6 ms·
I feel certain that in the near future we will discover animals are a lot smarter and more emotionally developed than we currently realize, and future generatio
by grecy 10y ago
I feel certain that in the near future we will discover animals are a lot smarter and more emotionally developed than we currently realize, and future generations will look back on our treatment of them with disgust.
- hellofunk 10y agoI can highly recommend the book "Ravens in Winter" that shows just how complex and advanced the social structure is of these birds.
- kefka_p 10y agoWe've already demonstrated that some animals stand well above the capabilities we've historically attributed to them. While I don't share your enthusiasm for an improvement in human behavior as a consequence, I believe the nature of such intelligence is entirely too obvious to be ignored entirely. :)
- Aelinsaar 10y agoOur behavior will improve the instant that improvement doesn't represent an inconvenience for the average person. :|
- agumonkey 10y agoI have a weird metaphor. I grew up feeding on the 8bit period. A few years before I lost love for games. They grade objectively higher in most dimensions yet something isn't better. Resolutions aren't a defining variable. Old games limited in colors, dimensions, length, space etc etc still have the most important genes (gameplay?). This is how I feel about humans vs animals. They have the fundamental layers (fear, bond, game, space), we may have (I'm not qualified to claim more) a ridiculously larger upper brain that we use to reflect on this traits (we question emotions, etc), but in the end we don't have lots more than them.
- ekianjo 10y ago> I feel certain that in the near future we will discover animals are a lot smarter and more emotionally developed than we currently realize, and future generations will look back on our treatment of them with disgust. Replace animals by "slaves" or whatever human race we considered inferior in the past and you could write the same thing about a couple of hundred years ago. But the idea that humans are at the acme of evolution is going to be harder to kill.
- okasaki 10y agoYou're not the only one I think that all this time, human beings have been watched by creatures whose perceptions and understanding have been so far in advance of anything we have been able to accept, because of our vanity, that we would be appalled if we were able to know, would be humiliated. We have been living with them as blundering, blind, callous, cruel murderers and torturers, and they have watched and known us. And this is the reason we refuse to acknowledge the intelligence of the creatures that surround us: the shock to our amour propre would be too much, the judgement we would have to make on ourselves too horrible: it is exactly the same process that can make someone go on and on committing a crime, or a cruelty, knowing it: the stopping and having to see what has been done would be too painful, one cannot face it. -- Doris Lessing
- y4mi 10y agohah, as if the abuse would stop with that acknowledgement. its beyond unlikely that we, as the human race, become vegetarian. as such, we'll never stop abusing other animals beside us. on that note: i'm not a vegetarian either, nor am i planning to become one.
- andai 10y agoI'm curious, could you kill an animal and cut it up? Do you realize you pay people to do this every time you buy meat? Are you cool with that?
- MawNicker 10y agoNo, I couldn't do it. Too disgusting. Yes, I do realize that's what I'm paying for. It's expensive but then I don't have to do the icky part. I'm cool with it. I watched a video of a guy jabbing a cow with a pitchfork. It was pretty shitty. I think you could withhold any violence until the animal's final moments. That gets into realities of industrial efficiency and not the eating of meat. Things die. Should we cremate them? I realize going vegetarian solves the problem right now. That doesn't mean that eating meat is necessarily a part of the problem. I eat out a lot so I don't get all my meat from one source. But the meat I use at home I buy from a friend of my family. He raises the cows himself and "loves" them. My sister likes to go out there and feed them. It's a bit too mushy for me but I still like to think their happiness makes them taste better.
- 6stringmerc 10y ago...and then we'll all take a look at the animal kingdom and see that Chimps and Dolphins and all sorts of species treat each other - and other species - with innate brutality, and realize this planet is simply one giant cage match.
- rokosbasilisk 10y agoIf animals are more intelligent then we think, it really puts the chimp and dolphin behavior in a new light.
- Pxtl 10y agoWe have the technology and wealth to be more ethical than callous nature, we just choose not to be.
- nilved 10y agoWho is to say that callousness is more or less ethical?
- danharaj 10y agoNature is inhuman, not in the sense that it is cruel but that it is devoid of human characteristics. Nature is neither tender nor callous, those are human traits. Nature is not unethical or ethical, ethics is for humans. It is interesting to ponder what the nature of other animals is; discover what possibilities we have in common with them. That doesn't change that humans are capable of self examination and choosing between cruelty and tenderness, empathy and callousness.
- d0100 10y agoIf an animal can't communicate complex thought, he is just an animal. No matter how "smart" or "emotionally developed" they appear. Until then it's just instinct. And if the day ever arrives, it can just be seen as an evolutionary step for the species, and not as proof that they where intelligent all along.
- mjlangiii 10y agoYeah, people seem to want to decrease the degree of separation between humans and animals. The scientists probably reach a bit in their conclusions, for many reasons, and readers seem to me they may have some latent desire to bring humans and animals closer together, like they want a grand unifying law of life and ethics or maybe a link to our past and how consciousness evolved which could mean we have more reason to treat animals more like equals. I get it, that all seems good and fine. But looking at the general evidence I still conclude there is a huge difference between animals and people. And I think the results of experiments don't change anything, regardless of what they find we should respect animals even though they're "just animals". I liked the experience vs awareness model presented in Stumbling Upon Happiness where people think about the future (awareness of what's happening to them/others) and animals simply operate in the moment based on instincts and being informed by memories (experience). I think that is a pretty good model for the difference.
- fao_ 10y agoDefine 'complex', and 'communicate'. Are deaf and blind people "just animals", no matter how -your quotes- "smart" or "emotionally developed" they appear?
- d0100 10y agoNo need to stretch what I said. Communicate has a well defined meaning: share or exchange information, news, or ideas. And 'complex' was used to exclude what I consider instinctual feelings/thoughts: anger, hunger, love, happiness, obedience, etc. The deaf and blind can communicate. And even in the case of a human vegetable, a broken table is still a table.
- internaut 10y agoJust as we have Seed Banks in the world, I believe we ought to have Animal Arks. These are very large open habitats with difficult to pass barriers. Little human involvement is permitted and trespassing carries an instantaneous death penalty. I see this as the only plausible way to prevent the disappearance of Rhino, Elephant, Cheetah and many other animals that you had plastic toys of when you were a child. Those animals are going to be as extinct as the dinosaurs toys you played with in our lifetime. https://xkcd.com/1338/ https://xkcd.com/1338/ We have very little biodiversity in Europe, outside of our domestic animals the typical country has nothing much larger than foxes or squirrels running around. Conservation is a patriotic planet wide duty for humans and it is one of the few things that ought to go over traditional rivalries. I do not accept for example, that Africans, South Americans or Southeast Asians have the right to demolish important species because they are within their political territories. There is no moral reason not to simply extract them from there using a combination of carrot and stick since they are clearly incapable of handling the problem themselves at this stage of development, just as Europeans were back in the 1700s not exactly looking out for the plight of endangered wolves, boars or bears. Most major insights into biology and medicine come from having a variety of species around. So it is not as if we have no self interest. Ultimately any 'Arks' would be easily repaid for millions of times over in a variety of ways, even if just because you would ultimately be the only available source of rare biomaterials.
- ZeroFries 10y agoInstantaneous death penalty? Glad you're not in charge...
- internaut 10y agoI imagine it to be a cross between Jurassic Park and The Hunger Games. The predators shall of course be located at the peripheral. If the robots don't get them, the swimming knives will. With reality TV we may even turn a profit! To be serious, there is no real plan to prevent the level of poaching from killing off most large land mammals. I've been helping the Hoedspruit Endangered Species Centre and the Pangolin Specialist Group but most people in the field don't really believe this is a sustainable long term objective for conservation. The scale of predation by humans is simply too high for anything less than drastic action to prevent the extinction of most large land mammals.
- bchjam 10y ago"smart" is often interpreted as a measure of skills with symbol systems, rather than any general capacity to cultivate understanding. it wasn't that long ago that this sort of reactionary logic was used to justify enslaving large populations of humans. bias borne from the relative locality of individual existence is hardly a solved problem for humanity. In future I'd hope for greater understanding and less disgust
- booleandilemma 10y agoI think a lot of it has to do with emotional connection too. If I traveled to some Southeast Asian country and I was offered dog meat, I'd probably try it. If however, someone tried to cook and feed me my own dog I would be horrified.
- mablap 10y agoI have always lived surrounded by animals, mostly cats, dogs, hamsters, rabbits etc. People who haven't usually completely underestimate the level of communication and emotional bonding that can happen between two species.
- projektir 10y agoI don't see why animals need to be smart or emotionally developed for our treatment of them to evoke disgust.
- dragontamer 10y agoBased on the reactions of: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2016/05/19/when-nest-cams-get-gruesome-some-viewers-cant-take-it/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2016/05/19/w... I think the vast majority of people are actually in the opposite situation. Animals have been humanized by cartoons. So when birds start pushing each other from nests, when Eagles start feeding cats to their eaglets, when Kangaroos attempt to mate on dead corpses... https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/jan/14/photos-grieving-kangaroo-viral-but-scientist-says-sexually-aroused https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/jan/14/photos-griev... People don't really believe it. Animals are vicious.
- devuo 10y agoIn the near future? Please. Think of all the daily horrors humans commit towards one another and you'll see we're still way off from that future.
- shawn-butler 10y agoYes, our actions will be SO important to future generations. I'm sure much ink will be spilled. The narcissism is real.