5 ms·
>> Self driving tech is poised to save many many lives. Based on what?
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
>> Self driving tech is poised to save many many lives.
Based on what?
- pacificmint 10y ago> Based on what? Human drivers are very bad. We kill over 32,000 people a year (and that's a 60 year low, just a few years ago it was over 40,000). So if self driving cars are just a little better than humans, they will save many lives. If they are a lot better than us, they will save many more.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoYou have to make a comparison if you want to pass a judgement that something is "bad". Bad compared to what?
- pacificmint 10y ago> Bad compared to what? Bad compared to pretty much every other form of transportation that humans employ.
- vacri 10y agoIf they are just a little worse than humans, they will cost many lives. If they are a lot worse than us, they will cost many more.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> if self driving cars are (...) That's a hypothetical. You say autonomous cars are "poised" to save many lives -not even avoid many deaths, actively "save". That's very strong language to use based on an "if" that nobody yet knows the answer to with any certainty. That is, unless you are privy to some information that the rest of us are not? Are you? What is it that you base your assertion on? Do you base it on anything or is it just a pretty turn of phrase you thought sounded cool?
- Nadya 10y agoNot who you are questioning. There are already videos of assisted-driving cars avoiding accidents which likely would have been fatal. We already know they can potentially save lives. It's something we already accept for flying. Autopilot in planes has resulted in deaths of crew and passengers. So we have precedent in at least one mode of transportation. Drivers get T-boned or rear end other people all the time. Those are two scenarios where driver-assist could have applied the brakes and actively saving lives for drivers inattentiveness. You'll also find no shortage of Liveleak clips of people being killed by drivers who failed to see them and brake in time. Many being scenarios that Google's self-driving cars have the technology to avoid.
- brokenmachine 10y agoPlanes don't have to deal with semi-trailers or wildlife appearing suddenly in their path regularly either. Autopilot in a plane doesn't have to deal with obstacles besides the odd mountain here and there. So I'd say that in many (most?) ways it's easier and safer to autopilot a plane than a car, and as you say, even planes with autopilot have failed.
- protomyth 10y ago> Planes don't have to deal with semi-trailers or wildlife appearing suddenly in their path regularly either Planes most certainly do have to deal with wildlife (e.g. birds) appearing suddenly in their path regularly.
- abduhl 10y agoThis is a ridiculous statement. Are you seriously saying that birds regularly fly at over 30000 ft? Or are you trying to imply that autopilot during landing/takeoff actively tracks birds and tries to avoid them? In other words, the plane autopilot doesn't "deal" with wildlife at all unless you count running into it. Which is apparently what Tesla autopilot does as well.
- takeda 10y agoHuman programmers are even worse we make 15-50 bugs per 1000 lines of code. Also don't forget that while each of us is somewhat unique in terms of driving, the cars are not, so a bug in a car's software can amplify issues even further. There are issues also how cars will behave when they will have to interact with other self driving cars. Those problems are already difficult when writing distributed applications and with cars we don't have luxury of just letting things crash together until things improve.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> Human programmers are even worse we make 15-50 bugs per 1000 lines of code. Only when that's deemed acceptable. http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff > But how much work the software does is not what makes it remarkable. What makes it remarkable is how well the software works. This software never crashes. It never needs to be re-booted. This software is bug-free. It is perfect, as perfect as human beings have achieved. Consider these stats : the last three versions of the program — each 420,000 lines long-had just one error each. The last 11 versions of this software had a total of 17 errors. Commercial programs of equivalent complexity would have 5,000 errors.
- ars 10y ago> if self driving cars are just a little better than humans You say that so glibly. Have you ever done the math? I did, I posted it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12012166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12012166 Summary: The computer would have to be better than 99.99999% perfect to save any lives.
- Fricken 10y ago94% of fatal accidents are due to human error, and preventable if you remove impairment, inattention, and poor judgement from the equation.
- snowwrestler 10y agoOk but what about the limitations of technology? Yes, self-driving cars will save lives if we assume that the self-driving technology is superior to humans in every way. That's almost a tautology though. Self-driving cars don't get bored, but they don't seem to see white tractor trailers either. Technology has different shortcomings than people do. Whether tech shortcomings result in fewer lives lost than human shortcomings remains to be seen. It's astounding to me that HN stories about self-driving cars sit right next to stories about iPhones and anti-virus software, and tone of the comments are diametrically opposed. If you read the comments on self-driving car stories, you'd think that technology can do everything better than people. If you read the comments on stories about iPhones and anti-virus, you'd think that everything has terrible bugs, vulnerabilities, and shortcomings.
- lkbm 10y ago> but they don't seem to see white tractor trailers either Isn't Tesla using pure vision? Google also uses lidar, which fixes the problem. EDIT: Looks like I'm wrong and Tesla uses radar. > Technology has different shortcomings than people do. Whether tech shortcomings result in fewer lives lost than human shortcomings remains to be seen. Technology also gets better. Ten years ago, people were as bad at driving as they are today. Ten years from now, they'll be as bad as they are today. Now compare self driving cars ten years ago to self driving cars today. And ten years from now. > If you read the comments on self-driving car stories, you'd think that technology can do everything better than people. If you read the comments on stories about iPhones and anti-virus, you'd think that everything has terrible bugs, vulnerabilities, and shortcomings. Those aren't contradictory.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> 94% of fatal accidents are due to human error I assume you just pulled that out of thin air but even if you hadn't, it is completely meaningless. We have nothing to compare human performance against. Humans have been driving for more than a century. What are you going to compare that to? As to how preventable accidents are- sure, if you remove factors like the ones you say, you'll reduce accidents, but humans suffer from those cognitive impairments on top of our extremely well-tuned cognitive apparatus. Computers have nothing of the sort. They may not get distracted, but they're rubbish at doing the thinking that keeps humans safe on the road the vast majority of the time (given that the vast majority of drivers don't get killed in accidents). To put it plainly, if you put a brick on the gas pedal and lock the wheel, you'll reduce the amount of accidents caused by cogntivie impairments like inattention and poor judgement- but you won't reduce the overall rate of accidents. In other words, if you hand control to a system that doesn't sleep on the wheel but can also not tell a puddle from a boulder, you will increase risks rather than reducing them.