3 ms·
> Now let's assume that our number A has > two factorings F1 and F2. Let's sort > them from the smallest to the biggest > divider. OK, I've done t
by ColinWright 10y ago
> Now let's assume that our number A has
> two factorings F1 and F2. Let's sort
> them from the smallest to the biggest
> divider.
OK, I've done that.
> Is it possible that F1 and F2 are
> different at the first position? It
> isn't as that would mean the same
> number has different smallest prime
> divider.
So why is this false in Z[ sqrt(-5) ] ?? There we have:
6 = 2 x 3
6 = (1 - sqrt(-5)) x ((1 + sqrt(-5))
Now 6 has a "smallest" factor of 2, and a "smallest" factor of (1 - sqrt(-5)).
> It is in fact obvious to someone who
> understands multiplication.
So you are claiming that the author of the linked article, Prof Sir Tim Gowers, winner of the Fields Medal, Fellow of the Royal Society, doesn't understand multiplication? Might I instead suggest that you don't understand the things that might go wrong, and the subtleties that lurk underneath.
- bluecalm 10y ago>>So why is this false in Z[ sqrt(-5) ] I don't know, I don't know what sqrt is, let alone sqrt for a negative number. It's like asking someone who made a nice geometric proof of Pitagoras theorem why it doesn't work on a 4 dimensional sphere for stuff which is kinda like triangles. It's different multiplication you are mentioning here. I can't do (1-sqrt(-5) x (1 + sqrt(-5) by putting some stones in a rectangle and counting them. The concepts of primes, multiplication, divisor don't instantly make sense for those objects and I am not sure why you ask me to extend them. I am just claiming FTA is obvious for natural numbers and straightforward multiplication. >> 6 = 2 x 3 >> 6 = (1 - sqrt(-5)) x ((1 + sqrt(-5)) I mentioned sorting from the smallest, can't do that with your sqrt thing. Another obvious thing with multiplication is that the more you multiply the more you get which isn't true for a + sqrt(-5). >>So you are claiming that the author of the linked article, Prof Sir Tim Gowers, winner of the Fields Medal, Fellow of the Royal Society, doesn't understand multiplication? No, I haven't claimed that. I think FTA is quite obvious to him but it's not obvious if you try formally define arithmetic using the smallest sensible subset of axioms. It is obvious is you just understand multiplication and can perform it by forming rectangles and then rectangles from rectangles (in case of 3 terms to multiply). >>ight I instead suggest that you don't understand the things that might go wrong, and the subtleties that lurk underneath. There are many subtleties in defining and proving things formally. That's a different point altogether.
- ColinWright 10y agoSo what you are saying is that if you don't know what can go wrong then it's "obviously true." Let's try some other things. * If you draw a distorted circle in the plane then it's obviously true that it has an inside and an outside. * The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to a plane with a hole in it. * In three dimensions if you have a distorted sphere then it obviously divides space into an inside and an outside. * The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to 3D space with a hole in it. All obvious, right? Now, pick the statement (or statements) from the above that are in fact false.
- scott_s 10y agoPlease eventually provide the answer, because I'm curious!
- Arnavion 10y agoThe correct spelling "contractible" yields useful Google results, namely that spheres in 3 dimensions (point 4) are not contractible to a single point. Edit: ... and maybe circles (point 2) too? Not a mathematician.
- JadeNB 10y ago> The correct spelling "contractible" yields useful Google results, namely that spheres in 3 dimensions (point 4) are not contractible to a single point. The claim is about the interior, not the sphere itself (which certainly is not contractible, as you say).
- ColinWright 10y agoYou have email.
- bluecalm 10y ago>>So what you are saying is that if you don't know what can go wrong then it's "obviously true." I never claimed that. I only claimed that FTA is obvious and that pointing out that something similar to FTA on some complex objects (a + sqrt(-5) things) doesn't work isn't a correct way to argue the FTA itself isn't obvious. >>If you draw a distorted circle in the plane then it's obviously true that it has an inside and an outside. Yes (as long as definition of "distorted" doesn't contain any surprises, I am assuming you mean not exactly a circle but something like it). >>The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to a plane with a hole in it. Those things already aren't obvious. Go ask someone a bright kid in high school what "contractable to a plane" is. It's not obvious in any way to non-mathematician. I am claiming FTA is obvious for a bright person who understand multiplication (or for a caveman who can do multiplication by putting rectangles together, then making rectangles from those rectangles etc.) >>In three dimensions if you have a distorted sphere then it obviously divides space into an inside and an outside. Yes, obvious. >>The inside is obviously contractable to a point, and the outside is obviously contractable to 3D space with a hole in it Again, those things are very far from obvious. What "contractable to 3D space with a hole" means is very far away from "obvious" by any reasonable definition of the word.
- JadeNB 10y agoI really appreciate your patient engagement with the doubters in this thread, but I think that your determination to make your point has led you astray here. > Now 6 has a "smallest" factor of 2, and a "smallest" factor of (1 - sqrt(-5)). As [nilkn](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11955341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11955341) mentioned upthread, if you consider well ordering part of the intuition of the positive integers, then you have (depending on what else you consider obvious) practically pinned down the integers already. This reference to the 'smallest' factor is not just a throwaway, and it sinks this example (why is 1 - sqrt(-5) smaller than 1 + sqrt(-5), for example?). > So you are claiming that the author of the linked article, Prof Sir Tim Gowers, winner of the Fields Medal, Fellow of the Royal Society, doesn't understand multiplication? This gives the impression that math is subject to an appeal to authority, which I think is a shame. The newest student can find the error in the work of the Fields Medallist—though he or she probably won't, and the error he or she seems to have found is more likely to be a concealed subtlety—and to suggest avoiding dissenting on the grounds of eminence gives entirely the wrong idea of how mathematical argument should proceed.