4 ms·
Why do you think that the Nordic model can't scale?
by adamnemecek 10y ago
Why do you think that the Nordic model can't scale?
- douche 10y agoSocial issues are easy when you have a 99% ethnically homogeneous population without any serious religious divisions either.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoSo, if this is true, that means countries have some scalability issues. Once it's big enough, it's not going to be 100% monochrome anymore.
- dirtyaura 10y agoReally? And you say that about a country that has had a civil war between members of this ethnically homogenous population (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finnish_Civil_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finnish_Civil_War). You are seriously mistaken that ethnic diversity is the only or even a major cause of social issues.
- Nokinside 10y agoNordic countries are not 99% ethnically homogeneous. Over 20% of Swedes have foreign background. Either immigrants or or their parents were immigrants. They come from Middle East, Former Yugoslavia, Somalia etc.
- adamnemecek 10y agoWhy?
- DasIch 10y agoThe problem isn't that the US is heterogenous, the problem is that the US has a massive problem with racism, freedom of and from religion. Maybe even worse than that though are people like you, who can't even openly admit that obvious problem and only mention it in some euphemistic indirect way.
- matwood 10y agoHate to break it to you, but racism is everywhere. The Nordic countries are not somehow magically excluded, and according to some reports it is worse.
- vanilla-almond 10y ago"the problem is that the US has a massive problem with racism" I think this is too simplistic. The US is a country of some 320 million people and the experience of racism undoubtedly varies enormously across cities and states. A blanket statement like this can't convey the complexity of the situation. I live in the UK, where we've seen a horrible rise in racism after the EU referendum. But what country in the EU can honestly say they don't have serious problems with racism in their society? Across EU nations, there are many racist political parties, not at the fringes, but actively shaping and influencing political discourse. I really don't think we in Europe are in a superior position when it comes to issues of racism. In fact, I'd argue we're probably less likely to acknowledge or consider it a problem.
- ajmurmann 10y agoHaving moved to the US from Germany, not a Nordic country, but a country with a much tighter social net that works comparatively well, I agree that it probably wouldn't work in the US. I think a social net works best if there is enough empathy in society to keep people happy with paying for those who need the net as well as keeping people from exploiting it too much. Of course there will always be someone unhappy with paying or someone exploiting he system, but it only works if that remains relatively rare. That is much easier if you have a relatively high empathy for each other which is easier in fairly homogenous populations. The US seems to have a very split society along all kinds of groups. There seems to be a strong fault line between large coastal cities and the middle of the country, racial divides, Republicans vs Democrats etc. These divides seem much larger to me than anything I know from Germany and I can only imagine that they are even smaller in the less populous, Nordic countries.
- uola 10y agoThe Nordic countries aren't spontaneously homogeneous though. It's because we (social democracy mostly) worked hard to make it so. As the Nordic countries are becoming more like everywhere else we also see the rise of things like populist parties and racial divides.
- jazzyk 10y agoI am in the US and I would be happy to chip in to help pay for health expenses of a poor person, who has no family, etc. What I am NOT willing to do, however, is pay enormous overhead to the the insurance/healthcare/bill-processing complex which sucks out the blood out of this country. I bet most people in the US object not to some kind of a social contract to help the less fortunate, but to the completely broken system.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> I bet most people in the US object not to some kind of a social contract to help the less fortunate, but to the completely broken system. I feel like there is quite a few who are fundamentally against the idea.
- matwood 10y agoI'm not even sure the Nordic countries themselves think their model would scale. At least in Helsinki, they also enjoy having a low cost neighbor to the south in order to go tax free shopping.