3 ms·
Everyone's grumpy about our (USA) elections, which use a terrible voting system (winner takes all), and then cynically conclude that all democracy is bad news.
by specialist 10y ago
Everyone's grumpy about our (USA) elections, which use a terrible voting system (winner takes all), and then cynically conclude that all democracy is bad news. Because people are stupid. And can't be trusted to do the right thing. Because reasons.
How do you currently choose new hires? Decide to ship (go/no go)? Probably something like Roman Evaluation.
How do you triage defects or choose features? Probably something like Approval Voting.
- eru 10y agoThere's also the possibility to vote on values, but bet on beliefs. Ie vote on your priorities and what you want to get done. Then use a prediction market (possibly on a very informal level, if it's a small group), to decide on a policy to reach those goals.
- ClayShentrup 10y ago"Winner takes all" is not a voting method, it just means single-winner districts. You can use an excellent winner-take-all method like Score Voting or Approval Voting.
- JanezStupar 10y agoThe country I live in uses a proportional voting system - and what happens is that one of the smallest and most narrow special interests party gets to be the the point of equilibrium - as nobody can form government without it. And then that party proceeds to blackmail everybody all the time. Thus all the governments need to pander to this particular party and they get to gridlock the government whenever they feel the smallest slight or displeasure.
- tremon 10y agonobody can form government without it Of course they can, they just choose not to. What you are saying is that the parties are choosing a blackmailer over a self-declared "enemy". That's a choice, it's not inevitable. Besides, if the political landscape is diverse enough, a minority coalition can be a boon for everyone: it means that the ruling parties must actually learn to cooperate with the opposition instead of dictating policy for the duration of their term.
- JanezStupar 10y agoYou are indeed correct. However our political landscape is polarized to a degree where minority coalition has no chance of doing anything. Not that any political problem could solve people acting as idiots.
- spacecowboy_lon 10y agoas the Hardline unionists did in the UK which is why northern irland lags the rest of the UK in civil rights