3 ms·
I have also moved to this view of peer review (my area is quantitative biology). Given the complexity of the papers, the ambiguity of the environment in which
by dekhn 10y ago
I have also moved to this view of peer review (my area is quantitative biology). Given the complexity of the papers, the ambiguity of the environment in which experiments are done, and the inability of most scientists to write up a clear description of their work, and the tendency to pad the significance of a paper's findings, peer reviewers at best act to find "invalidating errors" which should prevent the paper from being published because it's "obviously wrong".