7 ms·
Firstly, I don't think you can dismiss the racism/bigotry of a candidate like that. When even some of his supporters are calling him out for racism, it is hard
by slg 10y ago
Firstly, I don't think you can dismiss the racism/bigotry of a candidate like that. When even some of his supporters are calling him out for racism, it is hard to argue that it isn't an aspect of his platform. I personally feel that should be enough to eliminate him from holding an office like the presidency regardless of his legitimate ideologies.
The objective truth is that globalization and labor arbitrage overall produce value. That is why we are seeing markets around the world react negatively to the UK's decision. Global economies will work less efficiently in a world in which the UK is not part of the EU.
However as a society we are doing a bad job of distributing the increased value that comes from globalization. Int is true that the way we are distributing the value is leaving the people you are talking about worse even off than before. That is the problem and it will only get worse as other countries continue to develop and more jobs are taken over by automation. The way to solve the problem is not to roll back progress and retreat back into isolationism. That would leave society as a whole worse off. The answer is to continue to encourage progress but increase redistribution efforts to help the people who are left behind.
It is simple math really. Imagine a scenario before globalization where person X has $10 and person Y has $30. Now after globalization person X has $5 and person Y has $40. Person X would clearly be angry about this development but that doesn't mean the solution is to revert everything to how it was before globalization. The answer is to take somewhere between $5 and $10 from person Y and give it to person X. That way everyone is better off than before and we all benefit from progress.
- api 10y agoI wasn't defending Trump, just explaining why he has so much support. > The answer is to continue to encourage progress but increase redistribution efforts to help the people who are left behind. This is the Bernie Sanders answer to the same question. For Sanders to get as close as he did to nomination would have been as utterly unthinkable even 4-8 years ago as Trump's nomination would have been. Sanders rode the same wave, offering a left-wing reaction to the decline of the American interior vs. Trump's right-wing reaction. While I personally can't stand Trump, I'm actually a bit concerned that if he loses to Clinton we'll be facing a real full-blown gloves-off fascist in 4-8 years. The kind of systematic decline I described in my OP is historically the precondition of fascism. I have a friend who's been predicting this for years, calling this "Weimar America."
- slg 10y agoI agree that what is behind a lot of Trump support and Sanders support are the same motivating factors. The biggest difference is that Trump joins it with bigotry and anti-immigration rhetoric while Sanders joins it with the rhetoric of class warfare. Both focus on harnessing the anger we talked about, but I think one of them is clearly more dangerous than the other. It is also worth noting that the plan I mentioned isn't one Sanders supports. He agrees with the social safety net aspects, but he still wants to halt progress on globalization and trade. He might be even more isolationist in that regard than Trump. Sadly there was no candidate in the presidential race that joined both the support for globalization with an understanding that increased social programs are a requirement in a new and more globalized economy.
- MichaelGG 10y ago>racism/bigotry >bigotry and anti-immigration I hear this a lot. I've then gone back and listened to the exact words he's said. I think it's a very hard case for people to say there's anything he has said that's actually racist. Mexico isn't a race, and even if it were, he's simply correctly pointed out that illegal immigrants are not the best people the country has. Trump hasn't said anything anti-immigration. Only anti-illegal immigration. Much of it is focused on Mexico, and opponents yell about how terrible this is. Yet Mexico is hypocritical. I'm in Guatemala, and friends that have simply had a layover in Mexico require a visa and go through harassment. On top of that, I've been threatened deportation from the US during a border crossing (I'm Canadian). My wife lived as an illegal immigrant in the US (visa overstay while we tried to adjust status). My daughter was indirectly killed due to us having to leave the US and return to a bad country with junk healthcare. Despite that, I realise mass migration won't help. Hint: Most of Latam has it not-so-good. Probably a majority would jump at the chance to get US residency. But how is that a solution? Not to mention the current status quo mostly benefits Mexico. Guatemalans face a hard time just getting through Mexico - Mexico has harsh immigration against them and won't hesitate to deport. Trump's opponents refuse to address this. Instead they just scream racist/bigot/immigrant-hater, while waving Mexican flags. More and more people are realising these are empty insults and non-sequiturs.