5 ms·
But you assume that people in the UK have an alternative to those German cars. They don't. Germany makes better cars than anyone else. Brits will still buy t
by sandworm101 10y ago
But you assume that people in the UK have an alternative to those German cars. They don't. Germany makes better cars than anyone else. Brits will still buy them, they will just now be more expensive.
Two words: British Leyland
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11966471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11966471 and marked it off-topic.
- marcoperaza 10y agoThat's not how pricing works. Higher pricing for German cars will lower sales substantially in favor of cheaper cars. Even if someone still buys a German car, they will probably choose less expensive options. There's no way that the continent starts a trade war with the UK. Neither Hillary nor Trump agree with Obama's "back of the queue" comment. So no matter who wins in November in the US, they will almost certainly be very eager to make a good trade deal with the UK. Australia and New Zealand will too. Hopefully, this will result in a reinvigorated Anglosphere.
- sandworm101 10y agoPerhaps in a perfectly fair and free economy ... such as in a collective group of countries that all trade freely with each other. That may now be over. Britain still needs cars and, unable to produce them locally, may well tolerate the higher prices.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoAlso consider BMW/Mercedes/VW-Audi as political influences in Germany - they are going to do anything they can to keep their products flowing, and prices down.
- beninvalencia 10y agoI think Sandworm's comment is not really sensible. Most people surely buy on some price to quality benchmark, i.e. value. If German cars are suddenly x% more expensive, well that will have a big impact. Not to mention US/Japanese/French cars being perfectly decent!
- rodgerd 10y ago> Australia and New Zealand will too Good for Australia and New Zealand. But the ANZAC future stopped being British when they surrendered Singapore. > Hopefully, this will result in a reinvigorated Anglosphere. Why hopefully?
- marcoperaza 10y agoBecause these are countries that share some really great values like a belief in human freedom, democracy, and free markets. We share a taste for competitive capitalism and individual initiative. Our foreign policy goals are very aligned. It would be the most powerful and rich bloc in the history of the world. Why wouldn't it be a good thing?
- rodgerd 10y ago> Because these are countries that share some really great values like a belief in human freedom The head of state of the UK is an unelected monarch. The upper house is life peers and Anglican clergy. What kind of "belief in freedom and democracy" is that? > We share a taste for competitive capitalism and individual initiative. You... don't actually know anything about the political history of most of the world's English speaking countries, do you?
- marcoperaza 10y agoYes, they keep the Queen around for the tourists. The monarch wields zero actual power in British politics. Sure, the House of Lords is unelected, but it's only still around because it works so well that no one has convinced the House of Commons of a better alternative. Also, they can only delay legislation, not stop it all together. Is that really the best you've got against the Brits? And what about their history? I know full well that the UK, for example, has dabbled quite heavily in socialism. They're also one of the most resilient people on the planet, up there with the Jews, and they came back from that with a vengeance.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoI think Japan would disagree.
- sandworm101 10y agoJapan, Germany, Italy ... I think we can all agree they make better cars than anything produced by a British manufacturer in recent decades. US cars are strange. I often find the European versions of US models to be miles better than those produced for the US market. So it's hard to decide what exactly is an American car.
- arethuza 10y agoPlenty cars are manufactured in the UK - what we seemed to be useless at was running car companies, not making cars!
- addicted 10y agoAnd a lot of those manufacturers are gonna move those manufacturing out of the UK if they have to pay a 10% tariff to serve the 10 times larger EU market. Most British car companies are owned by foreigners anyways, and if anything, this was a vote against non-British than a vote against the EU.
- arethuza 10y ago"this was a vote against non-British" Unfortunately that was my impression of the main motive behind this Brexit vote - xenophobia.
- ageofwant 10y agoI only buy cars from the Axis, and so should you.
- TAForObvReasons 10y agoJust want to point out the same is true of european cars. The entry-level Mercedes-Benz cars in the US market are miles better than those generally available in the European markets.
- linuxkerneldev 10y ago> Germany makes better cars than anyone else Sure. Like those excellent Volkswagon diesel vehicles that are vastly more efficient than their Japanese competitors. Edit: I thought my sarcasm would be clear. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal
- dingo_bat 10y agoYou do know that the cars were polluting more because they are more efficient? Right?
- CDRdude 10y agoI'm confused; how does that work?
- imtringued 10y agohigh performance, fuel efficiency, low NO2 emissions pick two. (this is controlled by software which means they can sell the same engine that differs in performance and fuel consumption)
- enraged_camel 10y agoI took it as sarcasm...
- dingo_bat 10y agoIt's not. It has something to do with the catalytic converter needing some amount of unburnt fuel to work properly. But the Volkswagen engines are so efficient that they burn the fuel too efficiently. So the catalytic converter is unable to perform it's function.
- benjohnson 10y agoWith current technology diesel engines have to run less efficiently to ensure more deisrable gases being produced.
- labrador 10y agoThis is the stupidest comment I've ever seen on HN. Really? Britain will beg to reverse this decision because they need German cars?
- reillyse 10y agoI don't think thats the point being made. Just that this will probably make German cars more expensive, but Britain doesn't make any good cars of their own and so they don't have a ton of other options.
- BurningFrog 10y agoThey have MEGATONS of other options. Both Japan and the US has enormous car manufacturing industries, as do many other non German countries.
- reillyse 10y agosure and they'll all have to negotiate a separate trade deal with the UK, we all know how simple those are to get done.
- BurningFrog 10y agoBritain is a free trading nation. That's one of the reasons they want out. No "trade deals" are needed for free trade.
- reillyse 10y agoTrade deals are needed for all trade, free or otherwise. Having free trade between two countries requires a trade deal.
- BurningFrog 10y agoFree trade only requires that the government doesn't stop goods in customs.