18 ms·
An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound
- ourmandave 10y ago... because most of our consumers were listening to Morning Edition and All Things Considered in the automobile to and from work. Yet they still occasionally have a story with a siren in the background, so I start checking my mirrors and pulling over.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 10y agoThis is already illegal in the UK, but sadly I think it will take a high profile court case where someone sues the radio station or an advertisement company for causing an accident to enact this kind of change in the US.
- revelation 10y agoAnd the first person to be charged is the driver. If you cause an "accident" because you were listening to radio, you are driving reckless.
- CamperBob2 10y agoHuman factors are a thing. Ask anyone who works in the aviation industry. (Or, for that matter, Jeep.)
- matthewmcg 10y agoJust don't include emergency broadcast system[1] tones in your message[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Alert_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Alert_System [2] https://www.fcc.gov/document/enforcement-advisory-misuse-eas-signals-or-tones-prohibited https://www.fcc.gov/document/enforcement-advisory-misuse-eas...
- Trill-I-Am 10y agohttp://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/01/tbs-facing-hefty-fine-over-adult-swim-ad/457335/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/01/tbs-faci...
- quakeguy 10y agoOne fitting picture.
- mcguire 10y agoPardon me, but... Holy shit, NPR's fascination with sound effects. Yes, I want to listen to 15 fucking seconds of someone chewing loudly between paragraphs. Sirens, crowd noises, people talking about something undoubtedly unrelated in Urdu. Dear god, NPR's signature sounds are why I don't listen to it.
- larrymcp 10y agoThis, times a million! Oh, and the weird music. I'm not sure I need 15 seconds of annoying jazz improvisation at full volume between segments either. But that is indeed part of the "signature sound" :)
- themckman 10y agoThere's a great scene in a Parks and Recreation where Leslie (Amy Poehler) is on the local public radio station and they are about to go to commercial break. Before they do, however, they play part of a song from Nefertiti's Fjord (a "Lesbian Afro-Norwegian Funk Duo"). Leslie comments on how bad it is to which the host agrees but defends the choice with "but, they are lesbians, so..." There's several scenes throughout the show that poke fun of various aspects of NPR that are usually quite funny. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tU4t7COg6W4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tU4t7COg6W4
- shermanyo 10y agoI lost it the first time I saw "jazz + jazz = jazz"
- jff 10y agoThe shows with the constant sound effects also usually have what seems like a relatively new format: they try to make it sound like the hosts (it's always two hosts) are a couple of friends, interested laymen, having a talk at their house about the topic. So they stop to interject ("right?!" "No!"), they talk over each other but only occasionally so as not to annoy the listener, they basically feel like your two friends who've read the same Wikipedia page and are discussing it at a party. And it's during this "conversation" that they play the sound clips: HOST 1: "So there's this interesting thing they've just discovered, Host 2" HOST 2: "What's that?" HOST 1: "Scientists have discovered that when you eat..." chomping and chewing noises HOST 1: "... you're actually oppressing black people." prison cell door slams HOST 2: "What, seriously?"
- danielvf 10y agoYow! The microphone they are using is $3,600 a piece. I guess that's not as bad as it sounds, given a twenty year life and daily use. http://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/U87SetZ http://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/U87SetZ
- batbomb 10y agoThat's not as bad as it sounds because the console, preamps, compressors, etc... all cost a ton of money too.
- _asummers 10y agoEven the headphones themselves are probably at least a grand and they've got way more of those laying around. $3600 is a lot, but audio equipment gets REAL expensive pretty quickly. Edit: Fair enough, I'm entirely incorrect as far as the headphone price point.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoSony's MDR7506 is, or at least used to be a few years ago, the reliable radio workhorse. When you spend all day with your headphones, especially in the field, super expensive cans most people like for music are a liability. I love the 7506s: flat, cheap, and comfortable all day. <$100. NOT the consumer version (-V6 or something). Real, purebred, MDR7506. NegativeK is right, too; the $100 AKG range is also popular in working radio, as well as some Sennheiser HD280s. On the production side of things where quality super matters, you'll see the more expensive headphones for sure. But every single person in the last newsroom I saw rocked the 7506, and though I've moved on to more expensive headphones for programming and my music collection, I still miss my 7506s on occasion.
- nononosisisi 10y agoWhat is a can?
- 10y ago
- jsprogrammer 10y agoIt is curious that NPR contrasts itself with commercial radio, despite the native advertising, regular name drops, and references to listeners as their consumers (does active tuning decrease the availability of the signal for others?).
- mikeweiss 10y agoUmm, because commercial radio is 100% driven by advertisements where as NPR is less than 20% and is very selective about what sponsors it takes on?
- salmon30salmon 10y agoI have often wondered if NPR or public radio in general is motivated to pander to a demographic. By this I mean, consider the leaders of the organization have demographic data on who is most likely to pledge support during their quarterly pledge drives. Would it not make sense to ensure that the sort of stories that this demographic enjoys and (more worryingly) agrees with? This is not to say that its a bad thing, people are paying into a cooperative because they enjoy it, and they should continue to enjoy it. But public radio, though avoiding corporate advertising, still may have to pander, just on a lesser scale and to in a more democratic manner.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoIn the linked article a member of NPR discussed how the flavor of their sound is modified based on NPR's perception of their consumers' behaviors.
- kasey_junk 10y agoThat's not pandering though. Even content targeting isn't pandering. Pandering requires doing something distasteful.
- vertex-four 10y ago
- bramen 10y agoLove the superglue/epoxy trick! As the author said, hilarious. That ultra bassy sound always rubs me the wrong way -- I'm glad to hear someone's been going against the grain. And it's nice that they appreciate the different destinations for their signals, and take steps to prevent them from getting squashed into mush through multiple compression stages. Thoughtful people.
- pistle 10y agoI'd rather they actually mod it so the switch is removed and the circuit hardwired. I imagine someone beating up the "stuck" switch and breaking the circuit/mic altogether.
- bramen 10y agoThat's a good idea. Just bypass it internally and let the switch move freely, doing nothing. They'll learn to leave it alone pretty quickly.
- stavrianos 10y agoHa! Bet they don't. This is exactly how superstitions are made.
- PepeGomez 10y agoI wonder why some people like compression so much. It almost always makes the sound much worse.
- JChase2 10y agoMostly because you can get it louder, and usually louder can trick you into thinking it sounds clearer or "better". Plus there's the history with the whole loudness wars.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoAll broadcast radio is highly compressed. Without it, it would be inaudible in most practical listening conditions (car, walking on the street, in your kitchen cooking).
- robotresearcher 10y agoThere's also a psychoacoustic effect: compressed audio sounds louder, even if at the same objective SPL. Probably because very loud sounds are naturally compressed by the mechanics of the ear system saturating at high SPLs, so artificially compressed signals are recognized as 'loud sounding'.
- jws 10y agoI'm fairly certain he is speaking of data compression in the article, rather than dynamic volume compression. The problem with sending compressed signals is that they will probably be recompressed before making it to someone's ear and the chain of codecs may introduce strange artifacts.
- uxp100 10y agoNo, I don't think so. They specifically talk about adding compression only into their newscast unit. Why would they data compress only one segment? Also, Compression sounds good. Too much, or badly configured compression sounds bad, obviously. But don't throw it all away. (Not that producers are at any risk of doing so.)
- Bromskloss 10y agoSurely, bass roll-off could be done, with greater flexibility, later in the signal path, and applied to any microphone, right?
- gaur 10y agoRolling off before the microphone amplifier means that bass frequencies can't saturate the amplifier as easily.
- Bromskloss 10y agoI get your point, but I thought we had plenty of dynamic range available these days. Judging from the text, they seem to use it rather like an equaliser anyway.
- riprowan 10y agoRegardless of your dynamic range, in order to have maximum S/N you have to run as hot as feasible. So there's no point capturing and amplifying any signal you already know you don't want.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoFixing things closer to the source is usually best.
- radiowave 10y agoBoth the mics in the article have output transformers. It's really easy to saturate a transformer with excess low-frequency sound, so that's part of the reason to have a high-pass filter earlier in the signal path.
- bramen 10y agoYou're right, though sometimes simplicity beats flexibility. It's a lot easier to set it as a standard right at the beginning of the signal chain and frees all the engineers down the line from having to make decisions about it, and ensures consistency in the process.
- pklausler 10y agoNPR's "signature sound", sadly, is being overrun with hideous vocal fries.
- gaur 10y agoIs this a misophonia thing? I really couldn't care less about vocal fry.
- sukilot 10y agoIt is a prejudice against people who sound a certain way, especially women.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoIt's a preference, not prejudice. Prejudice would be if you see a person and assume they speak a certain way based on other characteristics like age, race, gender, or appearance. But if you actually hear them speak and don't like their voice, that's not prejudice.
- tptacek 10y agoWhen you describe the natural sound of someone's voice as if it were pathological or the product of incompetent mic/broadcast technique, you're moving past "preference" and into something darker.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoMaybe, but the style in question is cultivated. I don't think it's prejudice if you don't like the way Coltrane plays the sax. I feel the same way if you don't like some person's intentional vocal affectations.
- tptacek 10y agoIt's the notion that "vocal fry" is an "intentional vocal affectation" that generates so much professional scorn for listeners who complain about "vocal fry". http://val-systems.blogspot.com/2011/12/on-vocal-fry.html http://val-systems.blogspot.com/2011/12/on-vocal-fry.html
- baldfat 10y agoAS a former audio engineer THIS is so important for clear vocals. > We are fans of being close-miked, and P-pops come into play there. But we make sure that we are within a foot of the microphone and usually a lot closer — close to six inches — in working with any of our on-air talent. That’s another element that goes into it.
- pepijndevos 10y ago> The NPR sound has so many tentacles. If we’re just focusing on the studio side, which was actually the easiest thing. They didn't go into any of the other things.
- keane 10y agoFrom an earlier submission (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2546087 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2546087) another factor that gives NPR programs a different feel than your average live radio interview is a large amount of careful editing, described by On the Media’s John Soloman: http://nprfreshair.tumblr.com/post/5449544068/lk-on-the-medias-john-soloman-explains-how http://nprfreshair.tumblr.com/post/5449544068/lk-on-the-medi...
- dredmorbius 10y agoAs NPR falls increasingly under the spell of "it must be live" -- even the hourly news summaries now start with "Live, from NPR News in Washington", rather than the former "From NPR News in Washington", a gratuitous change that grates -- the segments are far more frequently not edited. Among the problems this presents is what I call "the chase", which are the final 30 seconds or so of an interview in which the host or interviewer is quite clearly trying to wrap up with a guest, who either isn't aware of, or doesn't want, to meet that time schedule. It is always awkward, and occurs at the end of EVERY live interview. (The BBC also exhibits this, the worse when it's over some long-distance line.) A pre-recorded, edited interview can go for full feel and length, and then be cut to fit the timeslot. One thing I recall (and miss) from those was a far more gracious interview wrap. I'm sure that far less of what had been said hit the air, but what there was was better for it.
- drivers99 10y agoIt was really awkward when an official in the UK was trying to give some condolences about Orlando and the NPR host had to cut them off in the middle of their statement.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt's always fucking awkward. My anticipatory cringe starts about 2 minutes into any interview.
- billforsternz 10y agoIt always puzzles me when experienced media pros don't recognise that they are going to be shut down abruptly by an approaching hour boundary. Sometimes this happens every week on a regularly scheduled gig! Surely it can't be that difficult to wear a watch and keep it accurate.
- cJ0th 10y ago> Another thing for engineers or anybody at a station to do is to go into the studio, turn the microphone on, crank it to 11. Don’t talk — so you don’t blow your ears out — and listen to the sounds of all the fans that you have in the room. This is one challenge that we’ve had for decades here. You’re never going to get it to zero. You’re never going to get it completely silent. Nor do you really want to, because in order to get it silent you’ve got to move a lot of equipment out, and there’s a lot of cost with that. Makes me wonder why they don't record the sound of the fans and then invert that audio track and mix it with the mic channel before broadcasting the master channel so that the relatively periodic noise of the fan cancels itself out.
- meowface 10y agoTools like iZotope RX can do a pretty great job at removing that kind of noise.
- doctorshady 10y agoTrue, but a lot of the tools within RX are meant to be very manual labor-intensive, very CPU intensive, and not particularly realtime. At the end of the day, the cleaner the source material, the easier it is to process in any fashion you want later on in the airchain. A lot of stations will have noise gates on their microphones, or even wideband gating before material hits the transmitter in some cases. With the right settings, it should be more than plenty.
- dharma1 10y agoI think audio fingerprinting for noise reduction can be automated but it will not real-time of course
- dri_ft 10y agoBecause it's not really periodic enough. I don't think any natural sound source short of a musical instrument (and even for them, it's doubtful) is so perfectly periodic that an out of phase version would stay in opposition (i.e. in the inverted/opposite phase of the cycle) for long enough for this to be of any use. But there are (FFT-based?) noise removal tools that can work for this sort of thing. edit: also, the weird phasing artefacts this would introduce would be much more prominent and noticeable, even if it succeeded in reducing the overall volume. So much so that doing basically this ('flanging') is a standard musical effect for making parts sound psychedelic.
- dredmorbius 10y agoTL;DR: It's all about that bass roll-off. Studio construction, baffling, and noise exclusion also matter. What I didn't see addressed were some other factors I've noticed and/or been aware of over the years. NPR's announcers, reporters, and hosts tend to speak conversationally. Rather than shooting for fill-the-room, highly-inflected (a/k/a Commercial Broadcast) voice, it's the tone you'd expect to hear from someone having a conversation with you in a room (though perhaps a larger room, and with less mumbling). That's a huge difference for me, and unfortunatly I'm hearing far more commercial broadcast inflection from the recent crop of announcers, to the point it's quite annoying. Steve Inskeep most particularly. ("Recent", for this old fart, means the past decade or so.) The other element, and it's one I'm raging against, is that NPR has increasingly moved to live and unedited audio, to its tremendous loss. When the network was small and it couldn't field reporters in many locations, sound often arrived after hours, or days, at headquarters where it was edited for broadcast. Even the flagship news programs were largely (and in cases entirely) pre-produced, with all news segments, interviews, etc., edited before they went on the air. Yes, it meant that what you got from NPR was often slightly stale relative to other news outlets, for the latest breaking news (though hourly headlines broadcasts were generally current). But the result was polished and digested. In terms of a program which informed rather than merely screamed, it was, I'd argue, a better product. NPR has been falling victim to currency bias since the late 1990s and I really don't care for it.
- AstroJetson 10y agoYou made two key points. One is that the NPR voices sound like they are next to me in the car. There is good, thoughtful discussion and presentation. And as an NPR supporter I really appreciate that. They know they have my (some) of my attention in the car, they are not trying to wrest my focus from the Honda about to cut me off. The low key nature works. I listen to NPR to get the slightly stale event that someone has taken the time to gather more than one fact and is trying to make a 1 min segment out of it. I can't recall a time where an NPR story got walked back (looking at you FOX) for shoddy reporting. Posts above have whined about how much NPR talent make. You should find out about your local morning zoo team and the Ken and Barbie team on your Action news. Those guys don't even get out of bed for 300K a year. Plus the people listed above also write and edit their material, vs Ken & Barbie. At a variety of levels, NPR and their shows are worth every penny. In a few weeks listen to them talk about the RNC / DNC conventions vs the others.
- Ericson2314 10y agoThis is a really good interview, in that the interviewer has knowledge comparable to the interviewee. Obviously that can't be achieved for when a single interviewer interviews people with widely ranging skills (e.g. many radio shows themselves) but is nice to have with something niche like this. On a different note, why is that (as far as non-expert me knows) that nice mics often have eq settings? Is this not a blatant layer violation?
- k0ngo 10y ago> On a different note, why is that (as far as non-expert me knows) that nice mics often have eq settings? Is this not a blatant layer violation? The low-frequency/subsonic content that this switch will remove often consists of wind noise, pops from talking too close, vibrations from the floor/mic stand, etc. Even if these low frequency noises may be more or less inaudible, they'll contribute to a large signal swing that will decrease the headroom in the following amplifiers. In other words, you won't be able to turn up the gain in the microphone amplifier/mixer as much as you'd want, because the low-frequency but high-amplitude content will make the amplifier clip and distort the sound. Filtering the signal after the mic preamp won't solve the problem, because the preamp (which can provide in the order of 60 dB gain) will be the component that clips. By including a low-cut filter in the head amplifier circuit inside the microphone (the amplifier serves only as a buffer, and usually with unity gain), the disturbing low-frequency noises can be removed before entering the high-gain microphone preamp. You can find the low-cut switch next to the capsule in the U87 schematic [0]. It seems to me that they increase the capsule bias voltage, thus changing the low frequency response by electrostatically tensioning the membrane. [0] http://recordinghacks.com/images/mic_extras/neumann/U87-schematic.png http://recordinghacks.com/images/mic_extras/neumann/U87-sche... edit: tweaked some things. meta: i'm not very good at commit messages.
- tacos 10y agoFor a vocal/voiceover mic loud sounds are not a concern. (The U87 has a pad switch for those cases separate from the proximity/EQ switch.) The things you mention (vibrations, LF rumble) are typically handled by the highpass on the mic preamp and are in the 75 or 80Hz range. In musical terms, that's 4+ octaves below the 1k proximity rolloff on the mic itself.
- Severian 10y agoThe flat sound really emphasises the sibilants, and for me, excessive "mouth noise". I hear a lot of nose whistle and saliva sounds. Maybe I suffer from some misophonia, but it drives me crazy sometimes.
- tacos 10y agoThat's due to the person being close to the mic. A flat microphone, by definition, emphasizes nothing. Moreover it's other aspects of the signal chain (compression, distortion, broadcast filters) that accentuate sibilance.
- riprowan 10y agoI couldn't agree more. I think that's actually the U87s you're hearing. They are very neutral, quite sensitive condenser mics - very unforgiving, not "flattering" just "realistic." Dynamic mics like most stations use (SM7, RE20) hide a lot of sibilance by exaggerating the fundamentals.
- zargay01 10y ago250Hz, not 250kHz
- riprowan 10y ago> We use a simple Neumann U87 microphone as the house-standard microphone at all of our facilities. They’re expensive, but that’s what we’ve used for years. That simple U87 costs about 5x what the other broadcasters use (typically an SM7 or RE20) and is much more fragile and difficult to maintain. As I recall NPR bought hundreds of U87s...
- lucb1e 10y agoI don't know NPR but from reading about half the article, it seems to be a radio station in America that flipped a switch on their microphones. Am I missing some insight, or is that all?
- mikejanssen 10y agoI'm Current's editor, and loving the traffic spike we're getting from this... thanks everyone! Serious follow-up question for you -- are there other public media/technology articles you'd be interested in reading that we should pursue? We don't cover tech exclusively, but this post has proven to be hugely popular (not just here but on reddit twice). Would be great to hear your thoughts.
- retrogradeorbit 10y agoAnyone know what polar pattern they have the u87s on? Cardioid?