3 ms·
So what you are saying is that if you don't know what can go wrong then it's "obviously true." Let's try some other things. * If you draw a distorted circle i
by ColinWright 10y ago
So what you are saying is that if you don't know what can go wrong then it's "obviously true."
Let's try some other things.
* If you draw a distorted circle in the plane then it's obviously true that it has an inside and an outside.
* The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to a plane with a hole in it.
* In three dimensions if you have a distorted sphere then it obviously divides space into an inside and an outside.
* The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to 3D space with a hole in it.
All obvious, right?
Now, pick the statement (or statements) from the above that are in fact false.
- scott_s 10y agoPlease eventually provide the answer, because I'm curious!
- Arnavion 10y agoThe correct spelling "contractible" yields useful Google results, namely that spheres in 3 dimensions (point 4) are not contractible to a single point. Edit: ... and maybe circles (point 2) too? Not a mathematician.
- JadeNB 10y ago> The correct spelling "contractible" yields useful Google results, namely that spheres in 3 dimensions (point 4) are not contractible to a single point. The claim is about the interior, not the sphere itself (which certainly is not contractible, as you say).
- ColinWright 10y agoYou have email.
- bluecalm 10y ago>>So what you are saying is that if you don't know what can go wrong then it's "obviously true." I never claimed that. I only claimed that FTA is obvious and that pointing out that something similar to FTA on some complex objects (a + sqrt(-5) things) doesn't work isn't a correct way to argue the FTA itself isn't obvious. >>If you draw a distorted circle in the plane then it's obviously true that it has an inside and an outside. Yes (as long as definition of "distorted" doesn't contain any surprises, I am assuming you mean not exactly a circle but something like it). >>The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to a plane with a hole in it. Those things already aren't obvious. Go ask someone a bright kid in high school what "contractable to a plane" is. It's not obvious in any way to non-mathematician. I am claiming FTA is obvious for a bright person who understand multiplication (or for a caveman who can do multiplication by putting rectangles together, then making rectangles from those rectangles etc.) >>In three dimensions if you have a distorted sphere then it obviously divides space into an inside and an outside. Yes, obvious. >>The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to 3D space with a hole in it Again, those things are very far from obvious. What "contractable to 3D space with a hole" means is very far away from "obvious" by any reasonable definition of the word.