7 ms·
I think this should be a wake up call for those of us who are American. Populist movements that rely heavily on anger, fear, and anti-immigration rhetoric can
by slg 10y ago
I think this should be a wake up call for those of us who are American. Populist movements that rely heavily on anger, fear, and anti-immigration rhetoric can still be effective in western democracies even if a large majority of experts think it shouldn't and won't happen. This is the first time I have legitimately thought we might end up with a Trump presidency.
- thirdsun 10y agoMy thoughts as well - it's surprising (well, maybe not) to see how effective these populist movements are these days whether it's France (Front National), Germany (AfD), Britain (UKIP), Czech, Poland, etc. To me it seems that Switzerland is the only country where its population can be trusted with plebiscitary measures, referendums and other forms of rather direct democracy.
- kele 10y agoAnd yet Switzerland is much less immigration friendly than all the countries you've mentioned.
- thirdsun 10y agoI didn't mean specific issues like immigration, but the general ability of the people to understand and comprehend complex issues and problems and vote accordingly - even if I disagree. Meanwhile it seems everywhere else whoever shouts the loudest, promises the most fantastic things or tells the most fear mongering tales gets ahead. Just my impression of course.
- faebi 10y agoAnd yet switzerland has one of the highest percentages of immigrants. Switzerland has a foreigners share of ~24%. Except Luxembourg every other EU nation has less immigrants than switzerland. As an example, Great Britain has only ~8%.
- kele 10y agoThe percentage of immigrants living in a country is a result of a long term process. I believe that what we are discussing right now is the 'refugee' crisis.
- herbst 10y agoThats not true. It just does not mix emotions with politics so much and so the decisions made sometimes sound really harsh, when in reality they often aren't. Disclaimer: I am a EU foreigner in Switzerland.
- kele 10y agoJust to be clear, I'm not saying that Switzerland is unfriendly. I'm saying that it's less friendly than the countries mentioned in the comment. That's because I believe they are too friendly. Last time I was in Zurich, this is the first thing I've seen at the railway station [1]. This is a very reasonable thing to do for Swiss people and something very different to what is happening in EU during the "refugee" crisis. On the other hand, in the EU it would be considered anti-immigrant or even racist (especially by media). [1] http://s1.ibtimes.com/sites/www.ibtimes.com/files/styles/lg/public/2016/02/28/512187838-people-walk-february-25-2016-zurich-gettyimages.jpg http://s1.ibtimes.com/sites/www.ibtimes.com/files/styles/lg/...
- misja111 10y agoThis is because in Switzerland there have always been referendums. That really makes a difference on how people see their laws and regulations. In Switzerland, people say 'We have decided to have law X or regulation Y'. In Germany people say 'They have decided', meaning the government. This growing distance between the people and the government is a fertile breeding ground for populists. And the distance is the biggest between the people and the government of the EU.
- mk89 10y agoBut this doesn't prevent ridiculous referendums, like the one about immigration. It shifts the responsibility to the people, true but who cares about who does what? We must care about the results - the society we live in. It's all about media. I will always blame the media for being extremely biased in whatever they do. I cannot mention today one objective and inquiring media. They ALL report what people already know or what they want to know. Democracy without objective media is oligarchy.
- misja111 10y agoI'm not sure which 'ridiculous' referendum you mean. There have been two referendums in Switzerland during the recent years about evicting immigrants who have been convicted for heavy crimes. The first one was approved, the second more harsh one was rejected by the voters. But why call a referendum ridiculous? I guess it is primarily because you don't agree with the proposal that the referendum is about. And because you don't agree with the proposal, you feel that there should not even be a referendum about it? That means that you think your opinion is more valuable than a possible majority of the voters. Isn't that an egocentric point of view?
- mk89 10y agoExactly the one about expulsion of foreigner who are criminals. According to Wikipedia: "Foreigners who commit a crime would be automatically expelled from the country, regardless of the severity of the crime." [0] I don't know the laws in Switzerland, but I can tell you that in Germany if they catch you without the train ticket for three times, you can potentially go to jail. In Switzerland, if such a law existed (I don't know), such a person would be expelled. This is ridiculous to me, because in a life span anything can happen. If you commit rape, homicide, break-ins, I can understand. It's the "regardless" that makes me wonder how welcome foreigners are. Although "ridiculous" might be the wrong term, I think that such a referendum should not even exist. Why was it even thought about? Why the "regardless"? What's wrong with us humans? Foreigners come, make your country richer - especially foreigners, PHD, master students, and highly skilled employees - and that's how you pay them back? Treating them like if they were worse than animals? "If you fuck up, go away". I don't doubt the effectiveness of referendums, although I come from a country in which they hardly have an impact. I really appreciate Switzerland's method, as it keeps its citizens closer and more interested to politics. However, I am still of the idea that news can corrupt democracy pretty much everywhere, no matter how it's implemented - as long as citizens are the main responsible for the elected people or laws. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_referendums,_2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_referendums,_2016
- CM30 10y agoIt's not that surprising. Recent developments (like globalisation) have been really bad for the working class, and a growing level in inequality and rising housing prices and what not means that populist movements and their 'simple' answers to complex problems are becoming more attractive. And the media too. By attacking people for their views, they basically gave these populist movements ammunition and caused their supporters (and much of the public) to see a divide between an elite and the working man. Things will probably get far worse in the future because of all this...
- Mikushi 10y agoWorse for who? I don't necessarily agree with far right arguments, but as far as I'm concerned nothing indicates that rejecting globalisation will leave us in a worst future. Globalisation has destroyed the planet along with the capitalism and values it touts as the future. All lies and deceit that contributed to the ever enrichment of the elite while we're left here saying again and again that the working man is stupid for reacting to it. As said, I don't agree with the rhetoric of the far right, but one thing I have been entirely certain for many years, left or right, it doesn't matter, neither hold the future for us.
- CM30 10y agoNot worse in the 'people are economically worse off' sense. Worse in the 'I worry that someday a psychotic lunatic will be voted in as prime minister/president/whatever' and lead to another massive war sense. I worry the politician voted in as a protest against elites and globalisation is going to be someone merely using that as a cover for a far worse ideology.
- angry-hacker 10y agoWhy did you only list right wing populist movements? Plenty of extreme left wing movements share the burden for being in this mess we are right now here in EU.
- thirdsun 10y agoFair enough. However those right wing movements often seem to be the ones that gain significant traction.
- rospaya 10y ago> To me it seems that Switzerland is the only country where its population can be trusted with plebiscitary measures, referendums and other forms of rather direct democracy. Is it? At one point they blocked one type of a building from being built. Not to mention this clusterfuck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_immigration_referendum,_February_2014#Consequences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_immigration_referendum,_...
- MichaelGG 10y agoI think it's bizarre that a wakeup call is needed. From the moment I saw Trump talk the first time, I thought "wow, he's going to blast things to bits". A lot of folks think the USG doesn't accomplish things, that politicians are full of nonsense, that the media/news is junk. Simply that Trump is an outsider that's basically an independent should be enough for people to see he's going to win big. The fact that enough people think this way (I've had people say your comment to me in person, but not nearly as nicely) just shows how far out of touch things are. Instead of just yelling bigot/racist/etc., I think Trump's opposition needs to actually listen and see what people are really seeing in him. Otherwise they're in for a big surprise. (FWIW I'd never have considered a US right or nominally conservative before.)
- peyton 10y agoI think you're right. I'm a lifelong Democrat, but having grown up in Texas, the anti-Trump rhetoric is cringy in its disingenuity. Part of winning an election is getting people to show up at the polls, so maybe the Trump opposition rhetoric is aimed at turnout rather than conversion of his supporters.
- agumonkey 10y agoPartly true but short sighted. Winning an election isn't just cutaneous reaction. What will he do that can fix things for everybody .. Not saying that his opponents did good or will do better.
- scruple 10y ago> Instead of just yelling bigot/racist/etc. For what it's worth, I've been a registered Democrat my entire adult life. I don't see that happening, at least not large-scale, I think that much has been made clear. I don't think that many people realize that, to many Trump supporters and swing voters, they are essentially proving his point for him. They'll have no one to blame but themselves if he wins.
- MichaelGG 10y ago
- pmorici 10y agoIt's a byproduct of the shaky economic prospects of the working class resulting from the 2008 crash. Anyone who finds the rising populist and nationalist sentiment surprising shoud go read some history for pointers on what happens next.
- humanrebar 10y ago> I think this should be a wake up call for those of us who are American. I'm confused. U.S. politics over the last decade have been dominated by populist pushes on all sides of all aisles: Tea Party, Occupy, Trump, Sanders, even Obama ran on 'change' had minimal 'insider' credentials when he was elected. > Populist movements that rely heavily on anger, fear, and anti-immigration rhetoric Substitute 'anti-immigration' with 'anti-someone' and you basically have the case for most reform these days. The reaction to the Orlando shooting has basically been this, right? Anger? Check. Fear? Check? Pick an enemy? You have three or four to choose from: Muslims, gun nuts, homophobes. I think we need to be more self-reflective and (socially) self-policing than tutting at all the other people out there.
- Chris2048 10y ago> Populist movements that rely heavily on anger, fear, and anti-immigration rhetoric The "experts" were wrong about the probability of a Brexit, maybe they're also wrong about the motivations too?
- ohthehugemanate 10y agoFrom a German resident: Facepalm. We had this whole World War thing, which is endlessly replayed in TV and movies from your country. How did you miss the moral of the whole story? Germany was one of the wealthiest industrialized nations. It was a top education destination worldwide, with some of the best universities in the world. The lesson of National Socialism is "if it could happen here, it can happen ANYWHERE". I don't think that trump is a Hitler. But the emotions and rhetoric that he uses is extremely dangerous stuff. And your media just eats it up. You guys arent just playing with fire; you're playing with TNT.