9 ms·
FAQ from Guccifer 2.0
- guard-of-terra 10y agoWhat's he notable for? This guy's writing reminds me of Bill Cipher uncomfortably.
- tacos 10y agoYup, not buying it. Too cutesy, too impersonal, too obvious. This is a team effort. And not a very good one.
- Kristine1975 10y agoMaybe he used that style on purpose to mislead any adversaries?
- randomname2 10y agoHow does this square with the generally accepted view [1] it was the Russian security services? [1] http://motherboard.vice.com/read/guccifer-20-is-likely-a-russian-government-attempt-to-cover-up-their-own-hack http://motherboard.vice.com/read/guccifer-20-is-likely-a-rus...
- Kristine1975 10y agoThat article seems to be mostly speculation, though. Maybe Guccifer is a Russian, but not affiliated with the Russian government (aka Putin aka Ivan the Terrible). But apparently this is The Cold War 2.0, and whenever Russians may be involved, this means that the Russian government is involved...
- jn1234 10y agoIt would appear that different people wrote different parts of this. The English goes from fluent to almost Google translatese ("inside the network to stay stealth.") in talking about the actual hack. This would suggest that an organization or at least multiple people were involved. https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/748482142968156160 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/74848214296815616...
- chillingeffect 10y agoI would look at the motive. State actors will use the information for economic and security benefit, not broadcast to the world. A guy who wants attention, to be thought of in the same vein as Assange and Snowden, will announce it to the world. Plus, I think if the system was as easy to access (via $1.5k 0day hack purchased online, and was disabled via reboot on June 12th), then I think lots of other people had access, including state actors. I don't think they would announce it to the world, just quietly use the information. Also, I don't think Guccifer wants to influence the election, as he seems to have an impoverished understanding of the facts. I think he just wants to show off. As for a coverup? I don't think it would be as loud or as prolonged as this (Streisand effect). It seems there is even more forthcoming info, too.
- saynsedit 10y ago“Let’s spell this out,” Rid said. “We have a foreign intelligence agency that is picking sides, that is doing a sophisticated hack and influence operation in support of the presumptive nominee of the Republican Party in the US general elections. That’s craziness, if that’s actually the case.” Yeah, having foreign intelligence agencies interfere in sovereign elections does suck.
- 616c 10y agoSome of do not agree with the generally accepted view. https://medium.com/@jeffreycarr/the-dnc-breach-and-the-hijacking-of-common-sense-20e89dacfc2b https://medium.com/@jeffreycarr/the-dnc-breach-and-the-hijac... I have this conversation with people often. They think I am an obnoxious IT guy, but I think we love reaching for convenient answers. Both sides, lone wolf or Russian state sponsorship, I don't seem off. Both extremes are easy win for easily placated minds, so I worry when I feel myself just gravitating to them. That being siad, it saddens me when reputable infosec people (by their own measure) use Medium. Haha.
- jswny 10y agoSeems like this Guccifer 2.0 figure really is just in this for the fame and glory. No real hacker with a different agenda would reveal so much about him/herself (assuming the info is true). It puzzles me. It's almost as if this new Guccifer wants to be caught just like the last one. As if his prosecution by the FBI will finally validate his status as a great hacker, the one who hacked the DNC amid one of the most historic elections in US history.
- rdtsc 10y agoFar fetched speculation, I wonder if FBI specifically instructed those who were hacked to tell the world it is the evil Russians. It played well with their victim's PR story (it is understandably we couldn't resist such a powerful enemy) but it also worked to flush him out with a blog post like this. Say, they suspected he was Romanian or from Moldova (a lot of Moldovans do not like the Russian govt.) so telling the world "this was a Russian super-hacker" was a way to get him angry and force him to try to repair his image so to speak. I think in the end because of of that blog post he might have revealed too much and is at a greater risk of getting caught now than he suspects.
- Exuma 10y agoWho is Guccifer?
- Kristine1975 10y agoRussian source just for fun: https://www.rt.com/usa/347681-guccifer-clinton-dnc-defense/ https://www.rt.com/usa/347681-guccifer-clinton-dnc-defense/ Hacker 'Guccifer 2.0' publishes DNC campaign docs with strategies for defending Clinton The handle is a reference to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guccifer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guccifer
- echelon 10y agoHe's a hacker who perhaps most notably claimed to have hacked into Hillary Clinton's private email server. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guccifer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guccifer
- cdubzzz 10y ago> Opposite to her, Donald Trump has earned his money himself. And at least he is sincere in what he says. His position is straight and clear. This must be satire...
- vec 10y ago"Build a wall across the Mexican border and force the Mexican's to pay for it" is an extremely clear proposal, and it's been repeated often enough that I'm willing to believe that Mr. Trump sincerely believes it's what we should do. That doesn't make it, y'know, actually feasible, or a remotely good idea even if it were.
- cdubzzz 10y agoIs that an actual proposal of his? I would call "force the Mexicans to pay for it" anything but clear, hah. Admittedly I have basically zero knowledge of either presidential bid, the "Donald Trump has earned his money himself" part was what really made me think this must be a joke.
- vec 10y ago> Is that an actual proposal of his? Sadly, yes. https://www.donaldjtrump.com/positions/pay-for-the-wall https://www.donaldjtrump.com/positions/pay-for-the-wall
- Uhhrrr 10y agoThe leverage to be used is to threaten to block remittances from Mexicans in the US back to their families. This makes up a large part of Mexico's economy. It could certainly work. Guccifer 2.0 actually criticizes Trump on immigration in the very next line, though. So it's a pox on both the Clinton and the Trump houses.
- vec 10y agoBlocking remittances is probably impossible. Even if you could shut down all the direct channels for money to flow from US nationals to Mexican nationals, which you can't, it's trivial to either send easily resellable goods like gift cards or to transmit the money to some third party in a neutral country who agrees to forward it on for a small fee. Even if it were possible, blocking remittances is probably illegal under our free trade agreements with Mexico. Any attempt short of pulling out of NAFTA is all but guaranteed to be tied up in courts for years before it could possibly go into effect. And even if it were legal, a huge disruption to trade is all but guaranteed to cost the economy vastly more than the cost of just doing it ourselves (even assuming we actually wanted to). All of which is before you even consider the internal politics of getting the US congress to pass a bill in the first place, or of convincing the Mexican government to roll over and accept a huge insult without requiring anything in return. There is essentially no realistic model under which "it could certainly work". It's a feel-good idea that falls apart with the smallest amount of critical analysis. It's a childish conception of international relations, and any attempt to actually implement it is all but guaranteed to both fail miserably and make absolutely everybody worse off in the process.
- shritesh 10y agoThis Twitter analysis on the FAQ is worth following: https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/748482142968156160 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/74848214296815616...
- Kristine1975 10y agoThat's mostly conjecture. No facts, just observations that might be true or not.
- rdtsc 10y agoAll guessing of course, but disagree with the insinuation it points to Russians still. - Rambo is not just a lame attempt at sprinkling in an American cultural reference. It is exactly what an Easter European boy in his 30s would have been looking up to back in the day. - Other than just Russian security services can find translators. English speaking / translating ability is not a rare, expert-only domain. Could have asked a friend. I guess at the end of the day, nobody likes to be hacked by a random loner guy. It feels more validating to be targeted by KGB's successor. As it explains away the security failures -- "Well these people torture and kill, should be glad we only got hacked by them, could have been a lot worse ...".
- ryanlol 10y agoThis guy is saying some really ridiculous things For example: https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/748524348818989057 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/74852434881898905... No, not every fixed security issue gets a CVE. Not even 1% of them. This is why while auditing a target you'll try to get a copy of the software version they run, and any newer versions to identify patched bugs. https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/748524954845581312 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/74852495484558131... There's really no inconsistency here, "non-public" generally means "not very well audited" Why is it that .ru intelligence is even pegged as a likely candidate here? Literally nothing pointing towards them, you don't have to be an intelligence agency to pop some DNC boxes.
- chasing 10y ago> As for me, I see great differences between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. Hillary seems so much false to me, she got all her money from political activities and lobbying, she is a slave of moguls, she is bought and sold. She never had to work hard and never risked everything she had. Her words don’t meet her actions. And her collision with the DNC turned the primaries into farce. > Opposite to her, Donald Trump has earned his money himself. And at least he is sincere in what he says. His position is straight and clear. So... good hacker. Crappy political commentator.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoWhy do you expect anything else from him than just stating his own opinion? Mine is roughly the same btw, for as much as I care.
- chasing 10y ago> just stating his own opinion Yup. I'm just judging his opinion with my own opinion. Which is that he (and you) are wildly misreading those candidates if that's what you really believe about them.
- smacktoward 10y agoHe's allowed to state his own opinion every bit as much as others are allowed to state their opinions that his is stupid.
- tomp 10y agoJust to clear some facts... Trump inherited lots of money, some people argue that he barely made more than he would investing his inheritance in an index fund. In addition, he frequently changes his opinion and is pretty much the opposite of "straight and clear", except of course for a few themes that he constantly champions ("ban Muslims", "build the wall", and a very underspecified "make American great again"), but e.g. he can't even make up his mind on how much the wall will cost. (Don't take this comment as an endorsment of Hillary, she's most likely a liar and deplorable in so many ways, in addition her positions are very maleable, but make no mistake, Trump is no better. It really is a choice between a disaster and a catastrophe.)
- awinder 10y ago"You asked me several times if I’m a man or a woman. I’m a man. I’ve never met a female hacker of the highest level. Girls, don’t get offended, I love you." Oof.
- tomp 10y agoA more reasonable and useful response would be to point out a counter-example.
- scottlocklin 10y agoCan you point out a counter-example?
- eli 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gigabyte_(virus_writer) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gigabyte_(virus_writer) I don't know what "highest level" means, but I'm not convinced that Guccifer 2.0 is unusually skilled.
- tomp 10y agoThanks!
- mikeyouse 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joanna_Rutkowska https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joanna_Rutkowska
- tomp 10y agoThanks!
- EthanHeilman 10y agoDebating the notion of who is a "hacker of the highest level" would be a silly waste of time and is totally subjective and unquantifiable. Are important or highly talented programmers/engineers hackers (not this again)? Is someone who writes clever exploits but doesn't break into networks a hacker? What about a great social engineer with limited technical skills? Or cryptologists? In some of these categories the better you are the fewer people know you exist? The very fact Juice2.0 brings it up reflects poorly on them (assuming this post isn't just disinformation which it could very well be).
- rdtsc 10y agoBased on what I've read there is a high chance he is from Moldova, and now works for one of the big IT companies. Probably in his mid 30s. Lives in US or Canada. A few things point to it: * He thinks Moldova is part of Romania. That is a contentious issue. He mentioned it specifically. To do so, they'd have to care about it a bit. Doesn't like the Russians it seems, that hints to it as well. * He listed possibilities about how someone could be a hacker not just be part of the Russian FSB -- working for a multi-national IT company. * Age based on what he considers are typical "cool" role models for this age. He listed Rambo and Terminator -- those were the typical boys' role models growing up in the early 90s in Eastern Europe (especially ex-Soviet Union). * Cares and knows about DNC and specific candidates. Guessing they are following the election process, so probably live in US or Canada.
- jontas 10y agoI was struck by his correct usage of "its" and "it's". That is something many native english speakers do not get right. He clearly speaks and writes english very well or has someone editing his posts. That would agree with your suggestion he is living in the US or Canada.
- IshKebab 10y agoThat might be something that foreign speakers find easier to get right because they have to actively learn it, and the words are more different in other languages so they wouldn't confuse the concepts.
- weinzierl 10y agoAbsolutely, but in my opinion it has more to do whether you learn to speak before you know how to spell and write or vice versa. Homonyms or near homonyms like "it's" and "its" or "their", "they're" and "there" are just different things for second-language speakers. For me as a non-native speaker it's a miracle how someone could ever spell "definitely" the wrong way. His writing lacks the typical mistakes Eastern Europeans often make when writing English prose, namely omitting the indefinite article. If you look closely he might be overcompensating, for example: I’ve already said about the software vulnerabilities I'm not a native English speaker myself but isn't the article superfluous here? The next one is more obvious: But I made some conclusions from the Marcel’s story
- Someone1234 10y agoWhile most of what he said strikes me as "likely true" this struck me as being utter nonsense: > The DNC had NGP VAN software installed on their system so I used the 0-day exploit and then deployed my backdoor. The NGP VAN is a service, not a piece of software, and most of the software NGP provide isn't internet accessible. Plus there's also the sticky issue of how he would get ahold of it to fuzz it. On this issue I believe CrowdStrike. He purchased malware on the black market ($1.5K per this FAQ) and then emailed it to tons of people at the DNC until some moron clicked. This FAQ has a few obvious lies like that in it, like his poor English is another obvious lie since they are so inconsistent with it. I think they read about the NGP VAN and then made up the zero day story to make themselves seem more badass. This individual strikes me as your typical script kiddy, in particular considering how much they glorify Guccifer (1) who themselves was a script kiddy. PS - Crowdstrike are still wrong about the Russian intelligence claims, they never had one shred of proof, even after posting their supposed "proof" it was all just generic hacktools and things you can buy on Tor.
- schneidmaster 10y ago> The DNC had NGP VAN software installed on their system so I used the 0-day exploit and then deployed my backdoor. I was the tech director for Bernie 2016, and this part tripped my bullshit meter as well. The VAN is a SaaS, not an on-premise solution. The DNC has some servers that have tight integrations with VAN (e.g. direct db access as opposed to using the API) but saying they had "NGP VAN software installed on their system" is a stretch at best, and those certainly aren't the same servers that the DNC uses to store their oppo research and such. NGP-VAN does run on Azure though, FWIW. I don't know what OS the DNC's servers run on, but it wouldn't shock me if it was Windows as well. If I had to guess, this whole part is a red herring. I'm sure either guccifer social-engineered folks at the DNC and/or the DNC was storing their oppo research on old servers with shitty security. The NGP VAN was an easy name to throw out and divert attention since their own security issues have been well-publicized in the past.
- fapjacks 10y agoThis is totally off-topic, but I tried a few times to get a hold of someone (anyone really) in the campaign to volunteer my technical skills, and every person I talked to was like "Yeah, that sounds awesome! Call this person and say you want to volunteer!" And that other person was just someone in charge of phonebanking and only knew other phonebanking volunteers. It was tedious and impossible to get escalated to someone that might be more useful.
- rrggrr 10y agoThis feels state-sponsored, perhaps a product of Russia. Catching my attention: * Emphasis on disparaging Clinton is interesting as current Admin policy is decidedly (and effectively) counter to Russian interests. * Referring to Intel community using the reverent European bureaucratic term "Special Services". * The boastful lone hacker, but calls himself Guccifer 2.0. Obligatory reference to Lazar midway through the manifesto. * Real political and security drama in the UK and Europe, but focuses on a comparatively boring Clinton campaign, dropping leaks just as a stumbling Trump campaign needs them the most - and all the while Trump, who is largely reviled in Europe, is praised in the FAQ. I'd be amused to learn this was homegrown. I have the increasing sense the Clintons made more than their share of powerful enemies at home as I begin to read the "Crisis of Character" book.
- fapjacks 10y agoI'm surprised at how many people are "trusting the client" here. Analyzing what is being said, as though any of it were the truth. As if the FSB couldn't type all this up just as easily as some thirty year old single guy from Moldova. Not only that, but this is so over the top ("I'm the best hacker ever!!!one") that I'm surprised people are taking it seriously. To me, this really just sounds like someone or some group of people trying to make themselves sound like a hacker, complete with hacker folk heroes like Snowden and Assange.