14 ms·
Vine isn’t growing and most of its top executives have left
- hackaflocka 10y agoTwitter is very very broken. "Retweet with Comment" are not showing up as Retweets: https://medium.com/@Maver1ck/is-twitter-unreasonably-broken-9ff4df0b93a8#.7n3zl9vd9 https://medium.com/@Maver1ck/is-twitter-unreasonably-broken-...
- ceejayoz 10y agoI have no idea why it wasn't just a minor product feature in the main Twitter app.
- illicium 10y agoIt was always a separate app even after being acquired. That said, Twitter has done pretty much nothing to bridge the two communities.
- dasil003 10y agoBecause it had the potential to create a community around it. If they just wanted the feature they could easily have built it into Twitter for less than $30M. What made Vine work is the same thing that made Instagram work: a killer app. If Viners had to compete with everyone else on Twitter their work would have been too diluted to get traction, and you wouldn't have seen the same creativity and commitment.
- philsnow 10y agoCritically, the vine community is a younger demographic. Maybe Twitter wanted to keep them separate because they didn't want an eternal September killing the "bird in the hand" Twitter community.
- Kadin 10y agoThat Vine's userbase consisted largely of younger people probably should have given Twitter pause, and in retrospect might have made them rethink that $30M valuation. Those are the same users who are most likely to drop your service overnight when it becomes uncool, for reasons that may never be clear or make sense. (See also: Myspace.)
- _pmf_ 10y ago> Because it had the potential to create a community around it. How is "having the potential to create a community around it" (and failing) more valuable than catering to the actually existing Twitter community?
- dasil003 10y agoBecause people would actually use it. A feature which no one uses is worthless. I'm not saying I agree with the strategy, but you can't really say it failed. For a $30M acquisition it was quite a value as it exploded in subsequent years, it would have easily been approaching a $1B valuation at its peak, it only petered out in the last couple years. I really can't see how building a looping video feature into Twitter would have achieved that kind of reach (of course it would also have been hard to measure)
- imsofuture 10y agoThat thing every time a 'startup' that never actually had a monetizable product makes headlines for not doing super awesome.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoTwitter's firehose is extremely valuable data, just not at the lofty valuations the company was given.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoWhat exactly is valuable about it? I keep hearing this but it is just a jumble of collective stream of consciousness. Has anyone that has read Ulysses actually made any sense of it? Twitter is the collective analog of Ulysses.
- spydum 10y agoIt can be pretty useful for sentiment analysis across large populations - for a lot of different purposes/clients
- prostoalex 10y agoIt can, but at what price? Parent was questioning this data being "extremely valuable" - is sentiment analysis at $.001 per user an attractive proposition to a client? Likely. Is it still a viable product at $.01, $.10, $1 per user?
- JonnieCache 10y agoDo we have sentiment analysis techniques that actually work now? Last I checked they weren't so great.
- VLM 10y agoIt is insightful to point out the widely held belief that Google Reader would never be cancelled because its an incredibly tightly curated data set of what real humans actively seek out and hard working devoted humans actively filtered the wheat from the chaff. All for free, for google to monetize. Everyone knows, that everyone knows, that its a very valuable dataset. But nobody is apparently interested in paying for it or otherwise monetizing it. Shades of "emperor has no clothes". The end result is Google Reader got cancelled. If twitter was not standalone and was a mere subproject of a real company, it would likewise be long gone. They have no plan B so they'll have to keep doing what they're doing until they run out of money or are purchased, pretty much a Yahoo situation. Its like a decades old portapottie at a concert venue, everyone goes there does not mean its worth anything to anyone. It would be a nice, cool world to live in where sentiment analysis is a thing. Its such an obvious and tasty idea, that unfortunately is completely wrong.
- decayy 10y agoTwitter should just combine all of their video apps into the main twitter app.
- pxlpshr 10y agoThe founders departed very early after the acquisition, like Rus and Dom. None of the 'top executives' were ever the original visionaries that created the product to begin with. It's sort of shocking that after Jack left but hailed back to save Twitter, that the board didn't have more wherewithal to retain the founding team of Vine. Textbook post-acquisition problem. I agree with other commenters that they should integrate Vine into Twitter. Like Instagram and video (or Facebook and Facebook Live), there's really no reason for it to be separate. Twitter needs better content generation tools at it's core. It's really starting to feel like a washed up RSS aggregator and nothing more.
- Dr_tldr 10y agoYeah, I'd have to agree. At this point, talking about Vine is almost (not yet, but almost) like talking about a subsidiary of Yahoo; whatever the unique problems of the child company, the parent company's dysfunction remains the primary issue.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- intoverflow2 10y ago> they should integrate Vine into Twitter Twitter already does video better than vine though, whats the point?
- pxlpshr 10y agoI guess you made my point. I care very little about Twitter now because their 2016 innovation was turning a star into a heart.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoMakes sense, Instagram has essentially beat them at their own game.
- beedogs 10y agoWhat game is that? "Collecting zero revenue until you're somehow bought by Facebook"?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- awad 10y agoWell, despite the fact that both companies were acquired by larger social companies... "Instagram will surpass Google, Twitter in US mobile display ad revenues by 2017" http://www.emarketer.com/Article/Instagram-Mobile-Ad-Revenues-Reach-281-Billion-Worldwide-2017/1012774#sthash.hhuGqYyb.dpuf http://www.emarketer.com/Article/Instagram-Mobile-Ad-Revenue...
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoThe short video game. Literally the only thing Vine does.
- terda12 10y agoInstagram has more everyday users. Think about me, the average dude. I have 100 followers on Instagram, most of whom are from high school/college. I have zero followers on Vine. Unless I dedicate my life to making funny Vines, I probably won't get any followers. Whoa, now Instagram has pushed a video feature, great! Now I can share "vines" with my 100 followers. No need to download Vine after all. Not to mention a lot of the funny vines get posted onto a youtube compilation anyways, so in the end youtube is profiting from vine's success. Vine's business model was just doomed to fail.
- raverbashing 10y agoInstagram remade vine 100x better Every time I click a vine video it takes ages to load. I can't remember a similar service with a crappier user experience The Vine app lasted less than a week on my phone, because it was pretty much unusable. Yes, please, let me play a series of videos with sound while scrolling.
- intruder 10y agoSuch a shame, I love Vine. Integrating it into the twitter feed just means videos will not be seen as they have to compete with all the other stuff that's taking space on your feed.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoI've seen this cycle a few times now. Just give it a merciful death (vine and twitter). Some things are meant to be ephemeral. I think vine and twitter are in that category. Just like a forest needs fires to be a healthy ecosystem. People should be more willing to let go of business ideas that see explosive growth but lack the business fundamentals to be sustainable. Instead what's gonna happen is that it is going to be a slow and steady march of attrition until only the husk is left and people just feel sad every time either twitter and vine are mentioned.
- beefsack 10y agoIn particular reference to Twitter, I wonder if they tried to make a product out of what probably should have been a protocol.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoI don't know. I think if they had souped up RSS they would have been in a much better position and maybe it would have been more sustainable but a long series of missteps has led them to this point. I think the biggest mistake they made was shutting down the developer ecosystem. They never recovered after that.
- ajmurmann 10y agoAs a Twitter user I wouldn't like to see that happen. What other platform do you suggest I use instead?
- dkarapetyan 10y agoI don't know. I think RSS aggregation with some extra bells and whistles is a perfectly good alternative but then again I don't think I'm the target demographic of twitter.
- niftich 10y agoMost power users who command an engaged audience ('influencers' or 'VIPs' or 'celebrities' or 'streamers' or insert-your-noun-here) already cross-post on every single service. Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter, Youtube, Tumblr, Twitch... Staying exclusive to a particular platform only pays if the platform literally pays you for your content. Otherwise you want to reach as wide of an audience as possible.
- jfranken 10y agoVine is the least of twitter's problem
- niftich 10y agoIt's such a shame, really; arguably Twitter, much more so than their competitors, tries to stick as close to the original form of their product as they can. I admire that. Facebook (and Instagram) and Snapchat have both transformed from their original incarnations, in ways that have improved the companies' valuation, but have not always improved the experience of users. It seems every single social network is trending towards feature parity with each other -- Facebook now has streaming video, Snapchat now has a decent text chat with messages that need not disappear, Instagram has an algorithmic no-longer-timeline wall and private messaging, they all have ads, even Tumblr now has IM and livestreaming. Some (important) differences remain, but from an observer time-travelling forward from 2012, the social networks of today would appear nearly interchangeable. But there's Twitter. All these years, it has stayed remarkably close to the original concept of microblogging. Instead, it developed (or acquired) other formats and cultivated them as separate services, separate communities. It's unfortunate that not even wide societal impact can make a service profitable, or at least quell the pressure to feature-creep outside of your original scope.
- s3r3nity 10y agoShouldn't this data be a validation of Facebook's/Instagram's/Snapchat's growth model? Maybe you _need_ to iterate and change up the game a bit if you're to continue growing, expanding into new markets, etc. ("There are no sacred cows.")
- niftich 10y agoOh absolutely it validates their business model (or so it seems), but I can't help but feel that value is paradoxically lost (for the user) once everyone iterates themselves into equivalence. Network effect advantages become almost irrelevant when everyone maintains an equally split presence. And if value is lost for the user, their platform loyalty will plummet. Facebook and Snapchat will begin to be perceived as a 'utility' (something that has already happened to Twitter), meaning, we as a society all expect these functions of social networking and messaging to be fulfilled by a provider, but the exact provider is no longer relevant. Pressures to maintain a positive balance sheet will lead to a proliferation of ads. This will leave room for new upstarts to target a niche they can serve better than the incumbents, and lure engagement away. They will use VC money to fund their effort and offer ad-free, carefully-focused refuges away from the big networks. But the incumbents have so much money, they will all get bought out in the end. (Snapchat refused to be bought out by Facebook for $3,000,000,000, at a time when it was still known as a sexting app) I see analogues to the churn of free image hosts -- new one starts up because all the old ones are full of ads; introduces ads a few years later because they can't pay the bills. The cycle continues.
- stephenyeargin 10y agoI knew things were getting bad when I got like three push notifications in a week to pretty please open the app to see what my friends were not posting anymore.
- julianz 10y agoHow on earth does Vine need all those people with inflated job titles to deliver tiny videos over the internet?
- timcederman 10y agoThis question gets asked pretty much every time there is an article about the size of tech companies. If you think about what is required for running something at the scale of Vine, 50 people makes a lot of sense, and if anything that seems somewhat lean.
- PeCaN 10y agoYou still didn't explain why they need that many people. What exactly _is_ required for “running something at the scale of Vine”? Yes, they have/had a lot of traffic, but traffic in and of itself does not require a large staff to manage.
- timcederman 10y agoI'm not going to explain the individual job functions of 50 people, and for folks who work in the industry this should seem like a reasonable number just from their own experience. However, let's do some rough numbers. It says they had 3 product managers. I would guess this means 8-10 engineers. 3 QA folks would be a decent enough ratio. You've then got a GM, a head of product, head of UX, head of data science, head of BD, editorial lead, and head of engineering who all just left. We're up to 26 people already. Now we've got some HR staff, maybe a recruiter or two, finance team, people underneath the UX, editorial, data science and BD teams (let's generously assume 1-2 hires each), and we're over 40 people easily. We haven't even discussed marketing, help centre and customer support, a DBA, ops, or IT support. Does that all make sense now? It's a company within Twitter and there are a lot of specialized roles to keep something with 25-30 million active users a month running smoothly. I'm not then going to go into what each person does each day, but with a product that you're trying to drive growth and new features for, while supporting existing customers, and just generally running a company, that takes a lot of bodies if you want to do it effectively and not cut corners.
- partycoder 10y agoi think snapchat covers pretty much the same demographic and the product has a lot of overlap.
- kevindeasis 10y agoI've seen people moving to different platforms. There seems to be always a platform replacing another platform. I have yet to see this with Facebook. It seems like the new Google Hangouts and their new messaging app (allo?) might be in the radar. But, at this point is it even possible to have a facebook replacement withing the next 3 years?
- abrongersma 10y agoThe content creators are running for the hills. Almost all of the popular folks I followed no longer post content on a regular basis. It's usually posted as an afterthought. I really enjoyed the comedy section and the time constraints on the video length was great to show off creativity.
- abpavel 10y agoThe key to scaling video content is automatic production, like Wochit, not shortened duration, like Vine.
- BilalBudhani 10y agoInstead of launching Vine a 6 seconds micro vlogging service. Twitter should have integrated that as a feature in their own app. That would have made so much sense. Every social media company for e.g SnapChat, Facebook etc. are closely integrating video content within the core of their app and Twitter had a huge opportunity and the managed to below it away.
- clw8 10y agoI'm not surprised. Using livestream apps (or in Vine's case short videos) I've noticed that broadcasters are incredibly addicted for a month or so, and then they disappear forever.
- fernandosoteras 10y agoA "6-seconds video" app had organigram with executives? really?
- draw_down 10y ago"Why is 140 characters worth billions?" Et cetera, et cetera, as nauseam
- ohitsdom 10y agoI loved Vine, it's a really interesting medium/format. But the userbase killed it for me. Young teenagers posting stupid clips with music edits about some boy band, TV show, or anime. I'm not interested in any of that. I liked the artsy clips, sports highlights, and comedy but it became increasingly difficult to find when using the app. I felt like an old man being somewhere he didn't belong. I still enjoy a funny Vine now and then, but I only see it when it pops up on my Twitter feed.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoThank god. While vine may have some significance, it's a wasteland of content, full of stupid crap, and unfunny memes that even /b/ would hate. I think that Thomas Sanders is one of the very few people on Vine actually producing interesting content. And most things on vine could be recreated as gifs with subtitles without missing much.
- joelrunyon 10y agoDoes vine load terribly for anyone else? Always amazed that it's considered a "production-ready" level product when ti doesn't even play videos consistently across multiple sites.
- chejazi 10y agoThe part that has impressed me about Twitter/Vine/etc over the past few years is their content embeds in other sites/services. Their main apps are so riddled with junk that I hardly use them. The real estate in their feeds devotes more to ad space than micro-blogging, and everyone knows that followers (/follow-for-followers) are a marketing cesspool. Twitter et al. should really become the blockquote service for the internet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ilaksh 10y agoWhy would you need multiple executives to handle a business that is mainly silly 6-second video clips and could never be more than that without changing the name in which case it becomes an unknown brand? What do top executives do for these types of companies. It seems like a joke.