4 ms·
Something I hadn't considered was the breakdown between the individual UK nations. What happens if the UK as a whole decides to leave the euro zone, perhaps by
by MBCook 10y ago
Something I hadn't considered was the breakdown between the individual UK nations.
What happens if the UK as a whole decides to leave the euro zone, perhaps by a small margin or perhaps by a lot, but for some reason Scotland decides buy a 15% margin to stay in the euro zone.
Is there any reason to think we might see Scotland decide to stay with the euro zone it leave the UK in that case? Or are the ties so strong that the UK would probably stay together no matter what even if one of the member nations has a strongly different opinion?
- tellarin 10y agoI'm on my phone now, so I can't find a link. But yes, some politicians in Scotland have already said they'd have another referendum to leave the UK if it leaves the EU. I wonder what will happen in Northern Ireland. My understanding is that it will be split in half in terms of voting leave/remain.
- kspaans 10y agoThe SNP has essentially already promised to hold IndyRef2 if that's the case.
- matthewmacleod 10y ago(Just a heads-up, the Eurozone and the EU are different – the former is the currency union under the Euro, and membership of the latter is what the referendum is about. Not all members of the EU are members of the Eurozone). Scotland had an independence referendum less than two years ago, where the outcome was a good 45%-55% in favour of remaining in the UK. However, the majority of representatives in Scotland remain pro-Scottish independence. Continued membership of the EU was an important argument during the independence campaign – with the pro-independence side wanting to remain, and the pro-UK side warning that Scotland would lose EU membership if it voted for independence. It's likely – but not certain – that there would be a second independence referendum in Scotland on the basis of being 'forced' to exit the EU. But it's not going to be pretty, and there have been a lot of elections in Scotland recently – no doubt everyone is getting a bit fatigued. It's not clear at all what the outcome would be, either, or if Scotland would even be able to maintain EU membership.
- MBCook 10y agoThanks, thought I might be getting the "euro zone" part wrong but wasn't sure. Honestly I was surprised when this whole issue came up because I assumed that the EU and the Eurozone where the same thing. I know the UK never decided to adopt the Euro so I just assumed that they weren't part of the EU.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoIt's not hard to get confused – there are a lot of overlapping groups involved here! The Eurozone, the EU, the ECHR, the EEA… they all have different sets of members and such. The UK has been a bit frosty about the prospect of further EU integration, possibly with good reason in some ways.
- jballanc 10y agoAh! This is where I get to pull out one of my all time favorite Wikipedia graphics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Supranational_European_Bodies-en.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Supranational_European_Bo... ...ya know, just in case you weren't confused enough already!
- eru 10y agoThis would be better, if it didn't rely on me knowing all the flags.
- toyg 10y agoSNP did not really campaign, despite having been resolutely pro-EU all the time in the past. They clearly hope Leave wins so they can get a mandate to break away for good; they'll have another referendum, which will be easily won, and say bye.
- notahacker 10y agoScotland will definitely try to leave (as others have pointed out, there's a definite theory that turnout there was lower because a lot of pro-independence Scots who support the EU in principle didn't particularly mind the rest of the UK leaving the EU if it reignited their opportunity for independence) The other interesting aspect is London: a part of the UK whose expected resounding Remain vote[1] is far from the only way it's increasingly politically, culturally and economically different from the rest of the UK... [1]Lambeth just voted 78%/21% for remain...
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoIt's an impossibility, but London independence would probably do an awful lot of good for the UK.
- eru 10y agoLondon as a city state would be pretty amazing. They can put the English parliament into Winchester, with some historical justification.