8 ms·
College Unaffordable Even in Higher Income Brackets
- squozzer 10y agoSolutions -- 1) Wait for the bubble to pop and see if prices reach a new equilibrium. 2) Double-down on current solutions, i.e. more subsidies. 3) Impose a head tax on everyone a la Obamacare.
- wyager 10y ago4) Stop having the government pay the exorbitant cost of state schools and making inappropriately large loans available to students.
- nofinator 10y agoObamacare doesn't have a head tax. It has a mandate and a tax penalty, and the penalty is proportional to income with a ceiling.
- squozzer 10y agoOK, so I over-simplified the process a little. You have to pay someone who is not the government. To merely exist sets the criterion for the mandate. The penalty is not flat rate, but has a floor. SCOTUS ruled in upholding ACA that Congress has a constitutional right under Article I to levy taxes.
- bmmayer1 10y agoDon't more subsidies put upward pressure on prices?[1][2][3] Also, how would a head tax improve the cost of education? [1]http://college.usatoday.com/2015/08/20/report-federal-aid-rising-tuition/ http://college.usatoday.com/2015/08/20/report-federal-aid-ri... [2]https://fee.org/articles/student-loan-subsidies-cause-almost-all-of-the-increase-in-tuition/ https://fee.org/articles/student-loan-subsidies-cause-almost... [3]http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2015/09/08/student_loans_drive_up_college_costs_what_should_we_do_about_it.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2015/09/08/student_loans...
- squozzer 10y agoYes they do. I didn't say the solutions would actually WORK. But this is America, so we'll deal with this problem the way we've dealt with health care.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoMy partner and I - both well-educated and well-employed professionals - sketched out our long-term financial plan recently. The only way we envisioned owning property would be to build our own a considerable distance away from our small city's center. That alone proved to be a significant part of our budget, which is already under considerable pressure from student loans and car payments. We estimated the expenses for future children and the picture was not pretty. Then we factored in higher education, assuming costs rise at the same rate as the last 30 years - roughly our lifetimes - and concluded that by the time our future kids are at college age, they will likely be paying for most of it themselves, with debt they may hold their entire lives. So we aren't having any. EDIT: Just to be clear, I am not simply saying that I am forgoing children because their college costs would be too high, I'm saying EVERYTHING is too expensive, and college in 20-30 years, assuming current rates, will be forbiddingly so.
- atarian 10y agoWhy not send your future kids to community college and then have them transfer?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoIf I understand this strategy, you send them to community college for the first two years, where they take their general ed requirements. Then they transfer to a "real" (expensive) college for the last two years, for the deeper/more specialized courses. It's not a bad strategy (we may do it with one of our children). But if higher cost is the problem, this solves less than half of it. Half because they still go to an expensive college for two years. Less than half, because the two years at a community college aren't free, either.
- TwiztidK 10y agoCommunity College is cheap, really cheap. I took CC classes during the summer while I was in school, working an internship at the same time, to knock out some of my humanities classes. In total, it cost me around $1500 to take 15 credit hours of classes there (compared to $7k + fees for the same at my college). But, you're right, it does solve a little less than half the cost. Which is awesome! If you wanted to go to a nice restaurant and could buy a Groupon that would let you get $100 of food for $55, that would be a great deal, despite it not being free.
- dougmany 10y agoWell with Over 675,049 California ballots remain uncounted. Bernie could still win the state. http://vote.sos.ca.gov/unprocessed-ballots-status/ http://vote.sos.ca.gov/unprocessed-ballots-status/
- civilian 10y agoYou remind me of myself in 2008. #RonPaul2008
- jamesroseman 10y agoI think a reality that will hopefully soon catch up with societal stigma in the United States is that college isn't right for everyone. I understand this as a separate point from college being unattainably expensive, but it is an important point. I have friends who would be mechanics, Peace Corps volunteers, electricians, or plumbers if they hadn't instead gone to a private 4-year institution, pressured to attend the best schools possible because they did well in high school. The permanent solution for this is either adjusted student loans or free community colleges, or some combination of the two. People on the opposite side of this issue I've talked to have often expressed concern that the bachelor's degree will basically become devalued if everyone has access. My response is always "it already IS devalued, but hardly anyone has access". It's near impossible to get a job in a desirable field without a college degree and relevant experience, but it's also prohibitively expensive to get a degree. Where will the 22 year olds with $100,000 worth of debt working at McDonald's going to be in 30-50 years? I have friends who in their early 20s are recognizing it's worth accruing more debt at even higher education in hopes of getting a job that will make the investment worth it. > Unless we make college affordable for people of all financial means, opportunity through higher education will be a false promise. But this is half of it, right? Plenty of people who walk out of colleges with no debt still can't find a job because the market is changing so much. As today's jobs move towards automation, I think most here can agree that current careers will change forever (frequently on HN the conversation steers towards more technological jobs). What I don't frequently see posted here is that automation will free up creative jobs where going to college is a necessary path. Writers exposed to other young writers can become inspired for life, especially given the opportunities. This turned into sort of a soapbox and is mostly anecdotal, but I think most would agree a national conversation needs to be had about this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- peterkshultz 10y agoA big proponent of the type of things you're talking about is Mike Rowe. He created a foundation "that rewards people with a passion to get trained for skilled jobs that actually exist": http://profoundlydisconnected.com/foundation/ http://profoundlydisconnected.com/foundation/
- sotojuan 10y agoIn my experience the middle and higher income brackets (middle and upper middle suburban class) is the bracket that is hurt the most by college costs. Too rich for substantial need-based financial aid, too poor to pay without big loans. The only answer is merit scholarships, but those can't go for everyone, so you end up with moms taking their kids to 1000 summer activities so they're competitive :-) Here's a possible solution also from personal experience: I went to high school in Texas and about 70% of the top students went to University of Texas at Austin because a) very good school (top 10 in CS) b) at least at the time, you got in automatically by being in the top 8% of your class, which isn't that hard in huge Texas schools c) not cheap but not $40k a year. Most parents realized this was a likely outcome for the kids early on (or pretty much expected them to go there) and started to save up money since their child was born. The result was the most unstressful college application process I've seen! Of course, not everyone lives in a state where the flagship public college is a top 10 in CS and many other majors, nor can everyone save up 18 years before the kid goes to college, but some can make it happen.
- tinduck 10y agoIt hurts on all levels of the income spectrum, from lower to upper middle class. It's real bad in Tennessee where our flagship public school is 389.9 miles away from what was our biggest city in Memphis. I am shifting in the opinion that we need to start funneling more money in to our public urban commuter schools. Wayne State, University of Memphis, Towson University, University of Cincinnati, etc... Honestly, The amount of public money that goes to private universities in this country is disgusting. Also the effects of Economic Agglomeration are well known.
- grimberg 10y agoI had a similar situation less a local top-10 local university. I could go locally and walk out debt-free (actually ended up about $10k positive) or go to a better university (Illinois or Georgia Tech) and walk out with ~100k in debt. A bunch of very sharp people of modest means stayed local. Those that didn't had parents taking second mortgages to help pay. Suffice to say, I went local and things worked out in the end. I calculated that now, with a top job, I would have broken even in about two years. The only open question is if it will impact my future career prospects.
- cheald 10y agoAnd yet, college enrollment continues to trend upward. The price continues to climb, but it's clearly not unaffordable yet. http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d15/tables/dt15_302.60.asp?current=yes http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d15/tables/dt15_302.60.as...
- nine_k 10y agoIt's financed by debt. That is, it's probably already unaffordable because the debts are going to be crippling, but it's not felt yet. It's like you're already severely poisoned but are not yet feeling the effects, and more people around see you and consider the poison for themselves.
- kmkemp 10y agoAgreed. It doesn't make any sense to conclude that a good isn't overpriced when (1) the government has created ways to subsidize its cost (2) created a means by which it can be paid for with debt (3) as a society, kids have been brainwashed to believe that college is the only path to prosperity The OP assertion only holds up in a free market.
- cheald 10y agoSounds like the solution might be to ease back on guaranteed student loans and tighten up available credit so it goes to qualified borrowers who are likely to be able to pay back what they borrow, rather than mandating that everyone who wants to goes to college without any consideration for ability to repay what they've borrowed. But then, that would result in decreasing enrollment rates and hysterics in the headlines about how kids can't afford education, and we can't have that. We've worked ourselves into a corner - by subsidizing education so heavily in pursuit of increased attendance rates, we've driven prices sky-high, and now can't cut those subsidies without hanging some people out to dry. We'll know that college is truly unaffordable - or at least the college premium reaches the point where it's not worth the cost - when enrollment rates start trending downwards. Until then, it's a giant ball of subsidies and relief programs and reforms and restructurings that work to maintain a system that is empirically affordable, even if it's extremely painful.
- nine_k 10y agoCollege may become unaffordable, but education should not. With price pressure like this, I suspect online and other forms of post-high-school education will become more and more valuable. Employers will start looking at them with more attention, and definitely certificates of passing serious exams will become (more) valuable. Of course, these exams certificates are not going to be free, and even the online courses are not going to be free. But they are going (and currently are) massively less expensive than a college, while possibly giving comparable levels of knowledge. (Also, the "buy new books" racket will hopefully be gone with online courses + relatively independent exams.)
- niftich 10y agoCollege/University has not solely been about education in a long time. It's about signalling [1][2], and therefore it's a competitive advantage. The accessibility of signalling is inversely proportional to its value -- it's no longer exclusive. This happens with certifications too. [1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/1882010 https://www.jstor.org/stable/1882010 [2] http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/04/bryan_caplan_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/04/bryan_caplan_on.htm...
- nine_k 10y agoAs signalling becomes too costly, it can become separated from skill certification. Much like a diploma from Yale now is not a signal of exceptionally good knowledge but a signal of financial ability and having the right connections, going to any full-time university can become such a signal.
- getgoingnow 10y agoI dropped out of college (computer science) few months ago. Ahhh, the sense of freedom and gaining my sanity back. I don't even know why I enrolled; plus I hated teachers and most students. When I was there, I rarely attended lectures and instead watched them online, read books and did practical things on my own - so it didn't even make sense to be enrolled. At least I won't be a debt slave.
- dingbat 10y agointeresting article but was it necessary for the authors photograph to be as large as the entire text itself?
- Shivetya 10y agoCollege at its current cost is too expensive for America, period. It has gone up faster than inflation. I still think any college accepting money backed by the federal government should be required to offer courses for a set amount per credit hour. People seem to have no issue with government dictating how much medical procedures and supplies cost, why not college.
- Glyptodon 10y agoI'd have guessed most families sending kids to college were making upwards of $100K anyway. The headline felt a little misleading because I thought it was already taken for granted that it was hard to afford for most sub-$90k households, particular if they have multiple kids.
- sadface 10y agoI'd be interested in seeing how a "single payer" approach to college financing would work. High level - The government pours many billions of dollars into colleges and universities every year, but because the money is disseminated via millions of individual loans to individual students, any buying power (and downward pressure on prices) that the government could provide is effectively eliminated. For a university this is a best case scenario: sell a "necessary" product to millions of individual customers with infinite money. If instead, the universities could only "sell" to the government, the government would be able to actually demand meaningful concessions in price. I'm thinking something like: 1. Students -$-> Gov't -$-> Universities (many more sellers than buyers) Instead of: 2. Gov't -$-> Students -$-> Universities (many more buyers than sellers) Easy to see how case 1 would keep prices lower in an ideal world...
- fiatmoney 10y agoIt's almost like a government-encouraged oligopoly is maximizing the amount of value they can seize from people regulatorily encouraged / forced to buy their product.
- noonespecial 10y agoSo long as the government guarantees students that they can get the loan, and guarantees lenders that it will be paid back (mostly by making the debt lifelong and not dischargeable through bankruptcy) the cost of education will simply be set at whatever the maximum available loan is. This will cause the value of the education to be transferred away from the student and to the administrators of the institutions. The student will be allowed to keep a small percentage of this value for his/her trouble, a sharecropper of their own education.
- davidwparker 10y agoI'm a little surprised that no one has suggested joining the military. When I was in high school, my parents had no money for me for College. We were middle class, and my grades weren't competitive enough for me to get a scholarship. So I did what I thought would work well (in 2002)- I joined the USAF as an enlisted "Computer Programmer". Fortunately, _did_ have a good education, so my ASVAB (military job test to determine what jobs you could be) score was relatively high. Joining as a computer programmer opened up the world to me like I couldn't imagine. Ultimately, I ended up taking night and weekend classes while in the USAF and finished my bachelor's degree shortly before getting out. Later I would go on to get my Master's with my GI Bill because I didn't want it to go to waste. I felt honored to serve my country and to contribute how I could and I graduated both undergrad and grad school with zero dollars of debt. I think more people should consider this option, at least if they have a decent education and good military jobs open to them. Understandably, if someone joins as say, infantry, in the Army, it may not be so easy to go to school (though I have plenty of friends who did and took online classes!) It's not for everyone, but it's definitely an option.
- massysett 10y ago"a college education is being priced out of the reach of middle-class and even upper-middle-class families." If this were true, we would see one of two things: (1) colleges would be empty and closing their doors, or (2) we'd have an enormous debt bubble. (1) is obviously false. (2) is more interesting and, indeed, debt levels may be high. However, in a development that most pieces like this ignore, the federal government now has significant loan repayment forgiveness programs, along with income-sensitive repayment plans. So no, with huge programs that will wipe student debt clean, I laugh in the face of a headline that asserts that college is "unaffordable even in higher income brackets." Look here: https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/understand/plans/income-driven https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/understand/plans/in... "Most federal student loans are eligible for at least one income-driven repayment plan. If your income is low enough, your payment could be as low as $0 per month." So $0 a month is unaffordable??
- choward 10y ago> "If your income is low enough, your payment could be as low as $0 per month." > So $0 a month is unaffordable?? "If your income is low enough." Read the headline again.
- massysett 10y agoI can read it fifty times and the conclusion doesn't change. The programs cap payments to perfectly reasonable amounts.
- sedachv 10y agoThe income-sensitive repayment plans come with a lot of caveats. My wife took that route before we married and it was mostly just a huge debt trap with interest piling up and she still struggled to make payments. I have not done the math with median debt/income/compound interest over X years but it seems to me that a lot of people who go that route will wind up with debt they will never be able to repay in their lifetimes. After we married it turns out the income part is based on household; my income is much larger than hers, and while hers has gone up since she still has trouble paying the new monthly rates based on our joint income from her salary alone.
- Steeeve 10y agoThis just isn't true. Compared to most of the U.S. I make a lot of money (Software Engineer in Silicon Valley). I have kids a few years from college, so this topic weighs on me. I ran my financials through Stanford's cost calculator (Stanford is among the most expensive schools), and my expected contribution would be under $10K / year. Yes, it costs $65K+ / year for tuition, housing, etc., but the reality is that those costs are not nearly as terrifying when you factor in financial aid programs that are available. I remember how terrified I was of my student loans in my day. I also remember how awesome it felt when they got paid off. This has turned into a political topic and whenever that happens logic and facts go out the window in favor of emotion triggering pseudo-statistics.
- devishard 10y ago1. Stanford is an outlier in terms of financial aid--they provide far more financial aid than most schools. 2. Good luck getting into Stanford.
- Steeeve 10y agoI just ran through the same calculator at UC Berkeley. The difference in expectations is minimal. I then ran through the CSU calculator. The cost is actually doubled for CSUs, which have a lower total cost, but no grant/scholarship programs offered directly through the university financial aid office. My own experience with that environment tells me there are plenty of grant/scholarship options.
- devishard 10y agoI'm not sure why you think looking at three California University calculators for one year's tuition is any more a representative sample than your previous anecdotes. You're disagreeing with national surveys of the cost that people actually pay over four years. You're disagreeing based on a limited sample of promotional calculators of one year cost from one area of the country.
- 10y ago
- beatpanda 10y agoWhy is every other advanced economy in the world able to deal with this, but America can't? People who respond in discussions like this that the real problem must be so many greedy kids wanting things like a good job, financial stability, etc need to first confront the fact that this is a uniquely American problem.
- Mz 10y agoI dropped out of college after two years, in part because I personally knew two people with a Bachelor's degree in hand who delivered newspapers for a living, both of whom had pretty pathetic lives. At age 18, my boyfriend delivered newspapers. I was very familiar with the terrible hours and pay. I felt extremely clear that I could deliver newspapers without a degree and my life would be vastly better if I did so without first being saddled with a mountain of debt. We sell people on the idea that college is The Ticket to a serious career with good pay. It isn't that cut and dried. We really need to stop promoting that idea. I later returned to school when I had a better idea of what I wanted to do with my life. One of my positive experiences was with community college in California. The in state rates are surprisingly low. I wrapped up my AA and this inspired my husband to start going to college. As a military member, he got 75% of his tuition covered. His out of pocket tuition expenses were substantially less than the cost of textbooks. The community college system in California is one of its little known strengths. Many four year colleges have agreements in place with community colleges that make it easy to do your first two years cheaply and then transfer to a prestigious four year program. California Virtual Campus is also an amazing resource.
- bdcravens 10y agoPerhaps the key is something between a boot camp (I mean the coding kind, not the military kind) and a 4-year school? A lot of time and money is wasted on the culture of college (sports, activities, partying, Greek life, etc....) and it seems there's a lot of room for disruption.
- bdcravens 10y agoPerhaps the key is something between a boot camp (I mean the coding kind, not the military kind) and a 4-year school? A lot of time and money is wasted on the culture of college (sports, activities, partying, Greek life, etc....) and it seems there's a lot of room for disruption.
- hdx 10y agoI went to college and graduated with a Computer Engineering degree from SJSU without any financial help from my parents, the government or anybody else. Oh and I had to support my child from the second year on as well. It took me about 30% longer to finish it, and I was sleep deprived most of those years due to having to work AND go to school, but I graduated with $0 debt.
- tw04 10y agoI'd say a bigger problem is parents encouraging their kids to go to college to do what they enjoy instead of encouraging them to go to college for a profession that will pay the bills. If you want to "do what you enjoy" for a living, and it pays $25k/year in salary... maybe don't spend $100k on college...?