5 ms·
Speculation: - People have become more aware of the risk factors, and behave accordingly. Awareness would be connected to prevalence but have a lagged effect.
by lordnacho 10y ago
Speculation:
- People have become more aware of the risk factors, and behave accordingly. Awareness would be connected to prevalence but have a lagged effect.
- Deadly diseases cause evolutionary responses. Perhaps a disproportionate number of people with predisposition to these illnesses passed away before having offspring.
- Reporting bias? While an illness looms large in the minds of the medical community, doctors are more likely to either wrongly attribute to the illness (false positive), or do false negatives less often.
- Highly speculative: combined effects are non-linear. I don't know what they use to do these studies, but typically you hear something along the lines of "for every x, there's m*x effect", which makes things sounds nice and linear. Maybe better prevention and better treatment does better than either on its own summed up, and so you won't be able to find the "reason" by splitting into each feature.
- tlrobinson 10y agoI don't think you'd see any significant evolutionary responses in the timeframes the article is talking about (<100 years or 4 generations)
- Swizec 10y agoHaven't studies shown that high stress (like concentration camp) has immediate effect on next generation's DNA? That would indicate that it's at least potentially possible for evolutionary adaptation to work pretty fast.
- bhouston 10y agoThat isn'y evolution if it is epigenetic, it would be another type of adaption, Lamarckian really: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamarckism#Epigenetic_Lamarckism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamarckism#Epigenetic_Lamarcki...
- coltonv 10y agoThis is incorrect. Evolution is simply change over generations by natural selection. the mechanism by which that happens, be it DNA or epigenetics or whatever, is not strict
- aroch 10y agoYes/no... It has to be heritable beyond a single reproductive cycle. Which isn't the case with all epi markers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- FreeKill 10y agoYeah, I was curious about that as well. I wonder if the internet and the resulting increase in spread of knowledge about diseases, symptoms, etc. has played a statistically significant part? I'd wager that at the least, it has helped people to realise they need more of an experts opinion when certain symptoms arrive that are linked to more serious illnesses.
- tenpies 10y ago> People have become more aware of the risk factors, and behave accordingly. I wonder how this could be properly measured. My impression based on rising obesity rates and decrease in overall physical activity levels is that we are terrible at making sacrifices in the present for our future self. Sure, we all avoid trans-fats, leaded fuel, and other similar choices; but all of these are largely forced on the entire population.