4 ms·
I find it a bit sad that so much tech has been put into advertising, which, as an industry is inefficient and a costly zero sum game.
by chii 10y ago
I find it a bit sad that so much tech has been put into advertising, which, as an industry is inefficient and a costly zero sum game.
- function_seven 10y agoAgreed, but consider it an analog of war technology. Much of it finds its way to more civilized uses. In this case, what we have here is a great tool for vehicular motion capture that can be used in gaming and simulators as well. Ads may have been the motivation to begin with, but other uses can reap the benefits as well.
- arijun 10y agoWell, maybe not entirely zero sum--if the advertisement lets you know about something you'd want but previously didn't know about, that's a net plus. Then again, those diet pill ads and other scams are a net minus, so maybe it washes out to 0 net.
- chii 10y ago> if the advertisement lets you know about something you'd want but previously didn't know about, that's a net plus i count those things not as adverts, but as information sources. An advert is something that tries to convince you to buy _their_ brand of a thing, rather than informing you of the existance of a thing you didnt know about. Suppose there's a universal catalog which lists all possible products/services, then you'd have no need of the former, but the latter is still a zero sum game.
- kerryfalk 10y agoI don't really grasp your analogy but your definition of advertising is not complete. Advertising does indeed include messages to increase product/brand awareness. It could be argued that in most advertising, this is actually the case.
- chii 10y ago> product/brand awareness this is the distinction i'd like to make - branding advertising is the zero sum game i was talking about above. Product awareness is simply information - using an advert to tell me about a thing that i didnt know is not really advertising to me, but showing me that a certian music player is so much better, because it makes me hip and cool , _is_ advertising of the zero sum kind. If i were to buy a music player, i want information, specs, and i'll choose based on objective comparisons. I don't want to, or need to take branding into account, and neither should anyone else! It's illogical!
- manigandham 10y ago> I don't want to, or need to take branding into account, and neither should anyone else! It's illogical! And yet you do, even if you think you don't. There are hundreds of billions of dollars spent on branding because it works, it's human behavior to have preferences and emotions and tapping into that as a business is the opposite of illogical.
- arijun 10y agoIt's a bit tautological to say "If you remove all but x, then it's comprised entirely of x." I don't think most people would agree with your definition of ads, either. The first iphone ads were probably showing a lot of people something they didn't know existed, but you'd be hard pressed to find someone who called the "iphone information services" instead of ads. Even in the realm of what you might consider to be zero sum ads, that might not always be the case. "Oh this car has 4 wheel drive? That's something I could actually use." Boom, added utility.
- kerryfalk 10y agoReducing the cost of getting your message to the market without changing your customer acquisition rate is by definition not a zero sum game.
- robbrown451 10y agoI think they are saying advertising itself is the zero sum game....not this particular modification to it. (and I don't agree advertising is a zero sum game, I think it is a very, very small number sum game :) )
- tomcam 10y agoHow is advertising zero sum?
- chii 10y agothe amount you pay to stay on top is directly proportional to the amount your competitors pay to get you off the top.
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago"The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads." --Jeffrey Hammerbacher
- manigandham 10y agoThese are the same sentiments echoed by people who think we should stop spending on space development so we can focus on world hunger instead. That's not how it works. Technology benefits everyone regardless of where it originates. Advertising is also a massive industry and economic driver that has led to the commercialization of the internet and many of the content, services and companies you perhaps take for granted today. It's also by no means zero-sum as connecting products/services to customers is necessary to actually build all these other non-advertising businesses. For all the hate that advertising gets, the reality is that it's a critical component for any company's success.