7 ms·
I'm really conflicted about this. On the one hand, I think that gun control is an important issue and limiting gun ownership has a very direct impact on saving
by onion2k 10y ago
I'm really conflicted about this. On the one hand, I think that gun control is an important issue and limiting gun ownership has a very direct impact on saving lives. I agree with the law that was being debated. (Aside: I'm British. I live in the UK. It doesn't directly affect me.)
But...
The point of a democratic government is to debate an issue, vote on it, and then to enact the result of the vote. Representatives should weigh the information available, the points raised in debates, and their own consciences, and come to a conclusion of their own. Direct action like a sit-down protest undermines and subverts the process of democracy by saying "Do what we want or we'll make life intolerably difficult for you." That is not how government should work. Government shouldn't be held to ransom.
In this case it's easy to agree with the protest, but what happens if, say, the Republicans lose a debate on reducing income tax for millionaires to zero and organise a sit-in to try to get their own way?
- laumars 10y agoI don't see how that's any worse than any other form of lobbying that happens. Quite frankly I'm increasingly of the opinion that the whole political process is broken and only favours those with the deepest pockets and loudest voices rather than the needs of the majority.
- kasey_junk 10y agoThe point of this protest is that the GOP won't allow a vote via procedural rules & haven't allowed a vote on lots of proposed gun control laws. The GOP used the same tactic on expanded oil & gas drilling http://heavy.com/news/2016/06/when-was-last-sit-in-longest-congress-house-democrats-republicans-record/ http://heavy.com/news/2016/06/when-was-last-sit-in-longest-c... I'm very conflicted on the bill the Dems want voted on but gun control needs open debate & voting.
- LyndsySimon 10y agoIt's not a "GOP only" thing, even on this topic. Harry Reid prevented all kinds of gun control bills from being discussed for years.
- kasey_junk 10y agoSure, but this particular protest is against GOP based procedural decisions in recent years.
- ericcumbee 10y agoThe Democrats did the same thing when they were in power.
- jimhefferon 10y agoBut in this case exactly what they are protesting is that the leadership of the Republican party will not bring the measure up for debate and vote.
- Cyph0n 10y agoI'm astounded at how adamant many Americans are when it comes to even discussing gun control.
- brightball 10y agoThat's because the US homocide rate is at a 51 year low according to the FBI while gun ownership is dramatically higher. We've had 2 terrorism incidents and we need to be addressing what could have prevented them. Every time an incident happens that gets on the news we see this song and dance about implementing gun control policies that wouldn't have stopped the incident being used to push them. That means that Democrats aren't trying to solve a problem. They are simply waiting to use national tragedies to push an agenda. Solving a problem looks like "here is how this happened and here is a policy that will make sure it doesn't again." Democrats have not proposed anything along those lines in the last 8 years.
- whatok 10y agoAgree with this 100%. No gun control law would have prevented this from happening in America solely because we have quite a few guns here. If not procured legally, he easily could buy a gun illegally. Constitution aside, if there was a way to magically disappear every gun in America and then enact complete gun bans I might be willing to entertain to the notion. Otherwise it's just a bunch of posturing to me.
- pigpaws 10y agothe problem then would be that only the 'important' people would have guns. I don't see any politicians giving up their security details. I don't see Diane Feinstein or Chuck Schumer giving up their 'concealed carry' licenses. Its a classic "Do as I say, not as I do." If they can carry in their overly restrictive states, why can't the electorate? don't they have the same rights? No? because political elitism. Even in that bastion of fascism, NJ: http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2016/03/lawmaker_let_nj_legislators_judges_carry_handguns.html http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2016/03/lawmaker_let_nj...
- distances 10y agoI thought the reason for the protest was that the republican speaker is refusing to bring the issue to a vote, even though they would clearly win the vote anyway.
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoYou are asking exactly the right question. When something happens that's unusual where you agree with the cause, but question the actions, ask yourself: what if I didn't agree with the cause? (This is Kant's Categorical Imperative - Act only according to that maxim whereby you can, at the same time, will that it should become a universal law.) Otherwise we're just out in the streets beating each other with clubs. In this case, however, it's political theater during an election year. The right folks cheer, the right folks get angry, and the two-party system keeps humming along. The House has the ability to direct the Sergeant at Arms to bring order to the chamber. That's their job. Been done before. So this goes on for a bit, the ruling party brings down the hammer, and everybody gets to be angry. I disagree with this cause, but even if I agreed I don't see much utility coming out of this aside from energizing the base in an election year where one party desperately needs an energized base. (The other party has gone off the playbook and is not appealing to its base at all. It'll be interesting what happens to their base.)
- jacquesm 10y agoThe whole point as far as I understand it is they don't want to vote because they'd have to vote against such a measure and this may prove to be very un-popular and with the elections coming up it will cost them (potentially) a lot of votes.
- mtgx 10y agoNot to mention the biggest issue here is that Democrats want to put anyone the executive suspects on a secret "terrorist watchlist," for which there's little to no redress and they won't even tell if you're off of it or not, so you could continue to be harassed by the government and you may not even know why that's happening. Fix the terrorist/no-fly watchlist first, and then we'll talk. Other than that, I am in the camp of favoring much stronger gun control. But secret lists and a further weakening of due process in the U.S. is not the answer.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoHmm. If it passed, though, that creates the possibility of this lovely hack: You don't know if you're on the terrorist watch list. Want to find out? Try to buy a gun.
- whamlastxmas 10y ago> Direct action like a sit-down protest undermines and subverts the process of democracy by saying "Do what we want or we'll make life intolerably difficult for you." That is not how government should work. Government shouldn't be held to ransom. This is pretty blatantly wrong in regards to how the US senate works and has worked for a long time. Filibustering is a normal thing for the senate and has an important, valuable role historically. Today, unfortunately, it's mostly a cosmetic thing senators will do for good press. What the House members are doing is essentially the House equivalent of filibustering, which doesn't exist in an official capacity. Regardless, it's not really interrupting much and it's definitely not doing anything other than generating press. Also, it's funny see a British person asking for rational behavior from foreign lawmakers considering the wigs, heckling, and jeering of UK parliament.