20 ms·
A Stark Nuclear Warning
- my_first_acct 10y agoThis is a review of the book "My Journey at the Nuclear Brink", by William Perry, US Secretary of Defense in the the Clinton administration. The reviewer is Jerry Brown, Governor of California.
- jamesrom 10y agoThe gushing flattery of Perry in this review is gross.
- ageofwant 10y agoAgreed. It actually forced me out three paragraphs in. I do now realise how ineffectual, grating even, fawning deference to authority has become, to me at least.
- pm90 10y agoI don't understand this sentiment at all. It seems like Perry's advice is most rational and reasonable and seems to be ignored by most of the Establishment and the general Public. I'm all against hero worship, but giving credit where credit is due - to a man who has lived through WW2 right up to the end of the cold war, seems reasonable.
- ageofwant 10y agoYou misunderstand. My beef is not with Perry. It's with the author's writing style. I'm not going to forgive poor writing because I happen to agree with the writer. Its not what he is saying, its how its being said.
- sdenton4 10y agoMeh. Writing isn't his day job, and it's really not all that badly written. There are many brilliant people out there who aren't brilliant writers, who are worth listening to none the less.
- lostlogin 10y agoNo no! "Perry does not use his memoir to score points or settle grudges. He does not sensationalize." Someone defines sensationalise differently to me and the dictionary.
- f_allwein 10y agoI agree that the nuclear threat may be bigger today than in cold war times. More nations now have nuclear weapons and the possibility that one will be used one day is > 0. When I grew up in Germany in the 80s, there was a real sense that nuclear war could start any time. Unfortunately, we haven't used the short widow of opportunity after the cold war to get rid of all nuclear weapons. Now I wonder what, if anything, can happen to convince us as a species to get rid of them.
- epicureanideal 10y agoI think part of the threat increase is also that when nuclear weapons were new, people were more afraid of them. Now the fear seems to be wearing off.
- saboot 10y agoIn addition to the current upgrading of nuclear weapons. New technology making them smarter, more accurate, and thus more tactical with small yields.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm conflicted on this. On one hand, the amount of damage we'd suffer is a lot lower now that the average weapon might be a few hundred kilotons and dropped precisely on a military base rather than a 20-30 megaton weapon tossed roughly in the direction of a city center. On the other hand, the fact that there would be so much less collateral damage (but still a ton) could make people much more willing to use them.
- ridgeguy 10y agoI agree with your "other hand". I think the changes you cited (less damage due to high precision use of low yield weapons) make it on balance more likely they'll be used. The real barrier to nuke use is gaining entry to the club. U235 enrichment, Pu239 synthesis, implosion, initiators, etc. In contrast, the entry barrier to precision delivery is small and diminishing. If you're new in town (IN, PK, NK), your noob inefficient, unoptimized weapons can be really effective if precisely delivered. And it doesn't necessarily mean ballistic delivery. Moves the "unthinkable" threshold downward. It's worrisome.
- rrggrr 10y agoDespite three major armed conflicts fought between nuclear powers by proxy, none thankfully have resulted in nuclear war. Deterrence works. What doesn't work, and a flaw that is growing exponentially with nuclear proliferation is failures in design, command and control. The incredible and incredibly frightening book "Command and Control" (see link at bottom), highlights several near catastrophic misses in the US nuclear arsenal. Now multiply by all nuclear states, the risks of accident are terrifying. The world would do well to open source safeguards so that even rogue states (eg. North Korea) can benefit from control and process that mitigate risk of unintended nuclear detonation. https://www.amazon.com/Command-Control-Damascus-Accident-Illusion/dp/0143125788 https://www.amazon.com/Command-Control-Damascus-Accident-Ill...
- zalg0 10y ago> so that even rogue states can benefit Dude, human factors like personality and mood quickly render safeguards moot, within the atmosphere of a despotic dictatorship. Open source any amount of safety protocals, and pray that they get used, and you'll acquaint yourself with disappointment. People who concoct nuclear programs are toying with suicide, and their level of interest in safety can be understood by their decision to weaponize such a thing to begin with. Meanwhile, cap such a program with a lone psychotic emperor, prone to fits of cruel and unusual punishment, and see what he does on a bad day, as his body ages, and he grows crankier with every waking morning. Now surround him with an echo-chamber of eager-to-please, hawkish, testosterone-fueled military upstarts. Sounds like a pretty cool video game plot.
- aswanson 10y agoSounds like a trump presidency.
- rrggrr 10y agoI'm no fan of Trump and I think its thankfully unlikely he'll be the US President. But if he is President there is this quote from Trump that suggests he has more self-awareness and emotional intelligence than his carefully crafted persona suggests. "When I'm wounded, I go after people hard and I try to unwound myself." If failed Presidents have had one thing in common its a failure to recognize their own limitations and failings before or after-the-fact. Again, no fan of the guy, but I think the scare-mongering is overblown.
- Gustomaximus 10y agoFrom Cuban crisis: "First, Perry writes, the Soviet ships approaching the blockade imposed by the US had submarine escorts that were armed with nuclear torpedoes. Because of the difficulty with communications, Moscow had authorized the submarine commanders to fire without further authorization. When an American destroyer tried to force a submarine to surface, both its captain and the political officer decided to fire a nuclear torpedo at the destroyer. A nuclear confrontation was avoided only because Vasili Arkhipov, the overall commander of the fleet, was also present on the submarine. He countermanded the order to launch, thereby preventing what might have started a nuclear war." Another one of these 'almost nuclear' stories. There's only so many times humanity can roll the dice and come out clean. Scary stuff.
- ams6110 10y agoA nuclear torpedo to take out a destroyer? Seems like the proverbial swatting a fly with a sledgehammer? And what of the submarine? Torpedos are fairly close-range weapons, at least in those days. Would it have survived the blast?
- pm90 10y agoI may be wrong here, but a surface detonation is unlikely to damage a submarine that is deep underwater. That is the reason why a fleet of nuclear submarines are the best nuclear deterrent: hard to take out since they can be anywhere undersea, mobile and ready to counterattack at a moments notice.
- narag 10y agoCan a submarine that is deep underwater launch torpedoes? I didn't think so. OTOH, a nuke doesn't need to yield several megatons. First devices were about 20 kilotons and it's possible to create smaller ones. I'm sure I've seen some video of 1 kiloton bomb. Also, intuitively, it doesn't seem that it would destroy a sub a few miles away looking at Baker test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nWFx-zmI0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nWFx-zmI0k Around 1:25 there's a brief fragment showing the explosion underwater with the usual expansion-contraction cycle.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoThis is IMO one of the most important things that next to nobody pays attention to. People toss around "use a nuke" or "because we have nukes" as though they're like any other conventional weapon. I'd venture to guess that none of those people have been around a large conventional weapon exploding, which pales in comparison to even a small nuclear warhead.
- vacri 10y agoThis reminds me of the irony of when the US invaded Iraq, because "Saddam has Weapons of Mass Destruction"[1]... while bragging that the US was going to use the MOAB, the Mother of All Bombs, the largest conventional bomb ever. The US has always had trouble with the internal consistency of it's propaganda :) [1] Which weren't nuclear, and required a redefinition of the phrase to suit.
- imglorp 10y agoWhy was China not mentioned as a third, major participant in the next arms race? Why were all the lesser proliferants not mentioned? Isn't it far more likely that somebody on a holy mission buys or steals something they shouldn't have in the near future than a full conflict among the big three later?
- thyrsus 10y ago"Perry also warns that a regional nuclear war between India and Pakistan could occur—with devastating global impacts."
- hackuser 10y ago> Isn't it far more likely that somebody on a holy mission buys or steals something they shouldn't have in the near future than a full conflict among the big three later? Perhaps we are too wrapped up in our recent experiences when we say that. IMHO humanity's perspectives tend to be reactive: If the last experience was a terrorist attack, that's what we look for next. If it was a major power confrontation, then that's what we anticipate.
- caf 10y agoChina's nuclear doctrine is based on "minimum deterrence", which is why their arsenal is considerably smaller than that of the big two.
- imglorp 10y agoChina alone has ICBM's to deliver anywhere they like. So they're on par with the big two. It really doesn't matter how many they have.
- keybuk 10y agoSeeing this title, I thought: "(Nuclear) Winter is Coming."
- wallace_f 10y agoEven though the risks are enormous, any world power using nuclear weapons would probably need to be exceedingly irrational. World leaders want to stay in power, and continue to rule over their subjects. I don't see it happening, except by: 1) misunderstanding/miscommunication 2) incompetence 3) desperation 4) particularly bloodthirsty individual Should we be confident? #1 was witnessed in the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (mokusatsu incident) #2 Incompetence is pervasive in government (i.e. when the Stratfor leaks came, their internal wiki said of the FBI "good at breaking up used car rings. Confused by anything more complicated." Even corporations with close ties to government disparage the powerful 3-letter agencies without counter argument.) #3 yet to be seen #4 I hope it is out of the cards
- hackuser 10y agoIt reminds me of investing advice from Peter Lynch: Invest in a company that any fool can run because, some day, one will. If we don't design our systems, Android apps or nuclear weapons, for those kind of people, we've failed.
- zalg0 10y agoDon't forget #5: detached, morbid curiosity combined with depraved abandon.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y ago>any world power using nuclear weapons would probably need to be exceedingly irrational. Leaders are exceedingly irrational. Stalin and Hitler literally killed millions. Considering that many generals in the German army considered WWII unwinnable before Hitler started it, WWII may have been one of the world's longest and bloodiest suicide notes. Combine that with a literal death cult, laced with bizarre fantasies about blood, iron, and the holy homeland, and you can see just how irrational world powers can get. Japan wasn't much better off. The bombs were a horror, but at least they cauterised imperialism out of the Japanese psyche for at least a few generations - at a huge cost. The US isn't much better off now. The reasons for war are more religious than personal - the pursuit of profit - but the millions who have died since WWII in US direct and proxy campaigns are no less dead for it. Russia? China? Let's see. It's clear that the only reason we've avoided nuclear suicide so far is blind luck - often the blind luck that put a relatively sane individual in a position where they, not presidents, emperors, kings, and politicians, could choose the fate of the world. Ultimately you can't win at Russian Roulette. You can only not lose - for a limited time.
- beloch 10y agoWhat concerns me the most about nuclear weapons is that the technical barriers to building them are getting lower all the time. They're currently within reach of despotic states of below average scientific capacity. All that's required is the will to defy the world (e.g. North Korea). Given how North Korea and Iraq have been treated lately, what despot wouldn't pursue nuclear weapons if he thought he could succeed in building them fast enough to avoid being invaded? In the future, the barrier will be even lower. Nuclear weapons will likely fall within reach of motivated and capable terrorist movements such as ISIL, although I'd be more worried about organizations that haven't carved out territory that's easy to attack. Once that happens, things could get very ugly. There is no such thing as MAD with a distributed terrorist organization. Missile defense systems offer no real answers. They don't work against state of the art missiles (such as Russia has), nor do they work against smuggled bombs or bombs built within the borders of their target nation. The kind of surveillance that would be required to adequately secure a nation against such weapons is the stuff Orwell never even dreamed of. It would require utterly pervasive, invasive, and constant surveillance.
- hackuser 10y ago> What concerns me the most about nuclear weapons is that the technical barriers to building them are getting lower all the time. It's 70 year old technology.
- narrator 10y agoI think this is a test for our species here on planet earth before we level up on technology. We have to be able to have a certain level of self-control or we're going to destroy ourselves and go back to the stone age if we can't handle the power that comes with advanced technology. So far, we've been able to avoid nuclear annihilation, so there's some hope.
- adrianN 10y agoIf you don't have territory, it's hard to build enrichment facilities. That is a step that is unlikely to get much easier in the near future. Controlling enriched material seems easier than preventing people from building bombs once they have it.
- dogmatix 10y agoWinter is coming?
- LionessLover 10y ago> but my intuition says this is believable. We replaced that with science and fact-checking hundreds of years ago. Seriously, what a useless, stupid response.
- nl 10y agoSeriously, what a useless, stupid response. What an uncivil thing to say. Incidentally it is also wrong. Humans are pretty good at inferring unknown behavior from known observations. A hypothesis is part of the scientific process and that is what we have here. As it happens, there is evidence for what would occur[1], and the posters intuition turns out to be mostly correct. [1] http://gizmodo.com/5942246/this-is-what-happens-when-a-nuclear-bomb-explodes-underwater http://gizmodo.com/5942246/this-is-what-happens-when-a-nucle...
- LionessLover 10y agoSeriously, what a useless, stupid response. Check the place between your ears - your brain seems to have escaped. Not to mention hypocrisy: I bet you are more than willing to point out in other contexts that actually measuring and doing experiments trump "personal experience". Just because I called the guy and you stupid - which both of you are - doesn't make me wrong. Just because people are "nice" doesn't make them right.
- nl 10y agoTo LionessLover (who's comment is now flagged): I agree that you calling us both stupid didn't make you wrong - it was the evidence from the experiment, and the way the scientific method works that did that.
- LionessLover 10y ago> it was the evidence from the experiment, and the way the scientific method works that did that. EVIDENCE? The parent only talk about his gut feeling, you fucking piece of shit.
- Farax123 10y ago
- dkbrk 10y ago> Perry tells us that parity is “old thinking” because nuclear weapons can’t actually be used—the risk of uncontrollable and catastrophic escalation is too high. They are only good for threatening the enemy with nuclear retaliation. This is an important point, which I believe is not necessarily subscribed to by all those in the military. In particular, I am greatly concerned that the use of tactical nuclear weapons—even very small ones on the scale of just 100t TNT or so—is far more likely to occur than a full scale strategic nuclear exchange, and that this could lead to escalation with tactical nuclear weapons of ever greater size, eventually leading to a far higher probability that strategic weapons are eventually used. I believe that if you looked at the Top Secret plans produced by the Pentagon and the Russian General Staff you would find many that call for "limited" use of tactical nuclear weapons in response to an overwhelming attack by conventional forces. In addition there are proposals such as the "nuclear bunker buster" that was floated a few years back during the invasion of Afghanistan. The great problem is that once the use of nuclear weapons of any sort becomes at all normalised, there is no upper limit to their destructive capability. The largest nuclear weapon ever detonated, Tsar Bomba, was a three stage thermonuclear device and had a yield of about 50 Mt TNT, but such a weapon could be easily scaled up simply by adding additional thermonuclear stages. Once nuclear weapons become actively used in any capacity the destructive capability of a nuclear-armed state is limited only by its restraint. Consider the Allies' strategic bombing campaigns against Germany and Japan in WWII. The goal was to destroy the enemy's ability to make war and to force them to surrender; this involved killing civilians and military personnel, and destroying infrastructure and production capability. Note that killing civilans served to advance the principal goal of winning the war but was not an end in itself. If the war could be won with everything exactly the same except for fewer enemy casualties, I believe any sane commander with ethics remotely similar to my own would take that choice. In other words, inflicting enemy casualties has positive instrumental value but negative intrinsic value. In contrast, Hitler saw killing Jews and other populations as having positive intrinsic value, as a goal worth pursuing in and of itself. If I had complete authority over a nation's nuclear weapons I would never, under any circumstances, actually use them. In all respects I would act as though I would respond to a nuclear attack in kind without hesitation, but that would be a lie. If I were faced with an overwhelming strategic attack and had the opportunity to respond with an attack of equal magnitude, I would not. Such an act would not change the outcome of my own nation, it would merely inflict the same on my enemy, which since I am not a psycopath has negative utility. At that point the war is already lost, the best one could do is minimise the destruction inflicted on humanity as a whole. So I believe Perry assertion "nuclear weapons can't actually be used" is literally correct in the logical extreme. The problem is that deterrence requires the appearance of being ready to use them, and that is very difficult to fake. I think this underscores the importance of control mechanisms. Historically such mechanisms were opposed because they might put the weapons out of action when they need to be used, for example the Minuteman ICBM codes were set to all zeroes until 1977 and even today the captain of a British Vanguard-class submarine has the capability to launch without a code being transmitted from headquarters. This lends credence to the idea that these militaries intend to actually use such weapons in the event, not just appear to be prepared to use them. If you wanted to just fake the appearance of being prepared to use them it would be sufficient to plan not to distribute the right codes: the deterrence effect would not be lessened at all as the enemy would never risk you not being able to distribute the correct codes in the event.
- bambax 10y ago> Why is fear of a nuclear catastrophe far from the minds of most Americans? Because there's nothing they/we can do about it? There's no much point in worrying about things you have no control over.
- LionessLover 10y ago> but my intuition says this is believable. We replaced that with science and fact-checking hundreds of years ago. Seriously, what a useless, stupid response.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoI completely agree that the danger now is much more than it was 40 years ago. Having said that, there's plenty of blame to go around for everybody, and I'm not sure there is much to be done about it. The underlying problem is that technology is making smaller and smaller actors capable of more and more destructive actions. It's not just nukes. It's not inconceivable that one hacker somewhere could take down the U.S. electric grid. That's insane. We're living in an extremely asymmetric world. Reducing nuclear stockpiles needs to be done. It eliminates the ability to create worldwide nuclear catastrophic damage with a push of a button. But if things got serious between major powers? They'd just build more nukes. You've taken what might have happened in 60 minutes and turned it into a 2-week affair. It's a move in the right direction, but I don't think it fixes anything. It's just better. I am probably wrong, but my gut tells me the nuke threat may be overblown, at least in terms of a complete, species-ending event for mankind. We're like cockroaches, and I tend to believe some of us would struggle through somehow. I hope we never find out. But as to the larger issue of small groups holding enormous destructive power, I not so optimistic. I could easily see a situation where multiple catastrophic attacks in various sectors occur simultaneously. I am not so sanguine about our chances then. And I don't see any sort of policy change or treaty changing any of that. Scary times to be living in.
- luckystarr 10y agoSo A Canticle for Leibowitz is still relevant. Chilling. :(
- graycat 10y agoThe article was concerned that NATO expanded its membership too much, that is, added too many countries too close to Russia. Presumably the concern here is that Russia will, then, feel more threatened by an attack from NATO. Uh, gee, guys, that concern seems not to understand maybe the more important role of NATO! Sure, first cut, it appears that the purpose of NATO is to have the European countries ban together better to defend themselves against an attack from Russia. Hmm .... But maybe a more important reason for NATO is to take all of the military forces in Europe, especially those closest to Russia, and put them under central command and control, with a big role for the US. Why? To stop another case like started WWI -- some terrorist in the long boiling Balkans shot a prince of Austria or some such. That is, the purpose of NATO is to keep a lid on the instabilities of 22 or so countries west of Russia and, thus, avoid war, protect Russia, etc. Sure, this is a joke but only partly. Or, in history, how often has Russia gone charging to the west trying to take over Sweden, Germany, or France? Or was the real threat Napoleon charging east, Germany charging east, etc.? Or, we can expect instabilities in Europe. So, we need to keep a lid on that pot. Thus, NATO! Russia? A good lid on that unstable European pot, e.g., the long boiling Balkans, is very much in Russia's interests.
- golergka 10y agoBTW, people jumping from government to industry and back is usually seen as corruption in liberal HN crowd — but I don't see any complains here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Farax123 10y ago> but my intuition says this is believable. We replaced that with science and fact-checking hundreds of years ago. Seriously, what a useless, stupid response.
- dang 10y agoPlease stop making accounts to break the HN guidelines with. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11958683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11958683 and marked it off-topic.