7 ms·
Ask HN: Why can I only downvote some comments?
Recently I noticed I can only downvote some comments. I used to be able to downvote any comment. Looks like the difference is age of the comment?
Is this a new development?
- herbst 10y agoI cant downvote anything and always wonder how people do that, curious to hear answers.
- vincent_s 10y agoI think you need > 500 Karma before you can downvote.
- herbst 10y agosoon™
- Noseshine 10y agoI think that's not sufficient, other factors like time since account creation and possibly activity too seem to be taken into account too.
- engi_nerd 10y agoThat may be true. My recollection is that the ability to downvote became active right as I crossed the 500 karma mark, but it's possible there are other factors.
- warmfuzzykitten 10y agoThe other factors seem quite mysterious. This is the only page in which I've seen downvote arrows in ages.
- vincent_s 10y agoLooks like we have official confirmation now :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12074198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12074198
- viraptor 10y agoYou can't downvote old comments (don't know what the threshold is) and comments that are responses to what you wrote. The time threshold seems to be on the comment itself, rather than article - I remember seeing pages where only half of the comments are locked.
- dozzie 10y ago> (don't know what the threshold is) Some time ago I think it was around 24 hours, but recently I noticed I can't downvote comments older than 12? hours. And yes, it's tied to comment, not the article.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stormbrew 10y agoI think it's 8 hours.
- mattmanser 10y agoThe fixed time limit doesn't make that much sense as what often happens is that the EU morning crowd sees the US West Coast's evening stories as the top trending stories, with a load of comments that can no longer be down voted, even though they are the most recent comments and barely debated. Then again, why make it too complicated.
- spriggan3 10y agoIs there a place where all these rules are detailed by the way ? not that I want to game the system , I'm working on a HN clone, and it would be interesting to know the business logic behind comments and submissions (how comments are sorted on an item page, how an article makes it to the homepage, is there something manual curation ? an algorithm ? ect... ) . While looking simple in terms of functionalities , HN is actually quite complex when it comes to content management,moderation and curation. I mean if all this is managed automatically.
- stormbrew 10y agoThe logic behind the time limit on down voting is almost certainly to prevent people from going into someone's history to downvote everything they ever said. Since your karma is literally the number of (upvotes-downvotes) you've ever received, doing that to someone could remove a huge chunk of their karma.
- danso 10y agoOff-topic but it seems that a change to upvoting has recently been implemented: https://news.ycombinator.com/voteclosed?id=11923301&how=up https://news.ycombinator.com/voteclosed?id=11923301&how=up We used to be able to upvote old items but now it seems there's a limit on that too. Too bad, I always liked being able to express that I enjoyed discovering something old in someone's record of contributions, even if no one would notice my upvote.
- liviu- 10y agoEspecially given that HN offers no support for saving items other than upvoting.
- danso 10y agoLooks like someone heard you ;) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12073675 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12073675 > 3. Save and share the best stories and comments. Click on a post's timestamp to go to its page, then click 'favorite' at the top. Your favorites are linked from your profile, and you can browse other users' from theirs.
- buro9 10y agoAs I understand it, you cannot downvote a comment if: 1. You have too low a karma (points, look top right) 2. The comment is a reply to yours 3. The comment is quite old 4. Something vague about a mechanism that stops you stalking someone and downvoting (spread the downvotes, don't focus them like a meanie) 5. It's already been downvoted to nothing (you can do it, but I think it has no effect) Generally, upvote the positive rather than downvote the negative.
- RussianCow 10y ago"Quite old" in this case seems to be about 8 hours, based on anecdotal evidence.
- DanBC 10y agoOP is asking if time length for item 3 has changed.
- jacquesm 10y agoIt has, it is shorter than before.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAgreed! I reserve downvotes for unhelpful comments. Helpful comments should be about the topic, and not other commenters.
- jacquesm 10y ago6. The comment is a reply to a story you posted 7. You may think you are able to vote, but it may still be ignored
- amelius 10y agoImho, if an option is not available, it should be grayed out, and the reason should be shown on hovering.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoWhy, out of interest?
- dave5104 10y agoTo prevent users from wondering what's wrong and asking questions like the ones in this topic. It's just a good rule of thumb for UI. "Don't make me think," as it were.
- vmateixeira 10y agoWhy are people focusing on downvotes other than upvoting what's important? If you upvote important comments, the ones you dislike will fade away... so why focusing on so much negativity? Does it makes anyone feel better downvoting an opinion they disagree with? Why not try to prove your point instead, adding your comment and upvoting the ones you like the most?
- vmateixeira 10y agoAgain, here we go.. the invisible hand, the warrior without face.. and my comment being downvoted... Do people really read 1k+ comment threads? Isn't this supposed to work as a community? If people would upvote comments they agree with wouldn't the most voted ones be on top? So what's wrong with what I just said?
- projectramo 10y agoWell, suppose you think a comment is really bad for whatever reason (pick the vilest comment you can think of for political, personal, or other reasons.) It is unhelpful, angry, incoherent and whatever else. Now for some reason the person has some friends who upvoted the comment. Do you really think you want to express your displeasure by upvoting every other comment relatively speaking? What if you don't particularly like any of the other comments, or don't have time to read them all?
- vmateixeira 10y agoI agree that upvoting every other comment is not a solution. But maybe the 'art of ignore' is. If no one would comment, that someone would eventually give up. After all, that's what those bad comments are seeking for: attention, support of any kind or just annoying someone. Have you thought that by downvoting you could be leaking to that person that he/she annoyed you, therefore empowering him/her to continue with such bad comments? In the other hand, if you downvote a comment just because you disagree with it you may be leading that person to give up on commenting/contributing.
- singold 10y agoIn my experience when a thread gets too much chained replies you can't down vote any more. I suspect this is to prevent down voting wars in heavy discussions.
- vox_mollis 10y agoWhat's never discussed is HN's "voting hellban". That is, you are permitted to upvote/downvote, but your votes don't ever actually count. This is the case with my account, but it's never discussed or documented anywhere.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoOr a throttling delay versus other posters. I caught someone's eye on HN, and now I'm limited in how many comments I can post in a sliding window compared to other users.
- xiaoma 10y agoThat is a highly nasty and unethical thing to do to an unsuspecting user who spends time carefully moderating the discussion and trying to help the site. On the other hand, it's a great way to handle someone who assists spammers or astroturfers.
- DanBC 10y agoWhat did dang say when you emailed HN? I've found he's always happy to talk about this kind of stuff. The software sometimes makes mistakes.
- vox_mollis 10y agoAt your suggestion, I did. I don't know what their typical response time is, but as of yet nothing.
- vox_mollis 10y agoOk, yes, it seems nobody responds to the HN email address regarding issues like this. They likely filter out those not as popular as you.
- dang 10y agoThat's neither true nor fair. We sometimes fall behind on emails, and I had several dozen to answer before getting to yours, which is currently next in the queue. Coming here to see the context before answering your email is an ironic moment to encounter snark about us not answering emails. If you'd merely said we were too slow, I'd fully agree.
- SilasX 10y agoSorry if too OT, but I thought I'd put it here: Why not let people see the scores of replies to their comments? I can understand hiding scores in general, sure. But it would be nice to know how popular certain replies are, so I know if it's worth continuing the thread. There are a lot of times when there's exactly one comment, which isn't grayed out. I have no idea whether zero or a hundred people think it's a good reply. If there are multiple replies, then that indicates interest and I can reply to the top one. But that doesn't help for the case of single replies.