction between humans of Earth, no government or entity, no system or blocks will ever stop it. Shut down the internet, it will continue. Short of a massive purge of life, drugs will never go away. If you somehow...were able to shut down the "darkweb", it would move into something else that authorities are unaware of. On a whim, if I desired, I can purchase any drug I want, probably get it today, without using the internet. The war on drugs has no end. Stop trying to pretend you (the lawmakers) have never tried an illegal substance. Even the most powerful public figure in the world (Obama) has admitted to using illegal substances at one point in his life. Government: It's time to sit down, shut up, stop wasting the taxpayers money and leave it alone.
- Lawtonfogle 10y agoNow apply this logic to other things traded on the darkweb.
- 15charlimit 10y agoIf you actually want to stop the trade of anything, you go shut down the source - not the distribution channel that lets you keep tabs on what's being traded where, between whom. See the somewhat recent media hysteria and stupidity around craigslist/similar sites and prostitution. The only thing accomplished was driving the distribution channels to other, less visible, less-easily-tracked places. Everything that was happening before is still happening now.
- jswny 10y agoI tend to feel the same way. These types of things are inevitable, you are never going to stop them from happening. However, when debating this point, I have a hard time defending my point when someone else says "so should we just not do anything? Wouldn't that increase the illegal activity? Should we let people buy guns too? Where do you draw the line?" I have to say, I'm not sure what to say about that. If the government did not actively fight this, successful or not, would it cause the markets and illegal drug users to proliferate?
- Fej 10y agoDo we really use the term "darknet"? I thought it was a layman's term and frowned upon.
- boulos 10y agoThe Economist is a broadly targeted publication. That's a term that's widely "understood", so just as Internet (capital I) is sort of silly, I don't take umbrage with it in such settings.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bahjoite 10y agoThe article is about online marketplaces published as Tor Onion Services; the darknet/darkweb is something else entirely, but the name clearly appeals to sensation-seeking media editors.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 10y agoThis is one of those topics where I've made a conscious decision to not check it out. I have no desire to find out how deep that rabbit-hole goes...
- eatbitseveryday 10y agoI share similar sentiments. I do not share these articles with people I know (or family) for this reason. But, that doesn't stop them from encountering them on their own.
- pzone 10y agoThere's not really much more to it than what you see in this article. You log onto one of a few crappy ebay-looking sites, and sellers list items for sale basically using the same list of categories in the graphic. No hit men or anything like that - and Craigslist works fine for prostitutes. Sometimes site managers don't even allow the sale of guns. It's mostly just people buying and selling drugs. And 15% of users of illegal drugs have obtained them through these sources.
- SamChoi 10y agoDidn't realize marijuana was such a big factor on the darkweb. Think of the all the missed taxes!! :(
- adrusi 10y agoIf you look at the second chart in the article [1] you can see that marijuana is much cheaper online than on the street in the US. A lot of it is coming from legal states and California, where it's cheaper to produce. Street weed in most of the country is usually either grown locally or imported from Mexico, so online prices are often significantly better. [1]: http://cdn.static-economist.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/original-size/images/print-edition/20160716_IRC989.png http://cdn.static-economist.com/sites/default/files/imagecac...
- darkstar999 10y agoThe chart breaks down marijuana in to "skunk" and "weed". Are these distinct terms that I am unaware of?
- DanBC 10y agoWhen people say "skunk" they mean much stronger, higher THC lower CBD strains. Whether the stuff they're talking about actually has higher THC or lower CBD is another matter.
- bahjoite 10y agoThe distinction is a loose one and to do with potency: skunk, originally a strain of cannabis with a 50/50 balance of Indica and Sativa varieties, is often used to mean potent, often hydroponically grown, cannabis flowers.
- joesmo 10y agoThe "Alprazolam" and "Xanax" bubbles that shoot out of the "Prescription Drugs" bubble should be combined into one bubble with a total of 2.1 as they are generic and brand name respectively for the same drug.
- arca_vorago 10y agoConstitutionally the government doesn't have any right to tell a person what they can and can't do with their body so long as it only affects them and doesn't impact the rights of another. It's a slippery slope argument that could be applied to all kinds of things. People need to remember the Constitution and its foundation of natural rights, that it was created to protect those natural rights, not to establish any rights.