2 ms·
It doesn't say that. What it says is: The fundamental theorem of arithmetic states that every positive integer can be factorized in one way as a p
by ColinWright 10y ago
It doesn't say that. What it says is:
The fundamental theorem of arithmetic states that
every positive integer can be factorized in one
way as a product of prime numbers. This statement
has to be appropriately interpreted: we count the
factorizations 3x5x13 and 13x3x5 as the same, for
instance.
That's not the same thing at all.
- TopologyDough 10y agoI miss quoted the original blog by replacing "has" for "can" and such. But the second sentence of what you quoted is misleading because that's not an correct interpretation of FTA.
- ColinWright 10y ago> But the second sentence of what you > quoted is misleading because that's > not an correct interpretation of FTA. I wonder if this is a language thing. The second sentence says: ... we count the factorizations 3x5x13 and 13x3x5 as the same, for instance. This is giving an simple example of what the phrase "up to ordering" implies. The full statement of the FTA says that the factorisation is unique "up to ordering" and that's exactly what the second sentence is saying. So I still think you are mistaken, and I don't understand why you are disagreeing with what Gowers wrote. Perhaps you could give more detail about why you think he is wrong.
- beagle3 10y agoYou also misquoted "appropriately" as "approximately", making the meaning completely different.