3 ms·
To be frank the EU was built on power centralization and socialism as key principles. It's been what, 15 years+ since the Eurozone and the Economy is still doin
by ekianjo 10y ago
To be frank the EU was built on power centralization and socialism as key principles. It's been what, 15 years+ since the Eurozone and the Economy is still doing as bad as before, if not worse for most member states. Hardly a success model by ANY measure.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoHow does anyone expect growth in a developed country? You can't free market your way out of it without sacrificing your social obligations and protections. What is success? High YOY GDP growth? Or quality of life? Look to America (my country) with very limited worker protections, almost no social safety nets, extremely high income and wealthy inequality; we still only eek out only ~2% GDP growth, and that's on the backs of the poor.
- ekianjo 10y agoThere are many measures of success, and if you want to talk about quality of life, by all means look at how bad the discontentment with the EU has been growing over the years, among all member states. Keeping everyone in the EU is not sustainable.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoShow me a model you'd replicate. I will argue that Britain was the model I'd replicate. Was.
- ekianjo 10y agoI'm not playing politics, but in my take any movement that distances you from a remote central power is positive in the end. Freedom should have been the basis for the EU, not Socialism. We all know where it's headed now.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIs the supposed freedom worth it if your country's economy suffers? I'm not asking for political reasons either, I'm talking purely economical. Freedom has a cost, and it seems that the UK populace who voted to leave does not fully understand that cost.
- ekianjo 10y agoFreedom is an investment. Of course the UK will be worse in short run, and I'm sure EU members will poit fingers and say "we told you so!". But in the long run they will be better off than the rest of Europe, where structural changes have proven impossible. Such decisions take dozens of years to give fruit.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWhat metric would you use to measure if the UK was more successful out of the EU then in? I'm looking for an objective metric that can be measured.
- ekianjo 10y agoGDP's not perfect, but that should hint at a number of things. Look also at Organic Inflation, and Debt Ratio. Unless the UK governments to come take much worse decisions than the EU bureaucrats, it should not be too difficult to do better.
- mhuffman 10y agoMedian wages up, economic inequality down, investments in social stability programs (retirement, healthcare, education) up. In the US, those are all going the opposite directions.
- mhuffman 10y agoYour economy can boom with all the citizens suffering. For example, if average wages go down, and the rich get richer, the overall economy grows, but is of little consequence to most people. When countries grow powerful, they begin to forget about the "socio" part of socioeconomics, and just look at dollars.
- Zikes 10y agoIf you replicated Britain it'd just vote itself out again. Clearly a very, very large portion of the country felt underserved by the model.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBritain is not the first country to be led into darkness by fear.
- ekianjo 10y agoFunny how such decisions always assume Fear and never Englightment.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI have yet to see any data that the Brexit is a net positive for the economical wellbeing of the British people. That is not what I'd define as "Enlightened".
- enraged_camel 10y agoNo one has any data one way or the other, and will not for at least ten years. The UK entered uncharted territory. Your guess regarding what the future holds is about as good as anyone's, including those of the experts.
- anon4this1 10y agoPeople are sick of biased crap and vague economic theory being touted as data telling them how good immigration and free trade is for them, while in their own lives only seeing things getting worse. Nassim taleb sums it up well: http://reason.com/blog/2016/03/15/nassim-taleb-the-global-rebellion-agains http://reason.com/blog/2016/03/15/nassim-taleb-the-global-re...
- dropit_sphere 10y agoThere's more to wellbeing than (relatively) short-term economic wellbeing.
- kkk661 10y agoNigger
- xiaoma 10y agoIf by "developed", the implication is "done making technological progress" then yes, economic progress will be very slow.
- baddox 10y ago> What is success? How about measuring by success by the preferences of the people in the country? Apparently a majority of UK voters preferred leaving.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBecause emotions aren't an objective measure of quality of life? Yeah! Success! We're out of the EU! Will they still be thrilled when trade dwindles and their social safety nets are cut? You can educate someone. You can't fix willful ignorance. > Gotta hand it to stupid people. They may not understand nuance, secondary effects, or the long term, but dammit, they know how to vote. https://twitter.com/rolldiggity/status/746195269390196736 https://twitter.com/rolldiggity/status/746195269390196736
- baddox 10y agoIsn't "objective quality of life" a semantic contradiction? Whose lives are you talking about, and who is a better judge of a person's quality of life than that very person?
- imtringued 10y agoIn that case WW2 was a fantastical success...
- tremon 10y ago"in the country"?
- WillPostForFood 10y agoYou can't free market your way out of it I'd argue you might be able to have a generous social safety net if you adopted a high tax, low regulation approach. EU is high tax high regulation, US is medium tax medium regulation.
- lossolo 10y agoE? Do you know what welfare does UK has? They are good with their socialism. It's not why they are leaving. And EU is much more than money, look at history of EU and look in which part of the history there was no wars in EU.
- ekianjo 10y ago> which part of the history there was no wars in EU. In case you have a short memory, before the EU there was the League of Nations between WW1 and WW2, to ensure wars would never happen again in Europe (and elsewhere). It did not work out too well. The fact that we did not get any war in Europe after WW2 has really nothing to do with the EU being there or not. If anything, war did not break out because we were too busy preventing the Cold War from exploding in Europe and having Russia invade or coup every other country, like they did in the whole Eastern part of Europe.
- lossolo 10y agoThey worked "preventing wars through collective security and disarmament and settling international disputes through negotiation and arbitration" which do not work look at UN and how many wars we still have. Democratic governments, rule of law and the most important: same values and connected markets and economies, euro zone - this is what prevented wars not some League of Nations with their dead agreements. Cold War ended what is keeping them busy from war now ?
- ekianjo 10y ago> same values and connected markets and economies, euro zone Same values, I beg to differ. The values of a Greek and of a German could be completely different as far as you know. Connected Markets? The EU has become a tariff-heavy zone, the opposite of a Free Market - look at how many trade agreements we have to regulate and impeach free markets. And the TPP, with the blessing of most EU members (in secret). There's no recipe to avoid war, but political stability is certainly correlated with economic prosperity. The EU is not making this happen, so we should see it slowly desintegrate.
- panic 10y agoThe worldwide economy isn't doing very well; it's not just the EU. Is there any evidence that leaving the EU will help this situation? I think there are a lot of people who agree with you, but this whole thing seems too poorly planned and justified to really understand the impact. People are voting based on how they feel instead of what will actually have the best outcome.
- ekianjo 10y agoWell there's ample evidence that the EU is not doing any better than the rest of the world, and certainly worse that many developing countries and even worse than non-EU developed nations. There's litterally no data to support that the EU was a good thing on an economic point of view.
- NetTechM 10y agoVery true, unfortunately, pooling money between a few economically well developed countries and quite a few economically bunk countries does not work well for those whose money was actually worth something in the first place.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoAre talking about the pound? Because it doesn't appear like its worth much now. https://twitter.com/DavidInglesTV/status/746192676085600256 https://twitter.com/DavidInglesTV/status/746192676085600256 > This is something we've never seen, chances are you'll never see again Pound just collapses 13% vs. the Yen #Brexit https://twitter.com/MatthewPhillips/status/746189646841978880 https://twitter.com/MatthewPhillips/status/74618964684197888... > Wow. The £ is down 8.4%. Currencies are not supposed to do that. (1% move is considered massive.)
- NetTechM 10y agoCompared to just prior to joining the EU, the pound is down nearly 100%, since they were at about 2.50 USD the year they joined and that was prior to massive inflation. I think the bigger picture is eluding some people in the face of shiny doomsday articles.
- alex_young 10y agoI'm sure Germany agrees. The EU has been just terrible for member economies.
- NetTechM 10y agoThe European Union was a resounding success for Germany, the Deutsche Mark was terrible in comparison and their economy saw a huge lift.
- 1w9813w91981291 10y agoWith Germany you always have to take the re-unification into account. The D-Mark wasn't bad before 1989 and the lift of the economy may as well being the East doing better rather than Euro effects.
- ohthehugemanate 10y agoI'm sorry to directly contradict you, but that's just factually untrue. The EU was built on an explicit policy of focus on small treaties, and avoiding creating transnational institutions. This was specifically to ensure that member states kept as much sovereignty as possible. It's why even the largest EU institutions are generally incomplete and only operate with the ongoing cooperation of all the member states. Hence monetary union without fiscal union. Hence the lack of police and military cooperation. Hence no central border or immigration control. These are key functions of government, which the EU has never been able to centralize because of the practice of "small steps." Its the way the US was supposed to work, only with even less power in the federal government. European federalism is free trade attached to a foreign policy body and a supranational court. The EU is more than 50 years old, not 15. it was established as a free trade zone first, to "make war unthinkable and materially impossible" - in 1958. That's the core of the EU, and it works very well for the members by every material measure. I don't know what makes you think otherwise. The recession has created a growing movement of Euroskepticism, but that's associated with the extreme political right wing, and remains a minority - outside of Britain, it seems.
- ghzghz2 10y agosocialism?!! It is probably the only institution or country to have the free movement of capital and services written into its constitution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_market