7 ms·
The Day I Got My Green Card
- jetcata 10y agoI love the "welcome home" from Passport control here in the US, I think it's amazing.
- z2 10y agoI don't mean to be snarky--I'm genuinely curious if you are being sarcastic here. As a US citizen, I've been met with indifference, or more likely, quizzed on the places I've been, my home address, or the contents of my luggage. Never once has the greeting been "Welcome home"
- jetcata 10y agoOh, I'm sorry you've never been greeted that way :( I'm not being sarcastic, the first time the officer said it to me I was amazed!
- thebooktocome 10y agoI've heard "welcome home" each time, coming through Seattle or Chicago over the past ten years.
- xyzzyz 10y agoI also heard that in Seattle, though it was a weird feeling, as I am not a citizen nor a permanent resident. At the time I thought it might be due to my frequent travel to the US.
- randallsquared 10y agoI was greeted that way flying into both Miami and Dulles, separated at times from 2000 to 2009.
- pandemicsyn 10y agoIts the same as retail/customer service based industries. I've never had a pleasant experience at Walmart, but at the bodega down the street things are different. Flying into a major hub like say Miami the agents just wanna get you through, flying into say...Cincinnati or San Antonio the pace is a bit slower and the customs agents more friendly.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoI get the"welcome home" every time (Dulles, JFK, Philly, Miami), it's one of those things that kind of caps off an international vacation for me.
- terinjokes 10y agoI usually return via SFO, and I don't think I've ever heard "Welcome Home". Last time (after a short vacation from the region) I was quizzed "Do you reside in New Zealand or Australia?" followed by "Move along."
- tschuy 10y agoIn SFO most recently, I was welcomed back only after I thanked the guy at passport control and told him to have a good day. It really depends on how passport control feels that day.
- akhilcacharya 10y agoI've gotten a "welcome back" returning from the UK to Boston.
- Manishearth 10y agoUS citizen here, originally from Boston. Logan immigration has been very friendly to me in the past. These days I'm not in Boston and usually come in through Newark Liberty. Half the time I get a nice friendly/chitchatty immigration officer who welcomes me back. Nowadays most airports do that electronic thing, so they don't even need to ask you questions since its all on that slip of paper. So a couple of times I've had them glance at the slip, and then just welcome me back with a smile.
- robbrit 10y agoDepends on the guard you get. I'm a Canadian citizen living in the US and I even get "welcome home" sometimes!
- GCA10 10y agoIt's a different experience each time ... but sometimes it's quite pleasant.
- laurencerowe 10y agoI've had a welcome home on my H1-B at SFO, made me feel quite warm and fuzzy. Also had much less pleasant experiences (the immigration officer who thought Europe was being overrun with Mislims.) As a white British person I've never had a welcome home from an immigration officer in the UK, but being greeted in the UK would seem weird.
- karterk 10y agoI'm really happy that the author found a place that he could truly call home. However, his generalisation of India largely based on a single incident comes across as rather shallow and naive. Yeah sure India has many quirks, but I can't find another country which has people from so many diverse backgrounds (religion, language, customs) who co-exist so peacefully. Let's also not forget that the legalisation of same-sex marriage is a recent development even in the USA.
- intopieces 10y ago>Yeah sure India has many quirks, but I can't find another country which has people from so many diverse backgrounds (religion, language, customs) who co-exist so peacefully. "India, one of the most diverse countries in the world with a population of 1.3 billion, experiences severe caste and tribal discrimination, and in recent decades has seen a notable increase in sectarian violence." Bettye Miller's piece on Ajay Verghese, author of The Colonial Origins of Ethnic Violence in India (2016) [0] [0]https://ucrtoday.ucr.edu/37140 https://ucrtoday.ucr.edu/37140
- Ar-Curunir 10y agoA notable increase does not imply a large amount of violence. And personally I doubt that India had less sectarian violence in the past; it was just covered less dramatically.
- lake99 10y agoI agree there, and lacking any concrete data, it's better to not pass off opinion or speculation as fact. For quite a lot of the sectarian violence, I blame the government and the political parties for having policies that favour some castes over others, and for being soft on sectarian violence. Moreover we, in the middle class, who lead lives far away from politics, are largely isolated from these shenanigans.
- intopieces 10y agoTruly, you and I operate with different definitions of "peaceful coexistence" if yours has room for tribal discrimination and sectarian violence.
- arkem 10y agoI got my green card yesterday. It took me eighteen months, which is a ridiculously short amount of time, if I had been from India instead of Australia it'd be another 6 years or so before anyone even looked at my application. For me a green card was a convenience rather than a necessity. It wasn't anything life changing as it was for the article's author. As a software engineer that qualified for a non-supply capped visa I could live in the US almost whenever I felt a need (I only needed to find an employer willing to fill out some extra paperwork for me). That said I'm really grateful to have my green card, I'm much less stressed about my future. I no longer worry about having to leave the US if I lose my job. Now, maybe I'll buy a house, maybe I'll start a business? Exciting new possibilities.
- smnscu 10y agoWhat kind of visa is that? I know L1 is a popular non-capped option, but that is for intra-company transfers.
- arkem 10y agoE-3 which is like a H1-B but for Australians (from a free trade agreement). It is capped per year but has never reached the limit.
- wilsynet 10y agoAn E-3 is more like a TN. The H1-B has a lengthy application process, there is a maximum number of consecutive years you can be on one, there are more applications than availability, there's a transfer process, it is dual intent, and what else? None of which are characteristics of the E-3, which is practically instant and infinitely renewable and expressly not dual intent.
- tsaprailis 10y agoIf I may ask, which visa category did you have and how did you get it?
- 10y ago
- breakpointe 10y agoI love this. I am a teenager who got permanent residency a few years ago. America is the land of opportunity, and as a software engineer I can earn a lot of money, much more than I would in my home country, India. So glad I can have a great quality of life here in the United States, with a great job. This country was made for someone like me.
- ThomPete 10y agoI got my greencard this winter. It took me less than two weeks to be approved and a couple of months to get it through all the bureaucracy. My wife and oldest son also got one. It helped that I was on an O1 before. I feel truly blessed and I have always felt home in the US. Now next step is dual citizenship (Denmark and the US have an agreement)
- ismdubey 10y agoThom, I am also an O1 filing an EB1-A. Did u file premium to be approved in less than two weeks?
- laurencerowe 10y agoI'm also switching from 0-1 to EB1-A. Premium processing only applies to the I-140 part (qualification for the category.) The I-485 adjustment of status still takes at least three months to be processed before you get the actual green card. The big advantage of the EB1 here is that I don't have to wait 9 months for the labor certification. Hopefully I'll get my advance parole a little sooner so I can travel again as having applied for the AOS I'm unable to re-enter the country on my O-1.
- ThomPete 10y agoYes.
- yashinm92 10y agoMay I ask what you do for a living? From what I understand O1 is a very difficult visa category to get into.
- coke12 10y agoHe's a designer. Lots of designers come in on O-1, most of them with far less impressive portfolios than his.
- selvakn 10y agoCongratulations!! Oh, another note: Looks like you know very little about India. Disclaimer: Indian, IT consultant.
- Manishearth 10y agoHe provided his experiences, you can't discount those. Your experiences may be more pleasant, but that doesn't mean he is wrong. I can say that I know others who have been through similar experiences.
- aub3bhat 10y agoHis Experience is entirely a prejudiced monologue. If you read it, its all about what he thinks that the other guy is thinking. Thats not an experience thats racism.
- Manishearth 10y agoI suspect he has experienced it often enough to know what is going on, he just didn't provide the full facts of why he thought so, which is understandable since that's not the subject of the article. I've been living in India for nearly a decade now. Casteism and religion-ism are very non-obvious to those unaffected (or positivrly affected) by it, but spend enough time outside your bubble and you start realizing that it exists often in an undercurrent and start recognizing situations like the one he talks of for what they really are. I've seen far more overt versions of his anecdote play out; I have no trouble believing him there.
- Ar-Curunir 10y agoIndia has the second largest Muslim population in the world; it's unlikely that whatever tone he inferred was from being Muslim. More likely is the case that the passport control person saw the British passport and commented on that. Moreover to state that the immigration officer inferred him speaking English as a sign of class is in itself racist; English is one of the official languages of the country, plenty of Indians speak very fluent English.
- miguelrochefort 10y agoMy dream is to get a Green Card. I don't have a degree. Is my only option to marry an American citizen?
- dominotw 10y agoyea i think that would be the only option if you don't have a degree. unless you are an Olympic medalist( for example( who can get O visa.
- chrisper 10y agoWork experience can replace the requirement for a degree (I think). Have you lived in the US before? It is not as great as it seems from the outside. (My dream once was to get a greencard, but I came to the US through a student visa and after some years I can say that that dream surely has gone away)
- somethingsimple 10y agoWhat did you find disappointing about the US? I moved here a few years ago and have had my Green Card for a while. The US is every bit as I expected and even more. I love this country more than I've ever loved my home country.
- chrisper 10y agoWhere did you move from? I think that makes the difference between loving it or not loving it.
- somethingsimple 10y agoBrazil.
- chrisper 10y agoYeah. I came here from a wealthy European country. So obviously my expectations and experiences will be different.
- vowelless 10y agoGot my green card a few months ago. Also from a mixed Indian, Pakistani, Middle Eastern and British background. Was a minority in all of those nations. Really feels good to call America a home. Aatish's father was a true light for Punjab. It's a shame what happened to him.
- brendangregg 10y agoFor someone who has been through visa abuse, exploitation, threats of deportation, and so on, getting a green card is like opening a book to day 1 of your life. You get your humanity back. If you have a great run in the US on a visa, great. But it's not like that for everyone.
- aub3bhat 10y agoThe writer is a typical british born indophobic racist. More people are killed in pakistan (his beloved land of pure) every year in sectarian and religious violence than in India. Blacks were treated far worse in USA up until 1965 and even today considering how many of them are disproportionately jailed. The authors hate towards india is misguided, and not supported by any statistical evidence of increase in "intolerance".
- ebiester 10y ago...including his own father, of which he speaks in the piece. So, how are gay people (of which he is as well) treated in India again? Is section 377 any closer to being repealed?
- dang 10y agoPlease don't feed flamewars on HN.
- aub3bhat 10y agoHis father was killed in Pakistan! Section 377 was enacted by british, the only opponents to its repeal in the current pending supreme court case are Catholic and Muslim organizations not a single hindu organization. And oh several ministers in the ruling party have called on supreme court to render it unconstitutional. So get your facts straight.
- ebiester 10y agoLet me clarify: The author mentions that his father was killed in Pakistan. That doesn't sound like an apologist for Pakistan. But the last vote was not exactly close.
- aub3bhat 10y agoPakistan has tumbled so down, that its impossible to apologise for, but author did commit sin of comparing india as if the situation in both countries were similar. India has as many muslims as pakistan, yet there hasn't been a single incidence of large scale sectarian violence directed against them in last decade, in Pakistan its a monthly occurrence. Regarding vote. What vote? The sham vote pulled by an outgoing congress MP in a parliament session that was obstructed by his own party members. The ones who refused a vote (and haven't still) on important economic & tax legislations. It was his own party with him as a minister that was in power for several years when the initial supreme court decision was made. And that the biggest obstacle to indian parliament passing any gay rights legislation would not be BJP but rather from smaller parties which are trying to appease minority religious groups. While section 377 gets all the attention, the Indian parliament is also working on a transgender rights bill, which given indian context and historical discrimination faced by them is of higher a importance. Indian politics due to the fact that its a functioning democracy is complicated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rights_of_Transgender_Persons_Bill,_2014 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rights_of_Transgender_Persons_...
- realkitkat 10y agoAny discussion about Green Cards or permanent US residency should always mention eventual exit tax[1]: "...to deter tax avoidance by abandonment of citizenship, the United States imposes an expatriation tax on some of those who give up U.S. citizenship. The tax also applies to green-card holders who abandon U.S. residency after having held a green card for at least 8 of the last 15 tax years." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expatriation_tax#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expatriation_tax#United_States
- henrikschroder 10y agoI thought that only applied to citizens! What the hell, America?
- arkem 10y agoThank you for the reminder. I've just added a calendar entry for 6 years time to consider whether or not I am willing to be subject to an exit tax (and give myself two years to plan alternatives if I'm not).
- ismdubey 10y agoA problem in the author's piece is putting India and Pakistan at the same pedestal. Consider this: (1) Till date, not a single person has been charged in India for being homsexual. Being a homosexual is a crime in India. Yes, its a colonial legacy and in spite of indian bureaucracy being slow, people in govt are working to get rid of it. The less we talk about Pakistan, better it is (2) Indian metropolis have a vibrant LGBTQ community. Suffice it to say, that there have been many pride parades in different cities of india. Contrast this with Pakistan, where a pride parade organized by US embassy in 2011 sparked protests. (3) Author's claim about Sedition charges on university students - There have been massive protests against the govt in India because of this. Govt made a mockery of themselves with this action (as is evident). All the guys charged with sedition are still expressing their dissent against the govt and more forcefully now. (4) To any of you who have been to the countries of Indian subcontinent, I am sure you can see the difference.
- WWKong 10y agoI would love to write a similar article of my own. It has been 13 yrs of being in US, paying high-bracket taxes, raising a family, buying a home, befriending tons of wonderful folks, contributing to the community and generally being a good citizen. It might be another 2 to 4 years. Although it is hard to complain and I feel I have gotten more out of life here than given back, I often wonder what it has done to my psyche of not being at "home".
- bn-usd-mistake 10y agoMy dream is to migrate to the US eventually. Not so much for the incredibly better pay but just because it seems there's much more interesting stuff to work on there. I'm German and currently doing my Master of Computer Science in Germany. Do you have any advice on which path would maximize my chance of getting a visa? Or possibly your personal success story? So far, I will be doing an internship at one of the Big 4 and will be trying to get a job at the Big 4 in Europe or some other company in London (provided I can still migrate there post-Brexit) after my graduation. But I'd be glad to get other (possibly better) suggestions. EDIT: Added Paragraphs.
- navalsaini 10y ago“Aatish Ali?” one said to me just a few months ago as I arrived in New Delhi. “Quite a name you’ve got there.” The subtext was: You’re not part of the Hindu majority, so not part of the deeper organization of caste. This is an incorrect interpretation. Aatish means a cracker and possible the office was being humorous. The sense of humor is a bit different in India and a little more crude (though harmless).