4 ms·
I honestly don't believe in five-nines and all that, but my experience is admittedly limited to sectors where it's more about point-in-time backup reliability (
by toyg 10y ago
I honestly don't believe in five-nines and all that, but my experience is admittedly limited to sectors where it's more about point-in-time backup reliability (finance management) than anything else.
As I said, it depends on what your definition of "critical system" is. For aviation, for instance, there are many other factors (shielding etc); no hardware is perfect for all uses.
> How do you evaluate the cost of a risk you cannot compute?
Easy: you come up with a worst-case scenario, make plans to address it, and the cost of implementing such plans is your cost. Say you assume you could get silent errors: you build test routines for actual data integrity and implement test systems for continuous checks. The cost of building and maintaining all that is the cost of (accepting) your risk.
- hga 10y agoTelcos, at least in times past, really tried to achieve a true 5 9s. I worked for Lucent in 2001 on an ultimately doomed product that was essential to the company's independent survival, a Media Gateway (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_gateway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_gateway) to supply the other half of their successful Softswitch Media Gateway Controller product, and my NoVa group worked with the Cincinnati people who were responsible for the 5ESS. One of my tasks was vetting the low level design of the persistent database, and it was intense at all levels. No spinning rust, that's for sure. Point-in-time recovery is a snap compared to that domain.
- marcosdumay 10y agoGood thing you pointed at aviation. Aviation standard goal is 9 nines of reliability, and many systems get there.