13 ms·
NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites
- jMyles 10y agoThe particulars of this content (and the action by The Yes Men) aside for a moment, this is just another illustration that the current shape and function of the internet is highly censorable. This is a fixable technical problem. There needs to be an easy, low-friction way for groups like The Yes Men to publish content such that no single actor can subsequently be pressured to remove it. Whether it's federated web, P2P, blockchain, onion routing, some other tech, or a combination of all of the above, this needs to be an increasing priority so that viable civic discourse can continue and blossom.
- praptak 10y agoThis could also be abused, just as the libel/trademark/copyright laws can. Imagine Microsoft kind of money behind a smear campaign with untraceable funding.
- danudey 10y agoWe don't really have to imagine it. Peter Thiel anonymously used Hulk Hogan as a proxy for his revenge, which makes one wonder exactly how often it happens without us ever knowing. http://www.forbes.com/sites/ryanmac/2016/05/24/this-silicon-valley-billionaire-has-been-secretly-funding-hulk-hogans-lawsuits-against-gawker/#264380fa7805 http://www.forbes.com/sites/ryanmac/2016/05/24/this-silicon-...
- ptaipale 10y agoI believe Hulk Hogan disagrees about that being "used". As far as I understand, they were very much sharing a common cause.
- DasIch 10y agoThis would enable far more than civic discourse most of it undesirable. In many ways it could even hurt civic discourse by enabling harassment, hate speech and worse. In fact everything we know points to exactly that happening.
- tomjen3 10y agoThat is basically what Freenet does. Freenet is also infamous for being mostly child porn, because it is the one place where you can't find the person who uploads it and you can't censor it either.
- dublinben 10y agoChild exploitation content is an unfortunate canary in the coal mine for free speech. If a service or network is robust enough (in terms of censorship resistance and anonymity) for them, then it will be good enough for you too. On the other hand, if whatever platform you are publishing to is free of this objectionable content, then yours isn't safe either.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoI don't agree, and I don't think most people do either. The sane approach we would like is to have an internet where harmful and illegal content like child porn can be censored and the criminals behind it identified and prosecuted, but where legal forms of free speech are strongly protected from censorship. There isn't really a slipperly slope here. Very few forms of content are banned in this way, and the list is unanimously agreed upon and changes extremely infrequently. No one is trying to ban extreme-but-consensual-among-adults porn. No one is trying to ban extreme graphical violence. Etc. etc. The only area where there is a problem, as this case illustrates, is with copyright and trademarks. The correct solution to this problem is to implement more sane copyright laws, internet or not.
- jMyles 10y agoIf it's possible for the arm of the law to reach particular speech, is that speech really free? We need an internet were speech isn't protected because the government blesses it and decides not to censor it. We need an internet where the government is wholly unable to censor it. Then we'll see what actual free speech looks like. ...and the matter of what speech is permissible is far from unanimous. The list of content that various governments deem taboo is enormous and growing. In the USA we have it much better than most places, but even here we have a very robust system of denial-of-service via DMCA and other legal means, including the trademark at issue here. There's little doubt in most people's minds that the kinds of actions that The Yes Men execute are protected by the first amendment, yet here we are.
- neom 10y agoThe CEO of DigitalOcean also tweeted at them: https://twitter.com/benuretsky/status/748508252263059456 https://twitter.com/benuretsky/status/748508252263059456 Seems DO did everything by the book?
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoand this is why you don't use 3rd party services, ladies.
- jjnoakes 10y agoWhen people ask me why I lean toward hosting my content on infrastructure I control (as far as I can), I point then to articles like this. I get that it isn't for everyone - you have to know what you are doing and you have to have the time (at least initially) to do it - but if you can do it, you avoid all manner of third party unreliability. The trend to blindly rely on tens or even hundreds of third parties for stuff like web sites is a direction I'm personally not comfortable with. Just one issue can take everything down. The lower level your dependency (like an ISP vs a hosting company), the harder it is, intentionally or accidentally, to be affected like this.
- codezero 10y agoHow much of the infrastructure can you control though?
- mattbee 10y agoThe UK has a pretty fierce reputation for plaintiff-friendly libel laws, and hosting companies get loads of dodgy complaints. At Bytemark we got sick of them a few years back and spent _thousands_ taking advice from Carter-Ruck, the UK's go-to libel experts. I wrote an old rambling blog post here -> https://blog.bytemark.co.uk/2010/02/07/adventures-in-libel-or-why-i-wont-read-your-forum https://blog.bytemark.co.uk/2010/02/07/adventures-in-libel-o... but in summary, hosting companies aren't as liable for their customers' content as most solicitors would like you to believe! Since 2010 we demand very specific standards for legal complaints (more than a typical "scare letter"), or a court order - and most complainants drop away before actually doing things properly. Typical exchange might be: them: "Huge sections of this site are defamatory to my client! I demand under enormous penalty that you take the whole thing down" us: "We've not read it, do you want to tell us where the defamatory statements are?" them: "It's blazingly obvious, and we'll take you to court if you don't comply" us: "We don't know your client, or their reputation, and we don't read our customers sites, so you'll need to tell us about these defamatory statements in more detail." Very occasionally the solicitors _will_ do the work, and we're on notice at that point, but we then talk to the customer, explain the situation and ask them take down just the statements we've been notified about. The other strategy that works very often is to ask both parties if we can put them and our customer in touch, then let them sort it out. None of this is a free-speech thing, just the climate we found ourselves doing business in. We've always found it perfectly possible to respond to legal complaints across thousands of customers without pulling the plug in a panic.
- jbenz 10y agoI guarantee I never would have heard about this video (which sounds hilarious) if not for this news story. Pretty sure the NRA knows who Barbara Streisand is. There were all upset about her movie, The Long Island Incident. Maybe they are not as familiar with her Effect.
- alexbock 10y agoLet's ignore the topic of the video itself since gun control is quite a controversial issue. If you start producing political videos (and despite being a parody, it's certainly political) that contain libelous "paid for by" messages you are going to have problems regardless of the subject. There's a reason you see these messages in every political ad that airs in America, people take them very seriously. To the anonymous downvoters, note that it is illegal (and not just a civil issue) to falsify this kind of statement in some states. I'm not sure what people are disagreeing with since nobody has left a dissenting comment, so I'll just ask this: if the target here was a parody video encouraging mothers to abort 104-week-old fetuses that claimed to be "paid for by Planned Parenthood" would you have the same opinion? If not I think you're letting your opinion on guns get in the way.
- IvyMike 10y ago> (To the anonymous downvoters, note that it is illegal (and not just a civil issue) to falsify this kind of statement in some states.) Can you say more about this--can you give some example state laws? Note that Google apparently is comfortable leaving the video up on youtube with the "Paid for in part by the NRA" notice intact. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8punyPP-bs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8punyPP-bs
- alexbock 10y agoThe states I've checked all have a law against misrepresenting the origin of a political advertisement that advocates (even indirectly) for/against a candidate or party, and sometimes ballot measures are included too. Some of them are more strict than others, this is from Texas for example: A person commits an offense if, with intent to injure a candidate or influence the result of an election, the person enters into a contract or other agreement to print, publish, or broadcast political advertising that purports to emanate from a source other than its true source. It's hard to say this is a traditional political advertisement. Whether you could convince a judge that an ad purporting to be from the NRA (and presumably making Republicans look bad) is intended to influence an election is questionable. If they had included mention of Hillary or Trump in the video this would be pretty clear cut, but as is it's harder because the link between supporting or attacking candidates through political entities they do or don't support without actually mentioning them by name is a case law issue.
- wmeredith 10y agoIt's bizarre that a complaint about a single site (no matter the merit) can take a network of thousands.
- dandare 10y agoStreisand effect :) (yep I too shared the video on FB)
- AaronFriel 10y agoThis is a fairly awful policy for cloud hosting and VPSes. Microsoft's policy, and I suspect Amazon's and Google's, are to forward legal requests to the company or client using their cloud services and wash their hands of the matter. For DigitalOcean to intervene here seems strange.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoI am not a lawyer... That is partially correct, but the host (DO), still needs to ensure the content was removed. If they pass it on and the account owner ignores it, DO could potentially be liable.
- ultramancool 10y agoYeah, but I'm on DigitalOcean and I got a takedown just the other week for something a user uploaded. I removed it and informed them within the hour and all was good. It's possible they ignored this type of thing or that they just didn't want the mess...
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoThat's how most places handle it in my experience, but it does depend on the scope. I've received some from large companies with big legal teams and then our hosts' legal counsel gets very involved in the process. Given this is the NRA, it might have to do with that, or it could simply be some overzealous staff member.
- intrasight 10y agoIsn't is cheaper, easier and safer (from a "network takedown" perspective) to host your sites on S3? I don't think anyone, not even the NRA, is powerful enough to take down AWS.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoOnly if it's 100% static. Most websites are going to want at least some metrics, maybe a few forms, etc. And I suspect it's not THAT much more difficult to get AWS to do a more targeted takedown. I mean YouTube's pretty powerful, but they'll notoriously cave to a DMCA takedown pretty damn enthusiastically.
- intrasight 10y agoThe article specifically said these were all static sites.
- gcr 10y agoGoogle Analytics works fine and dandy on static sites hosted on S3.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoIn that scenario Amazon would possibly suspend your entire account, or suspend all access to S3 (if you didn't respond). Or even if they only suspend the bucket in question, unless you're splitting apart your customers into their own buckets, the same issue applies where other customers go down because of one customer. I think it's better to work with a smaller company in these kind of instances. Larger companies like Amazon are going to just do whatever it takes to make the complaint go away. They don't want trouble.
- intrasight 10y agoI think just the opposite is true. Amazon has more reputation as risk and will go through proper due process. Small companies probably don't even have that conversation internally.
- desireco42 10y agoThis should not be possible. There should be a law to protect hosting providers. It is not the first time.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoThere is a law protecting hosting providers -- it's the DMCA safe harbor provisions. But in order for those safe harbor provisions to apply, the host needs to take the content down almost immediately or have the account owner do it (grey area on how quickly this really is IMO, but it's usually <24 hours). After the content is taken down, the content owner can file a counter-notice (basically saying the complaint is incorrect). And then if no lawsuit is filed by the complainant in a certain number of days, the content owner can put the content back online. For the record, I'm no fan of the DMCA because it's rampant with abuse and trivial to forge notices. It is too easy to silence speech with the DMCA, at least temporarily, and the repercussions for sending false DMCA notices are a joke. Plus, anyone can send a DMCA, even foreign entities, which makes going after the complainant for damages for false reports not even worth the trouble.
- Karunamon 10y agoTrademark and DMCA are two different issues; per DigitalOcean, this was not a DMCA.
- desireco42 10y agoAs you can see even you got confused. I think hosting providers really need simpler terms of doing business.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoIt doesn't sound like Digital Ocean handled this very well. You are allowed to give ample time to the site owner to disable the offending content. And then the counter-notice process starts to get it back on-line. Only if the site owner ignores the notice should the VPS be turned off entirely.
- tshtf 10y agoIf you have a startup with any user generated-content, keep reports like this in mind when choosing your service provider.
- 20years 10y agoUpdate: Digital Ocean sent a statement. "We received notice on behalf of a trademark holder that a customer of DigitalOcean was hosting infringing content on our network. DigitalOcean immediately notified our customer of the infringement, and the customer was given a five day period to resolve the issue. The infringing content was not removed within the specified period even though several notifications were issued. Per DigitalOcean’s terms of service, a final reminder was issued to our customer and, when no action was taken, access to the content was disabled. The infringing content was subsequently removed by the customer and all services were restored in less than two hours." 5 days seems to be ample amount of time.
- hristov 10y agoThe content is not infringing. There is a fair use exception to trademark law to protect product criticism, works of art, irony, etc. You cannot use trademark law to silence all criticism of your organization.
- Mithaldu 10y agoFair use is a defense. You can preemptively declare it as that, and hope that whoever you're parodying will see the light, but it doesn't give you immunity. Once a DMCA notice is served, and not obviously invalid, the content has to be taken down by the carrier. In exchange for having to do that, the carrier isn't liable. That is safe harbour. Simultaneously the content uploader can either get the supposed owner to retract their notice, or inform the carrier they'll hash it out in court. And only then, in front of a judge, does "fair use" come into play.
- jassinpain 10y agoDon't confuse people with the truth, they don't care. I would also like to point out there are limits on parity which this video appears to push such as "finding a likelihood of confusion."
- hga 10y agoEspecially since helping the "impoverished" become responsible gun owners is something various pro-gun activists do, so while it's very hard to see the staid NRA start such a program, especially right now, it's hardly beyond the realm of possibility.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoJust because someone actually does it seriously, doesn't mean someone else cannot do it as parody.
- scrollaway 10y agoWhat's with the attitude?
- dang 10y agoIf you know more of the truth than others here, you're welcome to share it, but you're not welcome to post snarky putdowns. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12009799 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12009799 and marked it off-topic.
- kstrauser 10y agoIf you're going to host controversial, static content then consider NearlyFreeSpeech.net (https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net). They have a legal team that seems to love shredding takedown notices. For example, this is from their abuse handling document at https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/help/abuse#civil https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/help/abuse#civil: " A NearlyFreeSpeech.NET member site is defaming me or otherwise injuring me civilly, or is infringing my non-copyright intellectual property rights. Please forward a certified copy of your legal finding from a court of competent jurisdiction to our correspondence address. If you have not yet obtained such a finding, a preliminary injunction or court order is typically also sufficient. If you are not able to obtain the above, you will need to work directly with the site operator to resolve your differences. We will have to fall back on our members' contractual assertion that the content they upload is legitimate and therefore we will not be able to get involved." (Not affiliated in any way except as a happy customer. I use them for cheap hosting for some domains I control.)
- electrograv 10y agoIt's important to note this is not just controversial content, it's outright libel claiming false official sponsorship from real organizations. The parody video says: “Paid for in part by the National Rifle Association of America with additional support from Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation." [1] Conversely, I could imagine a parody video created by extreme conservatives mocking Planned Parenthood by happily and cheerfully promoting "baby murder" and "baby parts harvesting for the good of medical science", and quoting the text "This advertisement sponsored and paid for by Planned Parenthood." Independent of your political views, claiming false official sponsorship of a parody is wrong. Slanderous impersonation of a person or organization is not inherently protected by freedom of speech. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8punyPP-bs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8punyPP-bs
- amyjess 10y agoNot only is it defamatory, but in many states it's actually a crime. For example, here's the law in Texas: > A person commits an offense if, with intent to injure a candidate or influence the result of an election, the person enters into a contract or other agreement to print, publish, or broadcast political advertising that purports to emanate from a source other than its true source. Source: http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/Docs/EL/htm/EL.255.htm http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/Docs/EL/htm/EL.255.htm
- forgottenpass 10y agoConsidering something similar happened to surge in January, I'm surprised they haven't worked to mitigate this single point of failure. Whether it's a failover strategy, negotiating a different business relationship with Digital Ocean, or whatever. There is a lot more they could be doing to stay online until they (Surge) are the ones choosing to pull the plug on a user's site (or are ordered by the courts to do so).
- sintaxi 10y agoYou're right. I openly accept this criticism. Steps have already been taken to to get us to the point where a provider is no longer a single point of failure. To be honest this isn't a problem we had anticipated. I expect Surge will be provider agnostic sometime in the close future.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoAll they had to do was not use the NRA name and logo and call it something else like the MRA - 'Murican Rifle Association. Then it would have solely been a parody with no trademark infringement and no legal authority on the part of the real NRA.
- djsumdog 10y agoThat's not really the issue. If anything, that's for a court battle to decide. The issue is that DO took down Surge's entire company, without a DMCA complaint, and with misleading Surge (see the founder's comment). We're not even aware of what type of complaint this was. Cease and desist? That's an angry bullshit letter that holds no legal weight. If DO buckled over something stupid like that, and mislead Surge as to the nature of notice and the window of response; well that's just a shitty provider. I wouldn't use them for anything if that's all true.
- jtuente 10y agoIt's probably more about the NRA not wanting to be associated with the fictitious "Share the Safety" site[0]. [0] - http://www.snopes.com/share-the-safety-nra/ http://www.snopes.com/share-the-safety-nra/
- Steeeve 10y agoIt's irresponsible for a service provider who outsources server management to a cloud company to not know and meet that vendors contractual requirements. They were given notice, they failed to respond to that notice. Then they tried to make it seem like Digital Ocean was the bad guy. If anybody looks bad here, it's Surge. They lost 37,999 websites because they couldn't resolve a problem with 1.
- sintaxi 10y agoPlease know more facts before passing judgement. We told Digital Ocean that we were open on the issue and that we would rather take down the site than risk having all our customers disabled. We asked for one of two things either 1) we be sent a takedown notice from the trademark holder OR 2) Digital Ocean be sent a takedown notice from the trademark holder Digital Ocean took down our customers sites knowing full well that they didn't have to.
- Steeeve 10y agoI appreciate your response, but you have done a disservice to your customer base. If you're going to risk the status of 37,999 websites on principal, you have a duty to notify those site owners of your predicament and of the risk you are placing them in. You could have worked out a firm deadline for resolving this issue ahead of the shutdown. You could have complied, then taken your business elsewhere or come to a meaningful resolution without risking 37,999 sites. When coming to my conclusion, I read your side of the argument and I read Digital Ocean's. You chose not to tell the whole story in order to put Digital Ocean in a bad light. Bad decision after bad decision.
- makecheck 10y agoI don’t care if I agree or disagree with the content, there is simply too much power in mere “complaints” these days. We MUST reach the point where every provider is incapable of knowing exactly what is hosted. In other words: you pay me money for service X, I provide X, and anything outside that simple agreement is out of scope. Concurrently, we can address the likely reasons to want a “takedown” by working on new authenticity technologies: rather than trying to “remove X from the Internet”, make it so that any copy of X can be compared to a signed version. This would train people to scrutinize what they read, much like they sort of know to scrutinize non-padlocked web site forms. For instance, given any snippet of text X, perhaps a browser has a way to determine if that matches any signed statements from the quoted person. And then, if you set up a smear web site claiming that I said X, anyone can use my official signing key to see if I actually published statements that match your text. If what you quote can be verified then the browser could indicate that the information appears to be accurate; otherwise, the browser could warn that the content is unverified. This concept could be extended to other forms of media as well. In order for much of this to work, we need to be able to decentralize all encrypted content so providers can’t even easily guess who hosted something (like the firing squad: not every shooter has a bullet but somehow the deed is done). If the volume of traffic might also be a hint, then winnow and chaff the volume across providers to the point where you can’t even tell how much real content is present. Obviously this anonymity would mean that we can no longer use sledgehammers to kill ants, for some definition of $UNDESIRABLE ants. To me, that is not only fine but downright crucial: put the burden/cost of proof back where it belongs. Or better still, let these people learn to do the digital equivalent of changing the channel: if you don’t like what a web site said then don’t visit that web site!
- pessimizer 10y agoIsn't this the obvious result, if not an actual goal, of centralization?
- kmiroslav 10y agoThe DMCA complaint from the NRA looks legitimate, it's the decision from DigitalOcean to shut down the entire Surge network instead of just taking down the offending content that seems disproportionate.
- the_trapper 10y agoI don't think you quite understand how DigitalOcean works. They provide you with an unmanaged Virtual Private Server (they call them "droplets"), which means that they don't reasonably have the means to go through Surge's "droplet" and remove this content themselves. This left DigitalOcean with two options: leave the droplet up and potentially open themselves up to legal risk from the NRA and potentially Smith & Wesson as well; or turn off the whole droplet and let Surge sort this mess out.
- sintaxi 10y agoWe did not force Digital Oceans had by leaving them with only those two options. a) We told Digital Ocean that if push comes to shove we will remove the domain not resist and risk having all our customers sites taken down. We explicitly stated this. b) We had reason to believe it was still an open issue and being discussed. Including filing a counter claim (at their request). We were fighting for due process, not fighting to prevent the takedown.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- powera 10y agoThis is entirely Surge's fault. Surge buys and resells computing resources. If you're part of a Matryoshka doll of platform providers, your plan has to be to take down content at the first request of your provider and to put it back afterwards. The other option is to have your entire site get banned. Both Google and Amazon have had situations where their entire worldwide properties have been shut down in various countries because of a single piece of content hosted on their platforms that they refused to take down. Surge is expecting special treatment that not even Google and Amazon get by not taking the content down immediately and complaining about a larger shutdown. "Due Process" doesn't come into play at all.
- digitalneal 10y agoExample?
- mindslight 10y agoUnder your theory, every network provider has to shut down for each and every complaint.
- powera 10y agoYes, if you don't want to get shut down, you have to take down content for each and every complaint, even the spurious ones, until you file some type of lawsuit against it. Because otherwise somebody else will do it for you. It's part of being a middle-man, which is exactly what Surge is. There is no "due process" here. It's unreasonable for a service provider to ask for it.
- sintaxi 10y agoWe expect Digital Ocean to not remove content unless they have been given instruction to do so by the rights holder. I don't see that as special treatment.
- anonbanker 10y agoThe document in question is fantastic. I'm a lifetime NRA member living in canada, and I would _love_ to see if there was an increase in violent crimes by homeless people if they were armed. I've been witness to a lot of homeless people in my city being killed (often for sport). Arming the homeless, as Tom Morello advertised, might be in our best interest as a society.
- hga 10y agoI not sure this purported program could include the homeless, for per the infamous Form 4473 (https://www.atf.gov/file/61446/download https://www.atf.gov/file/61446/download has a 2012 version), you've got to supply your "Current Resident Address", which cannot be a P.O. Box. Which doesn't forbid possession, or legal purchase by private sale, just maybe doing it through an FFL as the mechanism necessarily is detailed in the web site.
- splawn 10y agoThey are going to have to take my fake NRA logo from my cold dead hands.
- kyledrake 10y agoHi, I run neocities.org. If you're hosting other people's content, DigitalOcean instances will only get you so far. You really need to be a proper ISP and have control of things like the IP addresses to make sure that these abuse reports go to you directly, and not to your upstream provider that will eventually get sick of dealing with you and shitlist you. We used to use DO for the proxy servers, but learned quickly that this wasn't going to work long term. Throwing CloudFlare in front of it as we see here doesn't solve this problem. Having control over your IP addresses adds a ton of bureaucratic and technical complexity and leaves out a lot of "cloud providers", including most of the big ones like AWS and Google Cloud. I really have no idea how you could run a real ISP on top of these cloud services. Without control over the reporting mechanism, there's no way to automate the process or streamline it. And you'll be at the complete whim of your upstream cloud provider. Only after we started down the path of IP control did Neocities stop having problems with the occasional abuse reports threatening to take down all of our sites. It took a long time to find the right partners to do this with, but we finally did. You can blame the NRA or DigitalOcean or whatever, but honestly at the end of the day, you're going to get a bunch of these from every random organization. Today it's NRA, tomorrow it's MLB because someone is using your web hosting to publish a pirated baseball stream. This isn't exceptional at all - Google probably gets tens of thousands of reports like this a day. The difference is that they control their infrastructure, so they decide whether a site gets blocked or not. As a web hosting provider, that's the position you want to be in. I'm available for consulting for anyone that wants to setup a web hosting platform that can resist problems like this. We also now own an IP block, and are willing to discuss providing some IP addresses for groups like surge.sh or anyone that does web hosting of this nature. I can make sure the abuse reports go directly to you, and if they decide to try to go upstream and piss off the provider, they go through me instead of indifferent abuse guy at a cheap VPS provider that assumes you're running a hacked wordpress blog.
- paulddraper 10y agoA bit off-topic, but that satire was so good it was great. I support the right to bear arms. Other than being childish ("dumb laws") and poorly worded (emphasizing "at risk"), there wasn't much I'd disagree with. I expected satire to have a little more humor.