3 ms·
Absolutely. Just as we are (in my opinion) a result of emergent systems (evolution) - the systems we build should be expected to have emergent properties. And t
by e12e 10y ago
Absolutely. Just as we are (in my opinion) a result of emergent systems (evolution) - the systems we build should be expected to have emergent properties. And there are other systems we are beholden to (and impact) such as the biosphere and the climate.
Criticism of capitalism is often misunderstood, or misconstrued as "conspiracy theory" - while what it often is, is just pointing out the most likely and apparent emergent properties of capitalism - and likely follow-on effects of that. Examples are concentration of capital and power, ignoring "external costs" like environmental damage etc.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoPersonally I think "emergent" != "emergent". Most of the systems we build are pretty dumb - except our socioeconomic ones, which gain complexity by being formed by aggregating over billions of sentient beings. Now I'm having some trouble sorting out the categories in my head. On the one hand, the "emergence" you described in your comment is garden variety feedback loops. Something very simple in principle - and being a part of a feedback system literally means 'being beholden and impacting it'. On the other hand, it really feels like search for intelligence is in a big part just tweaking one's abstractions. You can see the market as "just" a complex set of feedback loops between individuals and groups, or hop one abstraction level above and realize that we're all components of a feedback system that's optimizing for something we as individuals have close to zero control over. A system that's bossing us all around. We try to understand it, so that we can say that e.g. prices of product X dropped because people in company Y invented some innovative process. But if one digs deeper one can sometimes notice that if it wasn't company Y then it would be a company Z; if it wasn't an innovative process then it would be an innovative business model (or a scam), or a substitute product X1. All because the "market pressures" made it happen. If you step another abstraction layer up, you can just treat the market as a being and it's not a big of a stretch. So at what point one should stop playing with abstractions? Or, maybe, what do we mean by "intelligence"? If we're looking for a different-but-mostly-similar being to talk to, then searching for it by doing abstraction dance is not a good way. But if by "intelligence" one means a sufficiently smart optimizer, one that can make decisions to reach its own goals, and that in principle could coerce us to do its bidding - if one means that, then one may realize this has already happened.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoSome of the things attributed to capitalism have nearly nothing to do with capitalism itself. I'm starting, for one, to think that there's probably less concentration of wealth and power than we think. Bill Gates is a heck of lot wealthier than was JP Morgan, but Morgan had a lot more concentrated power and wealth than Gates. Not to quibble, I just think our analysis is deeply flawed.