2 ms·
One thing that should be clear in these argument is that many people intuitive sense of the nature of consciousness. It seems absolutely obvious that there's s
by joe_the_user 10y ago
One thing that should be clear in these argument is that many people intuitive sense of the nature of consciousness.
It seems absolutely obvious that there's something unique in a human brain-body that can't be encompassed by just information. It's often denoted by "living, breathing, feeling".
There's no more concrete argument here. A person whose awakened from general anesthesia still "feels like they are the same". A person who, hypothetically, had all cells in their body replace themselves through cell division (say some youth-regaining process more complete than the ordinary aging process, which replaces quite a few still) wouldn't face the "am I really me" question is the same way as that exact duplicate on Mars.
I think these "identity issues" have to do with our internal processes of psychological adaptation. Each human is constantly changing and has a multitude of impulses - yet we each have to pursue our interests as a single being who deals with other single beings. So our brains have a reflexive tendency to form a sense of unified consciousness.
One might say that these are "just psychological issues" but I think it's reasonable to say that this reflex towards unified self-conception is very important for the thing humans do, at in the world as a unified whole rather than a collection of, say, feedback loops.