3 ms·
- Being able to install updates without asking the ISP. Sibling comment covers this perfectly. - Fast lanes for their services with ISPs. I haven't heard of
by MBCook 10y ago
- Being able to install updates without asking the ISP.
Sibling comment covers this perfectly.
- Fast lanes for their services with ISPs.
I haven't heard of this, it just seems like a good idea from the ISPs side given how big Apple is. Do you have any evidence they've actually forced someone to do this?
- Making illegal deals with book publishers so they get preferential pricing. Same for music.
You mean a pretty standard most-favored-nation clause? The kind that lots of goods are sold with? Or are you talking about getting rid of the right for Apple to undercut the price of the book and force the publishers to eat the loss?
It's not like Amazon had a ridiculous giant horrible stranglehold on the eBook industry right?
- WayneBro 10y ago> Sibling comment covers this perfectly. Which one? The one that asked if it was wrong for carriers to block updates in the first place? Right vs wrong isn't my concern here. Here is the sum of my comment: Apple used their market pressure to make carriers (and others) change. Now they're whining about somebody trying to make them change. That's all. I didn't say that I have evidence that they force carriers to do anything through any means other than market pressure. > You mean a pretty standard most-favored-nation clause? No. I mean the illegal price fixing that they were convicted of 3 times. You can read the rulings here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Apple_Inc.#Rulings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Apple_Inc.#Ru... The final ruling - "In June 2015, the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals by a 2-1 vote concurs with Judge Cote that Apple conspired to e-book price fixing and violated federal antitrust law."
- MBCook 10y agoI'm not a believer in the idea that breaking up an illegal monopoly by selling books under a reasonable contract the publishers came up with before Apple was involved is a criminal act on Apple's part. That case never made sense except as a way to generate headlines by attacking Apple. Amazon had a TRUE monopoly in eBooks and WAS abusing it.
- canuckintime 10y agoAmazon had no more of a monopoly with the Kindle and eBooks than Apple did with the iPod and AAC.
- MBCook 10y agoThat's not true. The fact of the matter is Amazon had a huge lion's share of the market for e-books (measured by $$$). They had such a huge monopoly position that they could dictate terms to all publishers, more than once they refused to carry a publishers e-books (effectively killing them) if a publisher didn't agreed to some terms that Amazon wanted. They would stop selling PHYSICALS books to push the contract. Since no one else old e-books in any reasonable quantity, Amazon was in the monopsony position of being the only real buyer. So not only did they do that, what they really like doing with selling Kindles. And a great way to sell Kindles is to discount the books below the actual selling price; eating the loss and making the publishers e-books on other platforms (as well as physical books) worth less. To a fair degree it didn't matter to Amazon if the prices were unsustainable, it fueled growth in their devices which fueled growth in their profits. And then they would do something like push Prime since you could get free books that way (more loss for publishers) and Amazon would make up the money. And the publishers could either choose to go along with it and get a small price for each book or say no and get all their e-books pulled. Plus Amazon had cable direct, which was a publishing platform that anyone could access. This meant that they had TONS of content by authors who were willing to sell it dirt cheap. This put the publishers in the same position that the media is right now competing with YouTube. And of course some of those books were actually really really good (Silo series by Howey) and became great sellers. Maybe even books that the publishers had passed on. It wasn't all garbage. So Amazon could show the publishers that they weren't nearly as necessary as the publishers thought they were. Apple NEVER did anything like that. When Apple sold music it was at a flat price. They never undercut the publisher. After a little while to even let the publishers raise prices. And the whole time selling on the iTunes Music Store was an option since you could still sell CDs or sell to other DRM music stores like Amazon. Amazon was easily the standard oil of the e-book market. They WERE the e-book market. No one ever went after them. Then Apple came along, is part of the deal with publishers that broke Amazons monopoly, and they got an antitrust suit. None of that makes any sense to me.