3 ms·
An interesting simile here is that software rots in the same way that Encyclopedias do. (This is admittedly a fitting simile partly because the simile itself i
by WorldMaker 10y ago
An interesting simile here is that software rots in the same way that Encyclopedias do.
(This is admittedly a fitting simile partly because the simile itself is being rotted by software like Wikipedia.)
In the world where new Encyclopedias (and Almanacs and Recipe Books) were printed and sold on an annual basis, the question was often why do we need "this year's Encyclopedia" when the old one is still perfectly valid. Books in general decay pretty slowly and have a long shelf life, but the facts and the views in the world inside them are frozen and possibly. Changes from year to year of an Encyclopedia are somewhat hard to notice, but in Middle School in the 90s I recall having to compare articles from a tobacco yellowed Encyclopedia set from the 70s to trips to the same articles from very early predecessors of Wikipedia. The worlds contained in those two sorts of Encyclopedias were very interestingly diverging. The yellowed Encyclopedia's facts were almost all still valid and "worked", but there were things that didn't hold up and lots of new facts that needed to be inserted in various places. If I were to edit an Encyclopedia, I'm not sure I would start from the version in that yellowed Encyclopedia if I could find a more recent set. Some of the predecessors to Wikipedia were direct descendants of that yellowed Encyclopedia and yet for various reasons historical and technical, Wikipedia itself did not inherit directly from that set in any meaningful way.
(It's interesting to note too that the physical media of software to date has a much shorter shelf life than the pulp medium of books, tobacco-smoke-filled library aging included, so argument exists that software rots worse than Encyclopedias physically, at least.)
- joe_the_user 10y agoIt's a nice analogy but there are important differences here. The thing is that the process of encyclopedias roting/going-out-of-date is obvious because we understand that an encyclopedia is a collection of assertions about the world. It is not as obvious that software is also a set of assertions about the world - and it's not as easy to determine which assertions about the world the software depends on. Just as much, an encyclopedia is a static list of supposed facts and its change is somewhat predictable by in terms of how our understanding of the world changes. We have some idea what will be valid or invalid in an encyclopedia X years old. Software depends on obscure facts about OSes, about networks, about UI expectations, about time, and so-forth and moreover, software involves chains of dependencies so it's harder to predict what would or wouldn't break software X years old.
- WorldMaker 10y agoThanks Joe. I think the difference you point out only strengthen analogy, and which I tried to colorfully explore in the original post, but expand here because it is interesting. «It is not as obvious that software is also a set of assertions about the world - and it's not as easy to determine which assertions about the world the software depends on.» I like that definition: "Software is a set of assertions about the world". It may be less obvious than an Encyclopedia, but again, perhaps that only makes it a better analogy. «An encyclopedia is a static list of supposed facts and its change is somewhat predictable by in terms of how our understanding of the world changes.» Ah. This is where Wikipedia actually strengthens the analogy. An Encyclopedia has always been loosely hyperlinked with cross-references. Entire complex webs of assumptions and assertions about the state of the world. Refactors of Encyclopedia content always could have interesting complex relationships with other content. Certainly there is an extent to which Encyclopedias are known to predictably change: new elected officials each cycle, for example. But there is still plenty of unpredictable changes: new red letter days in history, new evolutionary scientific shifts in consensus, new lenses in which a culture views itself. An example of the lattermost, in that yellowed 70s Encyclopedia you could still spot fragments in the process of being excised of what we now consider to be racist views of culture and cultural history. That among other things was a source of fascination to this teen in the 90s. The often unspoken truth is that as much as Encyclopedias try very hard to be objective, they are still a product of their culture. (So too do we often want to think that Software is objective and nothing but mathematical assertions about facts about our world, but here too they are products of our [corporate] cultures and moored in ways both obvious and not obvious to the culture that built them.) Wikipedia shows us that complexity of Encyclopedias much more directly, but those bones were always there in Encyclopedias even when we couldn't see them. A link to click is much faster than shuffling between volumes of an encyclopedia to follow cross-references, but the cross-references have always been necessary to build up a view of the assertions about the world. More interestingly, Wikipedia strives to give a better, more transparent view, into the cultural biases of its contents; all of the [citation needed] tags and "More Research Required" templates and Talk pages of endless discussion. The novelty here is that they've opened up all of that to the common user, but the essence of that has always been in Encyclopedias, just locked away by the librarians and researchers in their own notes.