8 ms·
The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix
- patcheudor 10y agoIt needs a massive fix, starting with WiFi. "The drive, ability, and sheer will to change a WiFi password is inversely proportional to the number of devices one manages on a WiFi network." http://thefutureisastephenkingnovel.com/assets/player/KeynoteDHTMLPlayer.html#31 http://thefutureisastephenkingnovel.com/assets/player/Keynot...
- Er-c 10y agoYes, this is so true. I am curious to see an elegant solution for this particular problem.
- patcheudor 10y agoIt was suppose to be WPS but it turned out to be a disaster.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoEvery Wifi router needs to treat every device on the network as independently untrusted, except where explicitly told to do otherwise. Outbound connections aren't as big a problem as every random device having full access to a home network.
- snuxoll 10y agoThis is why I have two separate SSID's, one goes to my 'trusted' VLAN of home devices that have access to the rest of the network - the other goes to an 'untrusted' VLAN that has access to NOTHING except to pfSense for routing (and any access to the pfSense admin page is blocked from that interface since it's only bound to the other VLAN). MY stuff (desktops, cell phones, laptops, game consoles) goes on the first, everything else goes on the second (guest devices, appliances that are less than trustworthy and have no reason to touch the rest of my network, etc).
- kps 10y agoSimilar. My open ‘guest’ SSID is layer-2 switched to the upstream modem only. (I suppose it's possible that the modem could be compromised and send frames back to the LAN, but I see no evidence of that.)
- bigiain 10y agoI've been pondering this recently. Does your setup (easily) allow for things like untrusted IoT powerpoints/lights on the untrusted network to be controlled by their regular apps running on a phone hooked to the trusted network? I haven't quite worked out a simple-but-correct solution for that at my place yet. I have come up with a concept of "any device who's software I'm not actively updating and managing for security shouldn't be on the same network as my backup NAS". That includes not just IoT crap, but my original (cant upgrade past iOS5) iPad, my printer, my 3D printer's Windows machine, most of my Raspberry Pis, and friends and family's phones/tablets/laptops...
- mschuster91 10y ago> Does your setup (easily) allow for things like untrusted IoT powerpoints/lights on the untrusted network to be controlled by their regular apps running on a phone hooked to the trusted network? Sure, if the control uses direct IP connections it's just a matter of adding some routes - if using broadcast UDP, not so much.
- snuxoll 10y agoI do have access from my trusted network to the untrusted one, but not the other way around (ACL's on my switch prevent the untrusted VLAN from accessing anything but my pfSense router for internet access). Regardless of this, however, they are separate broadcast domains, so if I can't just punch in an IP address to access it I won't be able to use it (and this excludes a lot of proprietary "Smart" devices that rely on mDNS+DNS-SD or TCP/UDP broadcast for discovery without any option for direct IP connection). If I ever bought into the "Connected" / "Smart" home (and I probably will, it would be really nice to open my garage from my phone and have lights automatically turn on, monitor the thermostat remotely, etc) I will probably invest in standards-compliant devices that use Zigbee or Z-Wave and setup OpenHAB - all of these proprietary "Smart" devices just seem dumb when you have to rely on external services like IFTTT to integrate them, really defeats the whole purpose and I don't like being locked into specific brands / ecosystems when semi-open standards exist.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe only difference between an outbound and an inbound connection, and most particularly from an Internet of Shit untrusted, incompetently designed, compromised-on-sight device, is who commits the first SYN. (Why does it always come back to the original SYN?) Dan Kaminsky's demonstrated streaming video over DNS. There's NFS-over-SMTP. If there's a transport, you can tunnel over it. https://www.defcon.org/html/links/dc_press/archives/12/cbr_dnshack.htm https://www.defcon.org/html/links/dc_press/archives/12/cbr_d... Tools to limit specific internal hosts to specific external nodes might help. No need for any Internet of Shit device to talk randomly to anywhere on the Internet. But from past experience, vendor hosts are bad enough. Particularly if you can't tell from IP or hostname who owns it (datacenters, virtual hosting, AWS).
- mschuster91 10y agoSwitch your WiFi to RADIUS authentication, give every device its own "username"/"password", be done. Downside: it usually only works with phones and laptops, but IoT crap usually doesn't speak WPA-Enterprise.
- Retric 10y agoInternet of things needs a point. It's more about features for features sakes than anything else. Sure, a manufacture can add wifi for ~1$, but then what.
- krapp 10y ago>Sure, a manufacture can add wifi for ~1$, but then what. Analytics, surveillance and lock-in. Require the user to apply for an online account and charge them a monthly fee to do something online that used to be free, monitor their usage and make it difficult for them to use another brand's products without significant friction.
- Retric 10y agoGreat now what's the killer app? I have seen an internet connected blender, toaster, refrigerator, microwave, vaccume, coffee maker, oven, dishwasher, close washer and dryer. But not a single reason to buy any of them. AV, lights, thermostat, blinds, sure. But, that's 30 year old home automation stuff not 'the Internet of things'.
- krapp 10y agoA killer app for consumers probably wouldn't exist for most things, unless you could integrate streaming or delivery services. But I think the real killer app will help correlate consumer behavior, advertising and the supply chain. You could have a refrigerator that keeps track of everything you buy and where you bought it. Scaled up to tens of thousand or millions of consumers, you might have very useful data for stores to use to predict what to stock and how much, and how to target advertisements. I'm reminded of the story of Wal-Mart predicting one of their customer's pregnancies based on their purchasing habits, and sent coupons for related products. I also think integration with social media is going to be a huge part of the IoT taking off but I'm not entirely sure how, yet, other than vague ideas about appliances having their own AI driven social media accounts and posting to your feed. That could both be useful, and an incredibly sinister way of getting consumers to empathize emotionally with a brand, even if only subconsciously.
- JaymesKeller 10y agoSadly, knowing most companies, it will be more likely an internet of crap, with lock-ins and microtransactions up the wazoo.
- endgame 10y agoAn internet of shit, even? https://twitter.com/internetofshit https://twitter.com/internetofshit
- kps 10y agoBack in the kitchen he fished in his various pockets for a dime, and, with it, started up the coffeepot. Sniffing the-to him-very unusual smell, he again consulted his watch, saw that fifteen minutes had passed; he therefore vigorously strode to the apt door, turned the knob and pulled on the release bolt. The door refused to open. It said, "Five cents, please." He searched his pockets. No more coins; nothing. "I'll pay you tomorrow," he told the door. Again he tried the knob. Again it remained locked tight. "What I pay you," he informed it, "is in the nature of a gratuity; I don't have to pay you." "I think otherwise," the door said. "Look in the purchase contract you signed when you bought this conapt." In his desk drawer he found the contract; since signing it he had found it necessary to refer to the document many times. Sure enough; payment to his door for opening and shutting constituted a mandatory fee. Not a tip. "You discover I'm right," the door said. It sounded smug. From the drawer beside the sink Joe Chip got a stainless steel knife; with it he began systematically to unscrew the bolt assembly of his apt's money-gulping door. "I'll sue you," the door said as the first screw fell out. — Ubik, Philip K Dick, 1969
- intrasight 10y agoPKD was, as usual, decades ahead of his time. I guess one can do that when one's mind is invaded by an alien superbeing.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoAlso a topic today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12023728 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12023728 ("As a psychiatrist, I diagnose mental illness. Also, I help spot demonic possession." ;-) Although he did find recognition and prizes, in his lifetime P.K.Dick made SF fans - who mostly tended to staunch rationalism, or a good facsimile thereof - uneasy due to the slightly unhinged mysticism coming through. But he did hit a bell with resonance in the mainstream: after Stephen King he's probably the writer with most movie adaptations of his stories.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoIt will be vastly amusing when turning on a lamp or a microwave will require authorization from a machine in Kansas (or Kazakhstan, whatever).
- turnip1979 10y agoAs a casual gamer, I run into this quite a bit. Want to play online? Need a gigabyte update. Want to use Skype. . gotta merge your accounts. Makes me miss the days of the SNES and n64.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI've thought for a long time that internet connectivity was the worst thing to happen to console gaming. I liked consoles because games worked out of the box, without dicking around with accounts, services, etc. If i want to deal with that, I'll just play on my PC
- RGamma 10y agoInternet is the ultimate DRM. An interface to exchange arbitrary information with effectively secret infrastructure? "Perfect, let's just stream monitor contents like OnLive, they'll never guess the game's code from this to run on their own computers." It seems one of the major reasons that stopped OnLive were the latencies, let's hope it stays that way if you care about gaming culture.
- ams6110 10y agoIt also contributes to buggy games. If you know you can't update them, you make damn sure they work out of the box because refunds/recalls are expensive. If you know you can just push an update whenever, you have a lot less motivation to get it right.
- Arkaad 10y agoSure, but I think we can say that today's games are much more complex that what they used to be.
- robohamburger 10y agoI think the name itself is broken. Most applications just need to be a local network of things. Having a million device thats that are difficult to audit, configure and sensitive to internet and service outages is a nightmare recipe. Not sure how to solve this in an easy to fix way but it makes me miss the days of RFCs and standards. Seems like we need something higher level than z-wave, zigbee and 802.11.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI've been saying for years: I love the network of things. I hate the internet of things
- intrasight 10y agoWow. First I've heard that expression. I wholeheartedly agree.
- singham 10y agoIf it isn't connected to Internet how is it going to have new features. How is it going to take advantage of machine learning?
- quantumhobbit 10y agoMaybe the current feature set is enough; it is what the customer bought after all. ML algos can be pretrained before shipment and the model baked into the device. Online training can be gamed just like search optimization games Google search; in fact it is a pretty big security hole.
- SolarNet 10y agoSome internet/local network server on the network should provide software to do that. This software should be competed on separate from the network of thing devices individually (and should probably have open source interfaces and implementations; an industry consortium like the Khronos group - OpenGL, OpenCL, Vulkan, etc. - would be perfect). You could buy a pre-built box for it, it might get folded into the future all-in-1 router/modem (website) or console/TV box, you can have your laptop or old desktop do it, etc. That way there is a single authoritative device to secure and control everything with, a single device to reset if it becomes compromised, etc. Updates can be in cryptographically signed bundles from their manufacturers. And any smart algorithms can be run through the server. Arbitrary code execution on devices would be strongly discouraged by industry practice.
- paulsutter 10y agoThe actual Internet of things is Tesla collecting 130 million miles of autopilot data to make autopilot safer. It's GE collecting data from the jet engines they produce to understand failures and do predictive maintenance. It's Netapp collecting error logs from fileservers in the field, so they know how to prioritize their bug database, which performance bottlenecks to fix, and what limitations actual customers encounter. That's the real internet of things. Just ignore all the (hype for) idiotic connected home crap covered by the popular press. Yes vendors are producing these products but the only feature I want is a a global disable for any such thing I accidentally bring into my home.
- RGamma 10y ago> Just ignore all the idiotic connected home crap covered by the popular press. Funny, that's what a black hat would say who compromises tens of thousands of homes because of a shitty consumer device. And a global disable, how's that going to work? The "IoT" is a major crapshoot, because any idiot can hook up their garbage to the internet and (inadvertently) enable RCE (remote code execution) on it compromising the home network of the user even if it doesn't state that risk on the tin (as if you could prove that with current methods). The world hasn't seen an incident big enough to care, but I bet one is coming (look for cutesy names like Heartbleed and Stagefright in the headlines) and it will be the usual game of hindsight that leads politicians to go public about it as it has been the case with any major invention (cigarettes, alcohol, cars) that found its way into the public's hands. The golden age of black hats is before us still. I wish I could say I wouldn't be affected...
- enraged_camel 10y agoI don't mind Internet-connected home devices, as long as they: a) are actually secure b) do not send any data to the vendor or any third-party services
- carterehsmith 10y agoI would love it, but it looks like it will take time. As for security, we've been building PCs and such for decades and still are just beginning to get it right. Looks like one really needs a TPM chip as in Chromebook or iPhone. That may be too expensive for many devices, hell, it is apparently too expensive for most desktops, laptops etc. As for sending data. Seems like an IOT vendor would hope to sell the usage data. That does seem to have some value.
- Animats 10y agoThe way this ought to work is that you have a home server that talks to all your home devices, and can also be reached from the outside world with suitable security. A "cloud" service is unnecessary. Unfortunately, we're not going to get that, unless some carrier such as AT&T or Comcast pushes it.
- potatolicious 10y agoTo some degree both Apple and Google seem to be pushing towards that. In iOS 10 your phone/tablet talks directly to home devices, and if you have an Apple TV it allows secure tunneling (e.g., talking to your devices via the always-on Apple TV). Ditto Google is working on similar things, though the precise plans are a bit more uncertain. An "actual" home server in the form of a computer in a closet is IMO incredibly unlikely. Piggy-backing this functionality into an existing always-on device seems much more likely for mass adoption. The big issue is that IoT manufacturers will be fighting this tooth and nail. Nobody wants to be a commodity IoT manufacturer, and so all of them will try to push their own (shitty) cloud platforms as value-adds and avoid commoditization. Similar to how Android OEMs keep crufting up a perfectly fine OS in a futile bid to prevent commoditization. It won't work, but they will try.
- bigiain 10y ago> An "actual" home server in the form of a computer in a closet is IMO incredibly unlikely. You're right - my Mom's not gonna install a "home server" when she convinces Dad some WiFi controlled lightbulbs or powerpoints from the supermarket are a nice idea. It seems "the industry's" current solution to this is via some 3rd party P2P network: http://krebsonsecurity.com/2016/02/this-is-why-people-fear-the-internet-of-things/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/2016/02/this-is-why-people-fear-t... What could possibly go wrong?
- intrasight 10y agoHere's one area where I think some government regulation is going to be called for. If nothing else, it should be mandated that one can "disconnect" and still have the device function to consumers expectations. That should apply to everything from watches to cars.
- swiley 10y agoThat kind of registration sometimes works in the beginning but quickly becomes a mountain of irrelevant requirements and paperwork.
- teslaberry 10y agothe countries that try and force centralized IoT infrastructure like netherlands as a test case for the EU and eventually China will do it and probably Japan, are going to have the biggest problems with the IoT, possibly financially and industrially significant problems. the 'IoT' dream that was much heralded by oracle and the likes of many has died . the apologists argue that all that is needed is government decree and centralization by force. sure, a few socialist and centrally forced governments may jump into the ring, and sure a few mega corporations will get rich off government at the expense of the people , and of course some good might even come out of it. but a problem of organizing complexity at this scale is DEFINITELY going to be unsolved by forcing a reductionist solution for the sake of some corporate and government bureacrats to have bragging rights. this whole human technology project is not going to happen as fast as the startup venture vulture capital world would like. MOST if not 99% of IoT related companies will go bust. look at nest, google is already shuttering most of its billion dollar 3 year old aquisition. this is just the start........... that doesn't mean much was not gained, but as they say---------fail often fail early . well, as for the IoT that means we need a few decades of failure, staged decades of staged failures. eventually it will all come together well if governments don't get involved. if they do, you can guarantee the result will be a half baked obamacare style mess that will one day have to be scrapped anyways due to its fatal design flaws.
- unusximmortalis 10y agoIt was never intended to be internet of things literally. There's now way to scale to that level where all tiny devices are connected. It was ment to be the local network of things exactly like someone else pointed out here. The things will be connected on the local nerwork behind the home router. The IoT is a buzz word that was catchy and market pushed it farther cause it sells well. For as long as these things and what surrounds them are secure (as secure and safe as my router is) and they respect my privacy policies I will vote up them big time and they will grow farther be sure of that at the same rate and speed as the other tech wave is/was.
- digi_owl 10y agoconsumer routers are usually anything but secure in the iot sense. This because while they block unsolicited inbound traffic, they will allow any outbound traffic. And if you have upnp enabled on it, and most come with it on by default, all bets are off. Damn it, Samsung managed to produce and sell a voice controlled TV that sends everything the microphones pick up back to the mothership unencrypted.
- fcanela 10y agoI honestly do not understand the IoT hate. Yes, there is a lot of insecure devices: mostly the not-cloud ones which needs an open port. But IMHO they provide a lot of value, especially if you are a developer. At least it does for me.
- Pica_soO 10y agoIm very sorry Sir, your house has a virus. We have to put it down.
- digi_owl 10y agoIoT is a corporate pipe dream. Just about the only thing that could use a internet connection is my fridge, and then only after every damn thing in it has a NFC tag to go with their bar code. Meaning that it could keep a constant watch on its content etc, and allow me to check what is there (and not starting to develop its own lifeforms) when i am out shopping groceries. For all the rest i need to be physically present to load and unload them with something anyways, so unless they come laden with enough sensors that i can bring up a full diagnostics on a whim (and actually do more than order a whole new machine, thank you very much) I'll pass on IoT.