12 ms·
If the concept of Bushido didn't become popular until Japan's modernization (at the end of the 19th century)...how much of Japan's conduct in WW2 (notably, the
by danso 10y ago
If the concept of Bushido didn't become popular until Japan's modernization (at the end of the 19th century)...how much of Japan's conduct in WW2 (notably, the fighting until death) can be attributed/blamed to this misinterpretation of samurai history?
Looking at the Wikipedia entry for Kamikaze [1], I was surprised to read that the concept of suicide attacks only became formalized late in the war (June 1944), rather than something ingrained in the Imperial Japanese fleet from even before the start of conflict.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamikaze#Beginnings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamikaze#Beginnings
OT: I really love the posted article's massively deep footer, which also looks good on mobile. I frequently have trouble designing nice footers around a long list of links and I'm bookmarking this site as a place to copy from.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jbooth 10y agoIf you're talking about Japanese conduct during the war, I'd find the rampant war crimes a lot more notable than the fighting until death.
- bbotond 10y agoCan someone knowledgeable about Japanese culture explain why those war crimes were so common?
- berntb 10y agoWas Japanese war crimes really worse than the European standards in pre modern times? From my Swedish history, see the 30 year war (for a viewpoint not covered well in Swedish schools, google Polish deluge). To me it seems the main difference is that Sweden didn't have the same technological resources a few centuries earlier... Edit: The obvious point is -- does present Swedish culture explain why historical atrocities were so common...?
- coldtea 10y ago>Was Japanese war crimes really worse than the European standards in pre modern times? Or the bombing of 250.000 civilians in Hiroshima and Nagashaki to make a point for the post-war era?
- cheriot 10y ago> to make a point for the post-war era? AFAIK, American WW2 leaders saw it as a choice between invading and dropping nukes. Is there evidence to suggest otherwise?
- Ygg2 10y agoSame can be said of any decision.
- peteretep 10y agoELI5 how the decision making behind letting the Rape of Nanking happen relates to the decision to drop the bomb.
- berntb 10y agoThen please explain the rational calculations for e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanking_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanking_Massacre (This atrocity was part of an invasion, not a total war with an enemy that didn't follow the laws of war.) Edit: The brother comment referenced the same example while I was off for a coffee and to find a wikipedia link. :-)
- awesomepantsm 10y agoI'd guess it has more to do with fascism than the Japanese in particular. See: Nazis.
- barry-cotter 10y agoSure! Japanese people are human and the base morality that evolution has endowed us with. This divides humanity into two groups, in group and out group. Morality only applies to the in group. It takes a lot of acculturation and education to expand an individual's conception of the in group is, from family/tribe to nation/culture to humanity. As such, any sub-culture that can take over the public sphere of a culture will have little difficulty getting people to dehumanise the other, and once they're dehumanised people have little more difficulty committing atrocities than they do slaughtering animals. As you may have noted none of this is specific to Japanese culture. That's because in this respect we're a lot weirder than they are in historical perspective. If you want a good overview of man's violence towards man and it's decline I recommend Better Angels of Our Nature, Stephen Pinker.
- bbotond 10y agoThanks for the explanation. The book looks quite interesting. But that still doesn't explain why the armies of Western nations seemingly committed less and less serious atrocities. Or is that just an illusion because "history is written by the victors"?
- cjslep 10y agoUgly points in the USA's history: Trail of Tears. Slavery. Battle of Blair Mountain. Japanese Internment. Kent State. Jim Crowe. Abu Gahrib. Guantanamo. Drone Strikes. Global Surveillance. History is written, there's just more eye-catchy things to get distracted over. Game of Thrones. Brexit. Reality TV. Concerts. Drugs. Sex. Food. Cars. Video Games.
- daemoncoder 10y agoBeginning to sound like Billy Joel - We Didn't Start The Fire
- lgieron 10y agoAdd colonialism (The Phillipines, Central/South America) and assasinations of a bunch of inconvenient leaders of sovereign states.
- duskwuff 10y agoDiscussed in the article. Read the section titled "FASCISM – NITOBE'S UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCE".
- iwontreddit 10y ago> how much of Japan's conduct in WW2 (notably, the fighting until death) can be attributed/blamed to this misinterpretation of samurai history? Japanese soldiers' "fighting to the death" nonsense was myth invented many years after WW2 by allied "historians" to justify the mass murder of japanese soldiers by the allies. It's not that the japanese weren't willing to surrender. It was that the allies ( unfortunately out of extreme racism ) wouldn't allow japanese soldiers to surrender. If you dig a little past the history/propaganda and look at the raw data/facts/etc of the pacific war, you will learn how brutal the pacific war was. And how racist the allies were towards the japanese soldiers. Nearly every japanese soldier who was wounded was butchers and killed as were nearly all japanese POWs. It was called the "no prisoner policy" of the allied soldiers. And if you want to read about some more base aspects of the pacific war, go read about the mutilation of the japanese soldiers by the allied soldiers. Some real sick shit. The more you learn about the real nature of ww2, you realize that there was no good side in that war. Just two evils fighting each other.
- mathattack 10y agoReally no good side in most wars. Winning wars requires evil in one form or another.
- mercurial 10y agoNo, but while all sides in war end up committing war crimes of one form or another, you definitely have systems in which this is a feature, not a bug. Large-scale massacres of civilians have been a regular staple of the Japanese armed forces during WWII (particularly the Army). And the pattern of abusing civilians of the so-called "co-prosperity sphere" and terrible treatment of POWs was not a case of isolated incidents.
- Apocryphon 10y agoWho was responsible for the mass suicides in the Battle of Okinawa?
- akeruu 10y ago
- ekianjo 10y ago> Looking at the Wikipedia entry for Kamikaze [1], I was surprised to read that the concept of suicide attacks only became formalized late in the war (June 1944), rather than something ingrained in the Imperial Japanese fleet from even before the start of conflict. You don't lose planes for fun.